Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

Posts

I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#1

I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

Barry Irby

>Coring system. When it came back it was thoroughly mangled. My Friend ground the cutters on the top surface rather than the cutting edge and completely removed the hardened steel form one and most of it from the other two.

Someone suggested contacting Mike Hunter about putting new cutting tips on them. To make the story shorter, I tried Mike"s modification out today. I have only use the smaller of the blades, but I have to say it makes an amazing difference. If you have any inclination to do this, go for it. Thanks Mike.

A couple of questions. When the system came back, it had been reassembled in new and strange ways. There is a piece of pipe on one side of the restraining bar. Apparently he thought the bar should be fatter. There is tape around the bar and pipe or conduit over the tape. Anybody got any idea how to remove the Pipe? Does the vertical restraining pin come out?

As a matter of curiosity, there are two set screws in the bottom that are threaded up into the vertical "riser", but the riser is heavily welded to the horizontal piece. What are the set screws for? Did they just hold the pieces until it was welded?

And does anybody know what the set screws in the handle are? One of them is missing.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#2

A picture

Carole Valentine

>of this strange contraption you are describing would be helpful. LOL I think of my McNaughton's and I can't for the life of me picture what you are talking about.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#3

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaugh

Barry Turner

>I try really hard to avoid loaning out my tools........or borrowing them from others, because of the potential for uncomfortable situations like this one......and the potential for lost friendships.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#4

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaugh

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>set screws should be 8mm X 15mm.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#6

Rob Wallace

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaugh

Rob Wallace

>Somebody owes you a set of replacement parts...

If someone asks me to borrow any of my tools, I typically say that I would be happy to do the procedure for them, but explain that my policy is to not lend tools that will be used without my supervision.

I think the lesson has been learned....sorry yo hear this Barry.

Rob Wallace

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#7

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaugh

Carole Valentine

>I don't mind loaning my tools to the majority of my friends. Almost all of them subscribe to the policy that they return things promptly and in the same or better condition than when they borrowed them. Of course, maybe Barry's friend "thought" he had improved the McNaughtons. LOL

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#8

Picture of Mangled post

Barry Irby

>Here is the McNaughton post as it was returned. The other side had duct tape on it, but I removed that. It took me a moment to realize this was a piece of conduit on this side and I don't know how to get it off. Does the horizontal bar unscrew or do I pull out the pin on this side.

I suppose I could ask my "Friend" but I might say something I would not be proud of.


img

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#9

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Barry, one time long ago, I started getting text messages from some girl I did not know. They were laced with profanity and ethnic slurs, much in the way certain people of a certain ethnic group talk amongst themselves. She obviously thought I was someone else. I tried calling her several times. Each time she answered the phone, but instead of talking to me, she held her phone up to the group of people she was with, and started yelling, "Why does this person keep calling me!?!" Despite several tries, she would not speak to me so she could find out why I was calling her. She kept going to other people who had nothing to do with the situation. Does this help you out at all?

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#10

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Carole Valentine

>Not like my system. I have the newer post so I can't say if it unscrews or not. Can't imagine why he put that pipe on there to begin with. Personally, I would take it over to him and say "Would you please remove this thing you put on my post? And by the way, you ruined my blades by grinding the top of them and removing the layer of hardened steel. An honorable man would replace them."

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#11

Re: You got it Barry!

Lewis Dodd

>Amen, Amen!

MY Money bought it!! They can either buy it with their money or rent it, Even relatives know better than to ask me!! Now it is my option to offer if I am so foolish, generally it NEVER pays off!

Lewis

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#12

Re: Picture of Mangled post

robo hippy

>The only reason I can figure out for the piece of pipe is that he had the standard set of blades in the big blade gate/fingers. By the way, the support fingers should be 180 degrees from where they are, closer to the wood. You could use the other side of the tool support, but do have your friend fix it right, or maybe not seeing what happened the first time.

robo hippy

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barry, As far as I'm concerned, your friend just bought this tool.He owes you a new one. Period...you're probably lucky he didn't get hurt; you probably would have been sued.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#14

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Barry Irby

>Keith, I am not into confrontation. I would rather take the beating than confront him about this. The fact is I barely know the guy. I was in a garden club with him twenty years ago and then he appeared in the local turning club. So we rarely see each other, but have two parallel interests. We were discussing the coring system and I agreed to loan him mine. He is a well educated Engineer. I took the tool to him and showed him how to use it and sharpen it.

If I loaned it to you and you bent a knife or chipped a cutter, I would expect you to return it and apologize and would accept it if you replaced the damaged part. I would not expect you to keep working on it until you damaged or changed virtually every part. I simply don't get it. He must have disassemble it to put that piece of pipe on it. He ground away all of the hardened tip on one blade and most of it on the other two. There was duct tape on the restraining bar on the opposite side. I took that off and looked at the pipe and thought, I'll deal with that later. Now I don't know how to get it off. I tried to extract the rolled pin but had no luck.

I just don't grasp the thought process that lead to this. Even if you thought the pipe was necessary and you wanted to experiment with it, why not take it off before returning the tool.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#15

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Stuart Johnson

>"I took that off and looked at the pipe and thought, I'll deal with that later. Now I don't know how to get it off. I tried to extract the rolled pin but had no luck. "

This might be a good way to bring the damage to his attention without being confrontational. Give the guy a call and ask him how he put it on and how can you get it off without causing further damage. It is possible he doesn't realize he damaged it and might actually think he improved it.

Re: I posted recently about loaning out my McNaughton

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Picture of Mangled post

Keith Tompkins

>Me either, Barry. BUT, his actions show a great lack of respect for you and the tool you were gracious enough to lend him. I'd be upset enough to ask for a new tool.