Pre-Chat Contribution
charlie belden
>I�ve got a turning club meeting which starts at the same time as tonight�s chat with Betty Scarpino - and I have to go to pay for some stuff I ordered.
S0 - inc case I don�t get back in time - what follows is what I wanted to contribute to the discussion.
=====================
DVM / MD - Craftsman / Artist - Creativity / Synthesis
Many of the advancement in the practice of medicine start, not at the Mayo Clinic and with MDs, but rather at places like the Davis School Of Vetinary Medicine and with DVMs, Doctors of Vetinary Medicine. Organ transplants, bone grafts, joint replacement - the list goes on an on. Yet the credit, publicity, acclaim - and the monetary rewards - go the the MDs - typically the surgeons. But the horizons of medicine are often being expanded by �mere� Vets.
In turning, it�s the �raftsman, predominately the Amateur Craftsman, who pushes the boundaries and expands the field/craft beyond the existing horizon - with new shapes and forms, with new tools, new grinds, and new techniques for removing wood more quickly, more precisely, more easily and with more control, new finishes and post lathe enhancements. Yet the credit, publicity, acclaim - and the monetary rewards - go to the Artist.
Let�s face it, The Big Bucks in the Turning World, the pieces that sell in the Five Figures Range, aren�t bought because they�re made of wood, or because of the tecnhique and skill for making them is appreciated by the buyer - Collectors, Galleries and Museum. The Big Bucks in the Turning World is in pieces marketed as ART, created by an Artist, not a Craftsman.
And THAT may be why AAW and other turning organizations seem to be working on encouraging the value of turning as art - and turners as artists - taking down the wall between Art and Craft
Now if Art and Craft are in fact two different practioners of a field and Craft is one end of The Spectrum and Art is the other end of The Spectrum there must be some Neither Beast Nor Fowl point. At one end you have the FUNCTION dictated piece - at the other - a piece that that has no �practical� function other than to meet a human need - to posses something unique which has value beyond it�s intrinsic value - just wood, just its shape and form.
Somewhere along The Spectrum there�s a mental hurdle for the Craftsman to overcome - internalizing being a Closet Artist or a Self Proclaimed Artist. For many Craftsmen, the terms Art and Artist carry a lot of negative connotations - non-functional, snooty, affectateous, big egoes, unskilled exhibitionist self promoters. It also brings along the need to be Creative - another word Craftsman are ambivalent about - in part because it doesn�t seem to require any specific knowlege, skills or techniques - and in part because �creativity� has already been staked out by �artists�.
Perhaps the divide between Art and Craft, or Craft and Art if you prefer, is the Creativity Thing. �Craft� comes from the need for functional things - Form Follows Function. And �function� implies a meeting a specific physical need - in the case of turning - To Hold Something - be it a back for a chair so it holds you in the chair, a support for a handrail (and a way to hold you on the stairs instead of falling through the gap between the handrail and the open end(s) of the stairs), a cup or bowl for to hold a liquid, a container for holding Dry Goods, a place to hold popcorn, buttered or not, or fruit or nuts or m&m, or a handle to hold something - drawer pulls and finials being versions of �handle�. The Form must meet the demands of its Function - not only in shape and form and size, but also in terms of a finish. That�s a quite constraining set of design criteria (Craftsmen DESIGN things - before they begin making them - sometimes).
Art on the other hand can ignore practicality and functionality - completely. If there is a �design� it�s typically pretty loose and flexible. And freed from the those constraints there�s more �creative� space to play in - and maybe make more money at it.
There�s another element to the �creative� thing - a need every human seems to be born with - to be creative - and which our brains are set up to reward - with endorphins. In earlier days everyone had opportunities to be creative - and innovative - Yankee Ingenuity. As our culture becomes more specialized and more compartmentalized, the connection between effort and results become less and less connected and there are fewer and fewer opportunities for being creative and innovative as more and more of us spend our �working life� literally in compartments - cubicles. We�re losing something important to humans, something we have a built in need for - the lack of which having consequences we may not even be aware of.
Perhaps what�s needed is help with finding ways to fulfill that inborn human need. THAT may be what the book No More Second Hand Art is about - an attempt, albeit couched in academic/psychoanalytical/erudite clothing, to provide methods, means and permissioin to approach and experience being �creative� (I still think it�s actually synthesis) and �artistic� (which I still don�t understand) .
Personally, having been drawing and sketching and painting and sculpting since I was a wee nipper, the idea never occured to me until recently - to give that a name - art - or to think of myself as an artist. Engineering - that took some work. The art stuff - well that just happened - and was assumed as something everyone did. Apparently many if not most other people DON�T - but CAN



