Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question for woodturning teachers...

Posts

Question for woodturning teachers...

#1

Question for woodturning teachers...

Donna Banfield

>I'm posing this question primarily for woodturning teachers or demonstrators, as they might have encountered this issue, and what if anything they did about it. But I'm also interested in hearing from the other side, you're not the instructor/demonstrator, but have seen or done this before.

I teach at Rockler and Woodcraft. I have had a couple of classes that had one family member pay for the class, and take the class, while another family member stayed for the entire class, watching and asking questions. That second family member did not pay for the class. I'm not talking about a young child/parent situation, but two adults. I didn't say anything, because the store managers did nothing, but they were aware of it.

It seems that the 'family' is getting something that they didn't pay for -- two lessons/knowledge when they only paid for one. Has anyone else encountered this situation? How about those of you who teach at Arrowmont, etc. Does the school allow family members to sit in without paying? When you do private instruction in your shop/studio, how would you handle this? Am I making a big deal out of nothing?

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#2

Well RATS, I screwed up.....

Barry Irby

>I took my son to Arrowmont and paid for both of us. Went to Highland Hardware to See Richard Raffan and Sam Maloof (back when he was alive) and paid for both of us both times.

OTOH, I teach Home Inspectors and one of them brought his wife and did not pay for her. She was a better student than he was.

I have messed this up both ways.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#3

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Carol Reed - home in Strawberry

>I have not had the problem - yet.

However, unless I was being compensated rated on the number of people in the class, it is the manager's problem. If my compensation was computed on the number of people in the class, then I would tell the manager he/she pays according to the number of people in the room, not on who paid.

In my own shop, I only teach one on one. I have had two people ask to come together and pay only one fee. I just gave them my astonished look and said, "Wow! A fifty per cent discount for each of you. What a deal!"

They figured it out.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#4

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

john lucas

>I agree with Carole. I try not to worry about those things unless someone else in the class objects. I figure it's just one more person introduced to woodturning.

It isn't fair but then that falls on the person who is in affect cheating.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#5

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Donna Banfield

>John, that's what was 'sticking with me'. I got me to thinking that it wasn't fair to the students who were paying full price.

I know how I would handle it in my own shop -- just like Carol did, but maybe a little less subtle. But in someone else's classroom, I don't always get to call the shots.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#6

Re: If you don't pay, then you don't stay.

Jamie Donaldson

>How about the liability issue, when a "visitor" is a distraction to the student? I haven't run into this problem when I teach, but could imagine a situation when a minor, especially a female, could be chaperoned by an adult, and that changes the situation entirely these days.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#7

Re: Well RATS, I screwed up.....

Donna Banfield

>Barry, you didn't screw up. Your moral compass points in the right direction.

The majority of woodturners will do the right thing, pay for the time. Most of them understand the value, and not try to get away with something. I have no problem giving away my knowledge; I do it all the time at my turning clubs. But that's the point of joining and belonging to a club. You pay your dues, you give your time, and share your knowledge.

At the end of all my classes I encourage the students to come to one of the club meetings. In the last 3 years, I have personally been responsible for at least 1/3 of the new members in one club alone. But these are woodturners who have a strong moral compass to start with. And they will share their knowledge with other new members down the road.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#8

Re: If you don't pay, then you don't stay.

Donna Banfield

>Jamie, when a minor student wanted to take a class at either store, they were told that they needed to be accompanied by a parent or guardian, who also took the class at the same time (i.e., paid).

I insisted on that, because I didn't want to be responsible for having to babysit/discipline/be the 'parent'. It was never an issue with a parent/minor student, and I've had several young students in my classes.

In my own shop, I would make the same requirement, for the same reason.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#9

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Dick Coers

>I agree. You are a subcontractor to the Woodcraft Store, they send you a 1099. They collect the money, and pay you. I taught here in Peoria, and they paid 1/2 the class fee PER PERSON. It is up to the store to collect all money, and pay accordingly. Now if they just watch, or read, or knit, then no charge of course. You should have alerted the manager before the class started. I always checked off the sign up sheet, and passed out reciepts to students that phoned in the credit card. A good time to check everyone. My beef about teaching there, was the way people or store employee would ignore the prerequisites on registration. Then I had to slow down the entire class trying to get the unqualified student to keep up.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#10

Steven Antonucci

Was #2 turning?

steve antonucci

>If it was a hands on class, I would be a little bit upset. If the local Woodcraft wants to give away something, it shouldn't be your time. Maybe a free lathe makes a good BOGO offer?

If it was a hands on class, but #2 was only observing (even if they were a turner), I would likely not care as much. Even if it was a lecture about some special process or technique, I'd be lenient in "talking with a crowd" or Crowd+1...

steve

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#11

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Donna, I have had people ask if they could sit and watch, and I have invited people to sit and watch. In both cases I have made it clear that they are to sit quietly and not get in the way. This has happened in both my own shop and on the road - usually at Woodcraft. No one has tried to get anything past me yet! I did have one situation in my own shop where one person wanted to turn, and the other wanted to watch with an eye to learning, but not participate. I told them the same thing - watch, and be quiet. Don't get in the way.

Dick, I really feel your pain! I can't say how many classes I had where there was a prerequisite, only to have half the people show up without even knowing which end of the tool was the sharp end! Somehow I was supposed to teach them the terminology they needed to know just to turn the thing on, and then teach them how to turn a bowl, all in three hours. Now, I specialize in taking people who have never turned before, and getting them on the lathe - but not in three hours and in a group of people.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#12

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Lyle Jamieson

>Donna, I have been asked to do that a number of times and I refuse/discourage strongly. I want a lathe per person and everyone turning. This has nothing to do with being a nice person. Its not about your time or money made. Its all about doing whats right for the whole class, and giving your best effort to the class members. All the reasons stated are good but Ill recap.

-Its not safe

-Its not fair to paid participants

-I dont want to have to be rude to the intruder once the class starts but his/her questions would be ignored.

-My attention must be focused on the paid participants.

-The intruder could learn more from my DVD's then from getting in the way.

-The partner of the intruder will be intimidated, influenced, and distracted, not a good plan for either paid or unpaid person.

You are in control of your class its not the store manager's call. Its easy to fall back on the safety issue to ask somebody to leave the room.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#13

Re: Was #2 turning?

Donna Banfield

>Steve, the situation involved #2 observing, but not remaining entirely in the background.

After reading some of the responses, I now know how I will handle this if it happens again. Safety is the #1 issue, and that's a very good reason to ask the observer to step out of the classroom.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#14

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Donna Banfield

>Bill, I cannot imagine ANYONE having the nerve to challenge you! And you're very gracious to allow/invite others to observe or watch as you are conducting a class.

As for how 'green' the student is, I always do an informal poll before we start, to find determine the skill level. I actually like a student who has never turned before -- they've formed no bad habits. They're a fresh slate, and I can get them started right.

Some of my more scary, or frightful situations involved students who learned to turn in high school shop (where they did NOT learn to turn), OR spent 2-3 years trying to figure it out on their own, and developed their own 'dangerous' style of turning. I would often catch them using whatever tool was in their hand, and stab/jab it into the spinning wood, or try to scrape uphill or the wrong direction/against the grain with a bowl gouge -- using the wrong side of the wing on the finger nail or Ellsworth gouge! Now THERE'S a catch for you!

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#15

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Donna Banfield

>Thank you to everyone who responded. Sometimes you get a 'hinky' feeling about something, but you're not sure if it's just 'you' being weird. I guess even though I'm weird, there are good reasons for the feeling that something's just not right.

When it comes down to it, safety will always be my primary concern, for myself and my students. All the other reasons are just as good, but it will be hard for anyone to argue against the safety.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Mike Stafford

>I was doing a workshop for a turning club with 8 students. There were prerequisites that indicated the project was not for beginners.

One of the students came with new tools that needed to be sharpened and no turning skills. He monopolized all the time and made the experience miserable for everyone involved because when I was working with someone he would be standing there saying, "When you get a chance I need your help?" He ruined multiple pieces of wood and generally ruined my day.

At the end of the day I politely told him he needed to take a basic turning skills class and that this class was not for him.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#17

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well Donna, it doesn't happen often, unless my children are involved. ;-) They don't seem to be too scared of Dad most of the time. I actually prefer completely new students too, but getting into a class of four or six of them and having to define things like headstock, tailstock, live center, etc, and then send them home with a finished bowl in three hours really pushes it.

How some of these people survive in real life is beyond me. I have had cases where I have waved a live center under someone's nose, contrasted it with a spur center, told the what to do as well as what NOT to do, and the next thing I know, there is a spur center in the tailstock! It's like they just turn off their brains. Then there are the ones who listen, and things just go smoothly. I had a student like that last week. He had never turned, with the exception of once or twice back in the early 60s. But he listened, did what I asked, and it was a very pleasant day for both of us.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#18

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Jim Rutten

>OK. A message from the other side of the room. First let me say that I have NEVER brought my wife to someplace without paying for her (i.e. symposium or whatever). The problem is my note taking ability is atrocius. I am the guy at the demo with his mouth hanging open watching for 15 minutes while my wife takes copius notes. She is even a talented sketch artist and many is the time I have referred back to her notes on something we had seen at a symposium. I have been to several classes where I wish my wife had been there taking notes because of the furious pace of the instructor. Would I like to take her to class with me? Absolutely. Might she ask good and relevant questions of the instructor for clarification? Yep. She has been around the nomenclature long enough she could talk with anyone about woodturning. Would she EVER pick up a gouge and actually use the information she's gained in class? Not so far and I've been doing this for several years. So I gotta ask you, what's the harm?

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Lyle Jamieson

>Jim, Its not your wife that needs to get it, its you. So its you we need to work with, sorry but in my opinion she would be a distraction to both you and me. You will have the tendency to rely on her notes and skip over an issue that was not clear to YOU and possibly not ask a question since you can read about it when you go home. I want YOU to understand the process and techniques right then and there so you can keep up with the rest of the class.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#20

Re: The other side - kinda

GalenV in Iowa

>Donna,

Being new to turning attending the AAW Symposium in Albuquerque was a BIG event for me. I recognized up front the registration fee was paying to attend the demostrations and AAW membership, as the trade show and gallery were all listed as open to the public.

I was totaly surprised that the attendies were not monitored in any way and I felt like anyone setting next to me could have just as well walked in off the street. I expected to have someone confirm who I was and if I really "belonged" there.

Yes a little voice in the back of my mind said you are a chump for paying. The better part of me thought I got to see a lot of top notch turners for the money!

I assume the demostrators were paid a fixed fee for this event and not by head count. I'd feel like the shorted one if I had to sit in the back row if those in the front walked in.

Galen

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#21

Re: Several times I have had husband/wife....

Jamie Donaldson

>..."teams" take week long classes at the Folk School, and to keep order I move them as far apart as possible. I know how tag teams work, and separation usually gains their individual attention without so much translation! (;-D)

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#22

Re: Galen- your ethics as a responsible adult....

Jamie Donaldson

>....are reflected in the fact that you did pay full admission price rather than sneak in without a nametag. Laws are passed with the expectation that society will voluntarily obey them, to maintain order without constant policing being necessary, creating an invasion of our privacy.

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#23

Steven Antonucci

Agree with seen and not heard

steve antonucci

>I run some of the club functions, and I refuse to collect any of the money involved. I assume that most of my club members know me well enough by now that they will get their money's worth from any program that I put together, but I know that from time to time, I get stragglers.

During one of the programs, one of my "stragglers" (i.e. non-paying club members) started carrying on a distracting conversation with one of the payees. I stopped the program and waited for this person to recognize that I was annoyed at them, and shortly later, they left. Do I want to be policing the room for paid attendees? No thanks. Will I deal with someone who is disruptive? You betcha. The backside of a gouge handle makes for an awesome gavel...

I don't think you want a concrete rule for all situations. Part of demonstrating and teaching successfully will be in your ability to adapt to a situation. My read on your class was that it wasn't a big deal to have this person present, and I'd always look at it as an opportunity to make another connection.

Not everyone fits a Procrustean Bed... (you'll have to look it up :-)

steve

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

#24

Re: Question for woodturning teachers...

Bill Neff

>My other obsession is bonsai and the local club will have a Master's weekend twice a year where a bonsai master artist is brought in for a weekend of workshops. The attendance is usually limited to around 15 participants so that each person gets the proper attention from the master for the tree(s) brought in. There are also a limited number of "Observer" slots for a lesser $$ amount. The observers are just that. They can watch, walk around listening, but are not allowed to ask questions, work on trees or visit with others. If you're a distraction, you're asked to leave. Of course from my experience bonsai people have much bigger egos than turners do.

Bill