Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

Posts

Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#1

Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

charlie belden

>During Jimmy Clewes demo, he had an english walnut shallow bowl turned on the outside and rather than use just mineral oil to pop the grin and serve as a finish, he asked what the club's favorite finish was. The answer was Deft Sanding Sealer, light sanding and an application of Deft lacquer cut 50-50 with lacquer thinnner.

He sopped the 50-50 on with a paper towel and wiped off the excess - again with a paper towel - talked about finishes (there is no One Perfect For All Woods finish) whilel the lacquer dried - then applied a coat of mineral oil. Let it sit for a minute or two then wiped off the excess.

Club members were slightly aghast! Mineral oil - over lacquer, even cut 50-50?

Does THAT work for you Jimmy?

Don't know if it will or not - this is a first try at it.

Actually looked pretty good - better than just a coat of 50-50.

Clewes then tried the sanding sealer on the inside, hand sanded lightly - and applied a coat of mineral oil. Wiped the excess off after a minute and buffed by hand with a paper towel. The results were better than the 50-50 then mineral oil - and really quite nice looking.

That finish going to hold up? asked an attendee.

"Don't know, but I'll be gone before anyone finds out if it works or not." says Jimmy with a grin.

Now I know that mineral oil is used as a lubricator when buffing out a french polish, with or without rotten stone or pumice. And I know that just mineral oil on a raw wood bowl will pop the grain some - if there's anything to pop. Not sure what mineral oil over sanding sealer or lacquer cut 50-50 does - but it did pop the grain a bit over sanding sealer. How it holds up? No idea.

Anyone used mineral oil over any other finish - successfully? If so, what undercoat?

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#2

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/

nick

>Some oils dry to form a film finish which provides a little protection against dirt, humidity, etc. Mineral oil doesn't dry. It just evaporates very slowly.

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#3

Re:If the surface has been sealed with ....

Jamie Donaldson

>....sanding sealer(I prefer a mix of about 5~10% acetone/90% lacquer)then the MO cannot penetrate to the wood. I can't imagine any reason to use the MO at all in this manner.

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re:If the surface has been sealed with ....

Keith Tompkins

>Me either, Jamie.

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#5

Re:If the surface has been sealed with ....

russ fairfield

>Me neither. It will just lay on the surface. Might as well use motor oil.

However, there is a fast finishing method that is sort of like a friction polish mixed on ther surface of the wood. A sloppy coat of lacquer is brushed on the wood, let set for a couple minutes to soak in, then some of the excess is wiped off leaving it wet. Immediately give it a coat of Watco or similar oil finish. Let that sit for a couple minutes and then wipe it all off either vigorously by hand or with the lathe spinning the wood.

Notice that this finish uses a drying oil. I can speak from experience that Mineral Oil will only lay on the surface as a sticky mess.

Re: Finish - Sanding Sealer/MineralOil, 50-50Lacq/MO

#6

Possible Explanation of Why SS Then Oil Worked

charlie belden

>Note the details of the Sanding Sealer/Mineral Oil schedule.

"Clewes then tried the sanding sealer on the inside, hand sanded lightly - and applied a coat of mineral oil. Wiped the excess off after a minute and buffed by hand with a paper towel. The results were better than the 50-50 then mineral oil - and really quite nice looking."

Note the "hand sanded lightly" after applying the sanding sealer. If the sanding sealer raised the grain at all - and then the surface was lightly hand sanded - there will be SOME grain that isn't "sealed". The "unsealed" grain CAN absorb some mineral oil.

Subsequent wiping of the oiled surface - primarily to remove excess mineral oil - will also slightly abbrade the surface - removing more oil from side/face grain - than from any grain coming up out of the surface.

Though the attached illustration is about popping the grain on a flat board, this may explain the effect produced.

The Devil's In The Details and only after reading responses to my post did I think about the details of the Sanding Sealer, Lightly Sanded, Mineral Oil, Paper Towel Wipe Off/ Abbrade - procedure.

It would be interesting to try this with a water based dye rather than mineral oil and see what happens.

As for the mineral oil on the piece becoming a gummy mess due to lack of a "dryer" - Clewes wiped the surface down pretty well - and in the process may have abbraded off some of the oil ON rather than IN the side/face grain - leaving behind oil in the ends of grain coming up out of the surface.

On the other hand, the perceived effect may have been psychological - a Pro did it - so it must work.


img