Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Posts

Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#1

Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

charlie belden

>Just got another Lee Treeworks e-mail about new woods they've gotten in. Going through the names I'm convinced that they're following Taco Bell's lead - and just making up names for woods (try finding a ChimiChanga in any latin american country)

Leatherwood

White Top

Corrugata Burl

Coolibah

Horistes

Grey Box Burl

Effusia Burl

and

Gimlet Burl - come on

or

Vasticola Burl (is that from Coca Cola or Pepsi Cola?)

and what the hell is

Bimble Box Burl.

I can sort of understand sawyers and lumber folks using "common names" for the trees they cut up. When europeans came to the new world if a tree looked anything like a tree they were familiar with - that's what they called it - or added American to the front of the name - American Sycamore. Calling a wood sweet gum or red river gum is more marketable I'm sure than eucalyptus.

Great marketing. Not so great when you want to find out some of the working characteristics of one of these "exotic" woods - like its tangential to radial shrinkage ratio for example, or it's specific gravity (needed for moisture meter reading adjustments).

It's hard enough to find the specific gravity of "english sycamore" - which isn't actually a sycamore at all - but a maple. But Euffasia?

These guys are jerking our chains right?

Anyone for some Radiata - at ONLY $34.99 - a pound - shipping and handling not inlcuded?

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#2

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

E.T.

>Exactly. There is a wood supplier in my city that has 3 franchise stores. They sell a wood called "ulmo" in all three stores. In one store the wood looks like a tight grained cherry but in the other store, the wood looks like a coarse grained mahogany. I never did find "ulmo" in any wood catalog. I suspect that someone inthe warehouse made up the name when they unloaded the truck and needed to call it something that could be easily written and typed on an invoice.

I have seen other woods that I know well from past usage with new "made up" names at supply stores

ET

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Bill Blasic

>If you take for example Central America and pick one tree that is through the entire region I would bet that it would have 30 different names. I have a list someplace that shows even in one country the tree may have 6 or 7 names. I don't think anyone is making up names it probably is just the name given by the local folks of that region they are buying from.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#4

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Mike Foster

>I can't speak for the other woods listed, but I've turned wood that I got from a different source labeled Corrugata and Coolibah burl. Coolibah (and I believe corrugata) are one of the many species of eucalyptus trees that grow down under. Who knows about some of the others. Naming woods is also a local thing, and perhaps the local name of the wood is imported with the wood. Rarely do retailers actually give a scientific name for a wood. Ironwood is a great example. I have in my shop Ironwood from Mexico, Vermont and South Africa. Very different woods, but all called locally Ironwood.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#5

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Eduardo Sarmiento

>Here in peru the woodsellers,anything they dont know is call "oak" and there is were you find the great wood and even greater price,ussually 1to 3 dollars a bf,against cedar and mahogany 8 dollars a bd,names wow look at palms they are thousands of species but they are all palms ,rigth?

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Ric Taylor

>I'm not sure it's what you meant to say, but sweet gum and eucalyptus are certainly not the same wood.

Ric

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#7

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Barry Elder

>Charlie, just because you are not familiar with all the different names for Australian woods doesn't mean that they are not factual. One of the things that Jim King pointed out was that the same tree in Peru could have many different names depending on the country, neighborhood, and tribe where the tree was.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#8

Rob Wallace

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Rob Wallace

>Charlie:

This is precisely the reason why I have been advocating the use of scientific names of the wood species (even if only the genus name is given) instead of 'Common" or vernacular names, which differ wildly by region. Suppliers, importers, and retailers all should be including the scientific name of the goods being sold.

Mike:

In my plant taxonomy/systematics class very year, I routinely use the 'ironwood' example for explaining the imprecision and vagueness of the use of common names. College students (and many others) sometimes have an aversion to using the Latin names of plants (or for wood species), but they are the most accurate identifies we can use at present to know exactly what we are communicating about. If my demo on "The Complexity and Diversity of Wood" is accepted by the AAW for the Hartford Symposium, I will speak about this problem specifically, and show a number of examples.

Alternatively, we should begin to move toward international standardization of 'common names' for woods as the bird folks have done, but this is a much bigger challenge. Maybe we should just work toward standardization of turning tool nomenclature - something that we might even have a chance at accomplishing?

Rob Wallace

(Another plant taxonomist - woodturner)

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#9

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Jose Klipstein

>The woods you listed are all genuine, and by the way a chimichanga is a deep fried burrito ... a very popular Mexican specialty!

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#10

Steven Antonucci

More than half of those are "real" Aussie names

steve antonucci

>

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#11

JL

Standardizing wood names - what HERESY!

JL

>Just kidding.

I can just imagine, an IUPAC type commission on standardizing wood names. I think it would be a great idea - I don't know who would support funding it though. It was tough going for IUPAC (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry) when they first started standardizing chemical names. It took them many years - and many of the "common" names are still used instead of IUPAC. A good example is acetone (2-propanone).

I for one would love to see an equivalence table of scientific (taxonomic) names and common names. Maybe you'll publish your article here on WC.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#12

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Charlie, this is one of several reasons why 90% or better of the wood in my shop is maple, cherry, or walnut! Oh yeah, another is that the stuff is free. ;-)

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#13

Does one drink Gimlets from a Burl?

Ron Bauman

>

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#14

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

charlie belden

>Giving the wood sellers/dealers the benefit of the doubt - that they're not intending to deceive customers with exotic names they make up in order to try and get more money for a chunk of wood - it would be nice if they'd provide some minimal info we could use like:

1. The Tangential to Radial shrinkage

Cut a 1" cube - one axis Along the Grain,

weigh it, measure the three dimensions,

dry it, weigh it again and measure the three

dimensions. Put the data in a spreadsheet

and you can calculate the T/R per % MC

change.

2. Hardness

This one's a bit trickier because the hardness

changes with MC

3. Open grain, interlocking grain, etc.

4. Country of origin

5. On an endangered species list

The other possibility is to get a few leaves, a piece of bark large enough to be identifiable, a flower or seed pod and maybe some idea of the basic shape of the tree.

As for Australian woods and names, I was under the impression that most of the trees in Australia are eucalyptus. And I realize that like Acacia, Eucalptus can have a broad range of wood qualities. It's my understanding that one of the qualities of all eucalyptus is that they're all resinous, dense and pretty hard when dry. Which is why they must be milled very soon after cutting - and gum up milling equiptment (hence "gum").

Re: ChimiChangas

Perhaps an Urban Legend, but I saw a documentary on the development of fast food restaraunts and the Texan founder of Taco Bell came up with their deep fried "taco shell" which was cheap, quick to make, fast and easy to fill and could be held and eaten with one hand (while driving?). Much later they added the ChimiChanga to the menu - the name made up because it sounded "mexican" - and kind of cool and easy to remember.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#15

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Katherine Kowalski

>Charlie,

I can assure you that all of the woods you have listed are different varieties of wood and are authentic names. Actually, I really LIKE that they have funny names -- makes them more entertaining to order! Just the other day I bought some Red Mallee, Red Morrell, York Gum, Whitetop, and Bimblebox Burls... (And you might well say "what the heck is Bimblebox???") This last tree with the funny name produces burls with very large holes in the cap, and looks very odd indeed. (I'm going to have LOTS of fun turning it! :-)

In the past I've also bought Coolibah and Corrugatta too...

Here are a couple of sites that specialize in Aussie burls: check them out, you might find them interesting. (I've ordered from both and they have each have great customer service).

http://www.burlsource.com/

http://www.australianburls.com/

I haven't asked, but they may indeed be able to supply you with the information you are looking for. From my experience, Aussie burls ALL tend to be very hard and very dense, but look absolutely GORGEOUS when finished.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#16

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Carole Valentine

>I agree Katherine! It's a lot easier for me to remember Bimble Box Burl than "Eucalyptus populnea" and besides that, the names are fun. The Aussies have some great common names for their woods.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#17

Chimichanga trivia

Jose Klipstein

>The chimichanga was created at the El Charo restaurant in Tucson Arizona when a hurrying waiter accidentally dropped a burrito into the deep fryer. Not sure of the year but I believe 1922 or there about.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#18

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

charlie belden

>So I should expect to see a flyer announcing the arrival of

Pookie Poo Wood

Snookums Wood

Honey Bunny Wood

BunnyWunny Wood

and for the chocolate lovers

WillyWonkaWood?

or

Jack Daniels Wood

Cutty Sark Wood

or

Pinch Haig & Haig Wood?

I'll pass on

Bud Lite Wood

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#19

Ric Taylor

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Ric Taylor

>I don't know about the Jack Daniels, but I would love to have some wood salvaged from the Cutty Sark to turn. What a majestic ship she was.

Ric

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#20

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Carole Valentine

>You forgot one. I found a piece the other day. It's squirrely as heck, takes forever to turn, doesn't like even a razor sharp bowl gouge and the grain runs off in all directions. I've named it Charlie Wood. ;)

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#21

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

Rick_Allen

>Guide to Useful Woods of the World

ISBN - 10 - 1892529157

You might find this book useful.

The book contains information on a little under 300 species. You have to figure there are several thousands of species, but the wood species listed in the book should cover most of the woods which are available for sale in the USA.

There is also a CD which is more than 10 years old but the utility of the CD is great when searching for common names.

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

#22

Re: Wood Suppliers - Making Up Names of Woods

charlie belden

>Carol:

You left out

- internally illuminated

- swivels and rocks, apparently all by itself

- makes noises

- requires two rechargeable AA batteries

(batteries not included)

AND

you have to be a little crazy to turn it!

Interesting this turning thing - and -I must add

- the people who do it.