Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Vibration noise

Posts

Vibration noise

#1

Lyle Jamieson

Vibration noise

Lyle Jamieson

>Sorry I got into the Jamieson tool noise thread so late. A couple observations. Wood back rests have a trade off. The "Drag" is significant and will decrease your tool control to clean up tool marks. I prefer metal on metal slide with wax helping the fingertip control I want. Many folks have made back rests out of wood and I recommend that they put a metal strip for the boring bar handle to slide on. There should be no vibration with any hollowing process...home built, captured, hand held, whatever. The sound you should hear is a hissing sound of the cut. The vibration can be caused by two problems. One the wood is flexing and two the boring bar is flexing. Both are a NO-NO. Only something bad can happen with that kind of vibration, stop it or risk getting hurt. So its not the noise you should be concerned about its the vibration that's got to stop. I have a new set up, instalation instruction sheet that I have on my web site to insure that the setup is not the problem. This supersedes the outdated info on my DVD. Another resource for you might be to go back over my hollowing article again that is reprinted on my web site. lylejamieson.com I address the vibration issue in detail there. Its all about tool control issues. See if there is something in your cutting method that could stop the vibration.

The back rest should have a safety bar on TOP of the handle and the gap should be large enough to insure there is no binding or drag when you are hollowing. Something like 1/16 inch is what I have on mine.

Re: Vibration noise

#2

Steven Antonucci

Interesting point on friction coefficients *LINK*

steve antonucci

>From Wikipedia:

Approximate coefficients of friction

Materials Static friction,

Aluminum Steel 0.61

Copper Steel 0.53

Brass Steel 0.51

Cast iron Copper 1.05

Cast iron Zinc 0.85

Concrete (wet) Rubber 0.30

Concrete (dry) Rubber 1.0

Concrete Wood 0.62[9]

Copper Glass 0.68

Glass Glass 0.94

Metal Wood 0.2-0.6[9]

Polythene Steel 0.2[10]

Steel Steel 0.80[10]

Steel Teflon 0.04[10]

Teflon Teflon 0.04[10]

Wood Wood 0.25-0.5[9]

I thought you'd appreciate the fact that the coefficient of friction (avg) between steel to steel is higher (0.80) than the coefficient of friction of wood to wood(0.2-0.5). I was going to wax the MDF surface in my rig, but it was actually already slick enough so I never bothered. Now, I know why...

Steve


Wikipedia on Friction

Re: Vibration noise

#3

Re: Interesting point on friction coefficients

Texian

>Good info Steve. And/but note that the force required to slide one of the surfaces in contact is also a function of the surface area in contact and the force normal/perpendicular to the contact area.

Re: Vibration noise

#4

Re: Interesting point on friction coefficients

Stephen Mushinski

>Once the wax on the bars is used, these numbers shown are useless. It slides without any resistance what so ever. The captured bar set up works wonderful. Your wooden setup would work pretty good too by the looks of things. One advantage I do see is your system can go on just about any angle where the bar system sometimes needs to be adjusted.

Re: Vibration noise

#5

Steven Antonucci

C in statics, A in Dynamics :-)

steve antonucci

>Actually, I don't think the force is a function of areaat all. Seems counterintuitive that a larger surface area contact patch wouldn't create more friction, but I'm 99% sure it actually doesn't matter.

When the forces are measured, essentially the "weight" (mass x gravity) creates a downward force. The coefficient of friction creates a resisitive force normal to the weight. based upon the table, if wood-wood is 2-3X more slippery than steel-steel, the block I use would have to be 2-3x heavier than the Jamieson rig just to make up for the coefficient of friction. Doubt that's the case.

Think of it this way. Which would you rather push- a 100# 1' x 1' box of lead made out of steel or a 100# box 3'x3' made with a teflon bottom? The weight and the area go away because it's the friction forces that need to be overcome. Spreading it over an area is actually easier because you don't have to overcome point loads(think about pushing your couch over the carpet on feet vs. sliding a heavy box across the carpet).

Besides, if it had been too "resistive", I would have just ripped two inches off on my tablesaw... :-)

S

Re: Vibration noise

#6

Steven Antonucci

It's not as liberating as you'd think-

steve antonucci

>For someone who freehand hollows, I actually find that stupid thing in the way more than I'd like. It was knocked together as a quick proof of concept, and not meant to be "perfect". If I was going to make it again, I'd make it much smaller in width and with ROUNDED corners (so I didn't bang them while in use). I do not actually use this in hollowing- even though it does work very well- because it was the most sterile turning experience I have ever had.

I now have a laser for it (again, as a prototype), and I will add it to the system when I have a lazy Sunday available (not happening today :-( ).

If you want to make hollowforms with almost no risk and very little skill necessary, supported/captured/laser systems are the way to go. ANYONE can stand there and guide a cutter along the dot, and someday, perhaps we can rig it up to a CNC cutter an say that we made it because we know how to program the CNC lathe...

Steve

Re: Vibration noise

#7

Re: Interesting point on friction coefficients

russ fairfield

>To me, mass, rigidity, and smooth surfaces are more important than how easilly they slide. Steel offers these functions better than wood which is lighter, more flexible, and easily dented and damaged.

Re: Vibration noise

#8

Steven Antonucci

Rigidity as a function of distance

steve antonucci

>As part of load analysis, one of the factors you need to account for is where the support point on the back rest is. The closer it is to the connection point, the fewwer "flexible" joints are needed to deal with and the less important the materials rigidity will become.

Because of the width of the platform, the wooden handle usually only overhangs platform by an inch or so. If I was going to "manufacture these", I would likely make the bar recess into the wooden handle to even further stiffen and reduce the overhang.

With a metal captured secondary support, the width is only 1" or so wide, making the support point almost a foot further back. This could be remedied by making the boring bars "collapse inside the handles when the extra length is not needed.

Mass is somewhat irrelevant. When you have enough of it, you don't need any more. Nicks and dings also don't impact this rig because there is so much surface, each nick is a raindrop in the ocean.

I might just make another prototype with some of the things I've mentioned, just because it was a fun project...

Steve