Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Posts

Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#1

Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Joe Pack

>I have been toying with the idea of getting tooling to play with hollow forms. I have looked on-line at the Sorby tools and at the Don Pencil tools, the Sorby being a standard handled tool and the Don Pencil having the option of straight or bent arm handle. I know there are a few different sets out there, but I don't really know the pros and cons of each.

What suggestions or comments do you have on hollowing tools for a mediocre turner who wants to play with hollow forms?

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#2

The JohnJordan tools.

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#3

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Don Orr

>The Ellsworth style straight and angled tip tools are easily fabricated at home. There must be tutorials online somewhere. I have Keltons and Don Pencil tools and like them both, but often go back to my home made Ellsworth style if I have trouble with the others. Easy to make and easy to use.

I don't do a lot of hollowing so this is worth what you paid for it.

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#4

The Kelton hollowers

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I really like the Keltons for hollowing. I own Don Pencil's Scorpion set, several Sorby hollowing tools, and the boring bar and cutters that came with my Monster, but I am most comfortable with how the Kelton hollowers handle. I own three sizes and use them all. I have the 5/16" minis, the 1/2" smalls, and the 5/8" mediums.

I even had adapters made for my Monster so I use my Keltons in it.

keithz

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#5

Dick Hines

Re: The Kelton hollowers

Dick Hines

>I have a Kelton set I use for hand held hollowing. If I was going to buy a new set I would go with the John Jordan set.

I also have a Jamieson captured system. I don't suggest you drop the money for a captured system until you do some free hand.

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#6

Re: The Kelton hollowers

Lance Kanaby

>I have the Kelton Hollowers, 5/8" size and the Woodcut Proforme Hollowers in the 5/8" too. I find both tools easy to use.

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#7

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Barry Turner

>If you have never hollowed before, the Sorby multi-tip tool is a very good place to start. It is very easy to use. I also have the 5/8" Kelton's which I use handheld in a Oneway 18" handle. They are good, but a bit tricky to sharpen. I also have the small John Jordan set, 1/2" straight and curved. They work well and are easy to sharpen. If I had it to do over, I would probably buy the large JJ set instead of the 5/8" Kelton's. Good luck. Hollowing is not nearly as hard as you may have been led to believe.

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#8

Like Cyril said - John Jordan tools

Jeff Willaford

>

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#9

Re: Agree John Jordon NM

Peter Lamb

>

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#10

Rob Wallace

Thumbs-up for the Jordan and Munro Hollowers

Rob Wallace

>Joe:

I also agree with several others - I have been very happy for the past 5 years or so with the John Jordan set of hollowing tools, although I prefer to use it with the Sorby armbrace handle.

I also frequently use the Rolly Munro articulated hollower as well - very efficient cutter and leaves a great surface. I have the older version of this tool and have not used the new, recently re-designed tool, so if you are considering this option, you may want to ask others for their experience with the new Munro tool. I just got the carbide cutter upgrade for the Munro tool from Packards, but have not had the opportunity to try it yet. Many guys swear by this hollowing system. Steve Sinner, one of the gurus of deep hollowing, has adapted a Munro cutter to his captured tool deep-hollowing system. Something else to check-out.

Good luck with your decision!

Rob Wallace

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#11

I agree...Do free hand before captured.

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#12

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Bill Crommett

>Joe : A lot depends on your individual circumstances and your experience. If you are young and strong you can handle the customary hollow form tools advocated here, but if you are old, weak, and shakey like I am you will need to improvise.

I have made a number of outrigger tools with various degrees of bend at the tip which allow me to get in deep and also will allow me to get back into the shoulder of the HF. I am not too proficient on posting pictures on the forum, but if you would like to see some of my bent outriggers tools, let me know and I can post a picture in regular e-mail.

Bill

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

#13

Re: Hollow Form Tool Advice Needed

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Joe, it seems like I've tried them all and I have to say the John Jordan hollowers are hard to beat. The medium and new mini hollowers are my hands down favorites.

Jen