Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Jamieson-style boring users

Posts

Jamieson-style boring users

#1

Jamieson-style boring users

Pete in Holland, MI

>Hey all -

Starting to get cooler around these parts (SW Michigan) and am spending more time in the basement in the wood shop. Last spring, I build up a Jamieson-style boring system (kept the group up to date on the project) and had "the man" himself come to the house one day to show me how to really use it. Turned a few vessels afterwards, then got pre-occupied in outdoor activities for the summer. As I am getting back into the wood side of my long list of hobbies, the boring rig has been used for 4 vessels in the past few weeks. As I use it more & more, a couple issues are there that I wonder is just me, or are they common with the rig?

1) Chatter in the system being translated to the far right parallel beam support. Is this common? Keeping the bit sharp helps. How much clearance do you guys have between the holder and the parallel bars? Have been wearing ear muffs a lot because of.

2) I built my parallel bars from 7/8" square steel tubing. Are factory units of solid steel? I don't think I am getting any flex in the tube. They are spaced & held together with a couple 1/4" bolts and a stack of washers between the bars.

3) Has anyone tried other types of HHS square tool bits? I have some Chinese "HHS" bits currently, but will be picking up some 5 & 10% cobalt to try their longevity between sharpenings.

4) I assume you want to keep the right hand parallel beam support more so closer to the "left" to reduce the span of the boring system, reducing its ability to flex, thus reducing chatter. True ?

Still having fun & making sawdust. Will have to post some photos later on. Not world-class work yet, but still impresses the natives around here.

Pete

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#2

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

John Lucas

>Pete Not sure I can answer all your questions. Have you checked to see if the cutter is on dead center. Being off will cause the tool to be more aggressive and bounce what I call the outrigger bar.

I don't have a lot of space in the secondary tool rest. All it does is capture the outrigger in the case of a catch or over aggressive cut so it doesn't really have to be that close.

Most chatter I experience is from taking too aggressive of a cut or being too deep for that size bar.

I haven't tried the higher cobalt cutters but have used the #1 Hunter tool which I do use when I have to turn something that needs a cleaner cut.

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#3

Re: I lined the square tube capture..

Jamie Donaldson

>...area with a nylon tape that I found in one of the tool catalogues, but it was long ago and I don't remember which one? It may have been for drawer slides, but really cut down the noise, and enhanced the sliding action as well.

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#4

Steven Antonucci

Wood doesn't make that racket!

steve antonucci

>I am utterly befuddled why folks need to make these things out of metal? Metal makes lots of shrill noises and is great if you are building roll cages where that much strength is required.

I made my rig out of 38 cents woth of parts (I didn't have the wing nut I needed) and 30 minutes worth of work. There is no noise, and the stupid thing works flawlessly. It's sterile (you feel nothing), but it does what it is supposed to do- keep the cutter on centerline!

Picture attached. I have a laser ($3, harbor freight) that I will eventually mount to measure wall thickness, just to say that I did it...

Steve


img

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#5

Denis Putland

Re: Wood doesn't make that racket!

Denis Putland

>Hi Steve

It just to simple!!!! It can not work!!!! Impossible!!!!!!!!

I have a good home built captured system made of metal but I will just have to try something like you have there,it looks intriguing, interesting.

Denis

PS: But it can not work it is just to simple!!!!!! :::))))

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#6

Re: Wood doesn't make that racket!

Pete in Holland, MI

>Ha !

Where were you a year ago when I was pondering on my system ?!? Looks like your system should work great.

I agree with you on the wood & noise transmission aspect too.

Pete

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#7

Re: Jamieson-style. . . Earmuffs! ??

Doc Green

>I read all this about wood screaming and wearing earmuffs, and I'm in disbelief. Does that really happen?

When I started hollowing, I had a few adventures. I soon learned that when a hollowing tool is misbehaving, one or both of two things may be wrong: (1) too much of the cutting edge is engaging the wood; or (2) the lathe RPM is too high.

My main hollowing tools are now ground to a V point, with the angle of the V being around 75 degrees. (It varies.) The tools are advanced into the wood in a direction parallel to one side of the V. (Never in the direction the V points) This allows me to control the depth of the cut, and if it starts talking to me, I ease up.

Of course, for finishing cuts I use tools with a rounded cutting edge, but while doing this I take very light cuts and often present the tool at a considerable negative rake angle.

~Doc

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#8

Re: Wood doesn't make that racket!

john lucas

>Steve I built my secondary rest out of wood. I was in a hurry and at the time had a small lathe so it sat on a wooden stand that sat on the floor. I've used it on mini lathes that way.

When I move to a big lathe I modified it to fit on the bed and fully intend to make a metal one someday but this one works so I haven't built the other one. I've been using this one for about 5 years or more.

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#9

Steven Antonucci

Making the impossible possible every day :-)

steve antonucci

>When I looked at the problem, I figured there were two simple forces to overcome. The first one is "down force" at the tip, which is a function of the amount of tool hanging over the metal rest. You counteract it with length when you hand hold a boring bar. Not much different here, except that there is automatically a counteracting force transmitted through the center of the rest (the weight of the tool). By simply adding my arm weight over top when I cut with it, there is no "down force" to speak of because the cutter is always on center line.

The second force is rotational, or the tendency for the cutter to want to twist downward. Honestly, this force is so small when you are on centerline, you probably don't need to do much, but that's why the board I use is so wide (also, my jointer is only 6"). By having it be wide, it almost acts like a canoe's outrigger.

So if you subscribe to KISS, you probably have all of the materials you need laying around the shop to make one of these. And I think wood is a much better material to use than metal because it doesn't "sing", you don't need any specialized skills to assemble (glue and screw), and it doesn't cost more than my lathe.

Steve

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#10

Re: But Steve, it's not shiny like metal!!!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#11

Re: Wood doesn't make that racket!

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>Nice idea, Steve.

What do you use to hold the boring bar in the board? It's hard to tell from the pic.

Gary

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#12

Steven Antonucci

Close-up of the business end

steve antonucci

>It's a 1/4" x20 nut. I tapped the hole, and then soaked it in CA and retapped. I hand-tighten and then give it a 1/8 turn with a wrench. The bar goes in about 2-3", and you couldn't pull it out with 3 guys.

S


img

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#13

Steven Antonucci

Shiny wasn't in the design spec

steve antonucci

>Neither was cold, or noisy. Free was, and if I could have found a bolt that matched the taps I had, I would have made it for free. I also had a laser pointer pen that I had gotten at a trade show, but the batteries were dead, and it needed 4- $3 batteries, so I bought a new one for $3 instead.

Go figure.

S

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#14

Steve Kubien

So, in theory...

Steve Kubien

>...you could drill different sized holes at each corner to accomodate different sized boring bars. Hmmm, I've got some 3/4" MDF in my shop that is chronically in the way. It would be easy to rig up my laser... Oh, I'm getting excited by this, but I will control that excitement until after Christmas as I've got enough to worry about until then.

Thanks Steve. Expect future questions....

Re: Jamieson-style boring users

#15

Steven Antonucci

Not theory, but exactly what I did

steve antonucci

>You build the platform first to within 3/4" to 1" of the swing of your lathe at centerline, then use the platform with a straight edge clamped to it to drill your bar hole. This way, no matter which bar you are using or it's diameter, you are always on centerline.

I have 1/4", 5/16: 3/8" and a 1/2". The 1/4" bars are O1 steel, the others hold cutters.

Steve