Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Cost vs. utility

Posts

Cost vs. utility

#1

Ellis Walentine

Cost vs. utility

Ellis Walentine

>I posted this on the main board, but it is certainly appropriate in the turning, too...

In a recent thread on the main board about Bridge City Tools, Brent Smith brought up an issue that lurks in every tool purchase: cost versus utility. My sense is that our primary criterion when buying a tool is utility. We need a tool that accomplishes a particular task. From there, it seems the criteria are all over the map. Some people buy adequate tools and take pride in making them work. Others buy fancy or highly engineered tools because they appreciate the feel or the engineering or some other characteristic of the tool, or simply because they can afford it, so why not buy the "best" or most expensive one available?

What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

Just curious...

Ellis

Re: Cost vs. utility

#2

Re: Cost vs. utility

Marc Phillips

>Looking back on my own tool purchases, I would have to admit to falling for the lure of "that turner uses one, and he/she does great work, so I want one" .... especially if a particular turner posts on a forum or points out a particular tool on their video. The good news is that usually works out for me.. Cost enters into the picture for me when you get to the hollowing rigs.... the lasers, etc.... too much for because I simply do not do a lot of hollow forms. I probably would if I could afford one of those rigs!

I guess, for me, it boils down to my personal trek along the turning road... as I progress, my needs progress also and if I want to keep getting better, and a tool is holding me back because of it's inadequacies, then I will buy a better tool.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#3

Overwhelming Tool Lust

Bob Macgregor

>Except as rationalizations, neither money nor utility have much to do with it most of the time.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#4

Re: Cost vs. utility

Greg Haugen

>Depends on what tool. In my opinion, some tools or better yet some applications almost any tool would be sufficient. For example, parting tools. There are a few that may perform better in certain widths but for the most part, parting tools are parting tools. The surface they leave usually isn't a "finished" surface (with the exception of fluted tools) so further work is needed and it's a tool of necessity. Gouges to me are a different story, to a point. I'm more concerned with the business end of the tool and not the handle. If I don't like the handle, I'll make my own. I'll pay for any Thompson or upper end Sheffield gouge before I'd accept a free "china" gouge. Is the steel's quality or flute design "cost or utility"? Depends on who you talk to, for me it's both. There are also specialty tools that are incredibly valuable to me. I wouldn't make boxes or small hollow forms without a couple of Hunter tools.

There are some applications I prefer to have the best available and there are some applications where "a tool is a tool".

To me, at least with turning the cost element is related to the "utility" element. A gouge will cost more with higher quality of steel so that's the cost, but the utility is the better steel, better edge capabilities, etc. A carbide tool will cost more than a HSS tool, but the superior finish on the wood and ultra razor sharp edge is the utility.

Outside of turning, there are more applications where to me, a tool is a tool. My corded drill in the turning shop is a cheap Ryobi, not an expensive Milwaukee or Dewalt. My dust collector is a Shop Fox with aftermarket 1 micron bags upgrade, not a Delta or Powermatic unit.

My answer, depends on the tool and it's application.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#5

Re: Cost vs. utility

Cyril Griesbach

>I'm inclined to agree with Greg...function coupled with value.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#6

Steven Antonucci

I think that BCT thing is sweet!

steve antonucci

>If I made things where having one of those BCT things made it easier, I'd definitely consider buying one. To have a tool as sweet as that and not use it is sort of a crime...

To answer you question, buying tools is somewhat necessity vs. desire for me. If I need something, money is no object. If I want something, I go through a hard qualification of alternatives. Money always can be spent, but at the expense of something or someone else. The question becomes one of governance. Will this purchase enable me to do something that perhaps helps me recover the cost at a later date? Is this item going to be partially financed by something it replaces?

I buy the best that makes sense, and rely on skill after that...

Steve

Re: Cost vs. utility

#7

I enjoy using quality tools ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>so I try to buy quality tools. Yes, I have a nice collection of Thompson tools. I want my students to enjoy them too, so I am taking a lot of them down to John C Campbell Folk School in a week and a half for them to try and in some cases, to purchase. I'll have Thompson 1/4" detail gouges that they may purchase. And they may try my Thompson skews and gouges, along with some other goodies.

I wanted a good lathe and I bought a Robust.

At the NC Woodturning Symposium I bought a great tee shirt from Ruth Niles, "I'm one tool away from divorce". ;^D

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Cost vs. utility

#8

Re: Cost vs. utility

Don at Central Illinois

>I have always tried to buy the best tool that I could afford, at that time. I enjoy quality, but if I can't afford it, it is useless. That's why I'm still turning on an old, purchased used, Delta lathe instead of a Vega, Powermatic or Jet (yet).

Re: Cost vs. utility

#9

Re: Cost vs. utility

Ruth Niles

>When I started turning (1989), I bought strictly utility and cheap, Craftsman with a Craftsmen monotube lathe. At that time I did utility turning and didn't have $$$.... : )

Now I buy quality tools but I'm far from a tool junky. Both cost and utility are determining factors. I tend to use whatever tool is in my hand for as much as possible, not because of pride in making one tool do more, I'm just a lazy turner. I buy a new bowl gouge (only Thompson tools) when the flute on the old one is embarrassingly short.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#10

Re: Cost vs. utility

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I love using good quality tools but more often than not buy middle of the road to justify the purchase. When I make a purchase decision it is typically based on three things; need, quality, price. Usually in that order too. Like many, in the beginning I made purchases of a cheaper quality tool based solely on price (and lack of knowledge) and regretted it when I spent the money again on a better version of the same.

Jen

Re: Cost vs. utility

#11

ebd

Re: Cost vs. utility

ebd

>Buying anything I always think about cost vs utility. I buy the least expensive tool that will do the job to the standard I require. That said, I always buy at least one cut above what I think I will need. I've been poor in my younger years. One thing I learned was that spending money on a GOOD tool was never a bad choice. I'm just careful which tools I buy. I really have to justify the need.

For the last few years I've coveted a planer. I'd like a DeWalt 735. I simply can't justify it. I've got other ways of dealing with thicknessing in my turning and I don't need to plane rough cut. I simply don't have enough need right now to spend that kind of money even though I have it. I keep checking on Craigs List and sooner or later I'll find a 3 knife planer that will do what I need at a price I can justify. Till then I've got plenty of work arounds.

Note to Steve A. - I have 2 of the BCT universal tools. You would be surprised how useful they can be on the interior of regular bowls and boxes, not to mention undercut lips, particularly with exotic grains. Highly recommended. P.S. I don't do hollow forms.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Cost vs. utility

Steve Kubien

>I buy what I need and will stretch that purchase as far as I can. Without getting political, there is another factor...where does it come from and who is selling it? I buy Thompson tools because they are very good quality at a fair price and Doug is an independant manufacturer. I love dealing with independants (that is why my good handplanes were by Steve Knight) when I can.

Steve

Re: Cost vs. utility

#13

Re: Cost vs. utility

Dave Moore

>Yes, it's utility first for me too, but what does that mean? Maybe not the same for everyone.

For me it's a little more than simply "does it work?"

There have been plenty of times when I needed to get something done and didn't have the "optimum" tool to accomplish it, so I have just made do with whatever I could cobble together from what's at hand.

But when it comes to the bread and butter main tools, rather than just this or that smaller hand tool (chisels, spokeshave, gouges etc etc) I go for the best I can find.

For things I use constantly all day like the tablesaw, the lathe and so on, I want heavy and powerful. I want no vibration, I want quiet, smooth operation. (there's an important safety factor here too)

I don't want things breaking and parts flying off. I don't want to be fiddling with replacing bearings, filing off weld spatter or sharp casting edges and all that baloney.

I still buy old carbon steel stuff whenever I see it in flea markets and such,a dollar apiece often as not, then grind them to something I'll use only rarely. Some of the older Sears stuff was pretty well made, and it works great for those "if only I had something shaped like this" moments.

I, too, tend to buy from smaller "mom and pop" outfits wherever it's possible, but that's more personal and political than anything else, and not a requirement for getting satisfactory performance.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Cost vs. utility

Dick Hines

>My father told me a long time ago to buy the best tool you could afford. I am just replaceing tools as I wear them out. I do try to get all the use I can out a tool. I have been known to grind the top of gouges flat so I could still get then into the grinding jig.

I don't buy every tool that comes on the market. I would be living in a box if I tried to buy them all.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Cost vs. utility

Dick Hines

>I could be a tool junkie very easy. I love the feel of good new tools but I have gotten to the stage where I am only relpaceing the worn out tools, mostly. I have been known to grind the top of a gouge flat so I could get into the grinding jig.

I did buy a new 1/4 detail gouge from Doug Thompson in Greensborb. Wish I had gotten one sooner.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#16

Steven Antonucci

What is a "Universal tool"?

steve antonucci

>Looked on BCT website, couldn't find it?

S

Re: Cost vs. utility

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Cost vs. utility

Keith Tompkins

>HI Ellis, I but the best I can afford, then try to take great care of it. I cringe when I see a $6,000 lathe plastered with finishing materials and covered with rust and chipped paint. I'd like to buy a new table saw, my current one was made in 1952. Don't really need it, but a Powermatic 66 would be nice! I finally picked up a Primus smoothing plane; always wanted one but couldn't afford it...purely an emotional thing. Generally, I feel old tools are superior to new; most of my hand tools are antiques. I enjoy making tools as well, especially with fancy wood handles. Most of my turning tools are M2 steel, and I often demonstrate with old Craftsman tools just to prove a point...it's the technique, not the manufacturer.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#18

Re: Cost vs. utility

Barry Turner

>I always buy the best tools I can afford. I've never found myself saying, "I wish I had bought a cheaper tool or a lower quality tool." With that said, I also try not to buy tools unless I have a specific and immediate need for it. Beyond that, I also need to have an expectation of a future need for the tool beyond the project at hand.

About eight (8) years ago, I was at Choice Woods in Louisville, KY talking to Clay Johnson. This was just after I had first started turning. I was having trouble hollowing boxes and was asking Clay's advice on a new hollowing tool. He asked if I had a 3/8 spindle gouge. I told him that I did. He said that was all I needed and proceeded to go into detail about how to hollow a box with a spindle gouge. What he told me was, "I will be glad to sell you a new tool, but what you really need to do, is go home and learn how to use the ones you already have." I try very hard not to buy a new tool, if I already have a tool that will do the job.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: Cost vs. utility

Mike Stafford

>I guess I am more of a utility guy. That said, unfortunately I buy a lot of tools trying to find the ones that do the job the way I want it done. I have never been one to who rushed out and became a Fes"fool".

I had heard about how great Thompson tools were from a number of my friends and I resisted the urge to buy another tool when I had some that were doing the job just fine. Finally I decided I would give them a try and the Thompsons are superior to what I had. They did the job better than what I was using before. Why, I believe the flute shape seems to be better for the way I use the tool. So, even though the Thompson gouges have proven they hold an edge longer the real reason I like them is that they do the job I want them to do better.

My tools are a mishmash of brands because of my desire for utility. I don't think a more expensive tool will make me a better turner. Only practice and patience will do that.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#20

Re: Cost vs. utility

Bill Crommett

>---wil I live long enough to really learn how to use it ?

Re: Cost vs. utility

#21

Re: Cost vs. utility

George Guadiane

>I read the whole thread before I started typing.

When I started turning I couldn't really afford ANYTHING, so I bought the fewest, cheapest tools I could find. I made LOTS of "detail scrapers" for close/small work out of garage sale purchased screwdrivers... Never spent more than a dollar, I still use many of them and I like them because I can grind a shape and keep it if I like or regrind to something I like better.

A few years ago, my mother gave me a check that I used to pay some bills and buy my Mustard Monster ("Big Momma"),thinking that would be the last lathe I would ever need. I also bought a Talon chuck and much later, a Stronghold chuck, a couple of "better" gouges and some eBay special Sorby Kangaroo gouges.

More recently, I had some turning FINANCIAL success (boy is THAT nice) and that allowed me to be MUCH more generous with my tool buying...

I STILL tried to spend like a poor man, only buying what I thought would best help me produce the best finished products.

My big purchases have been the Randy Privet Monster articulated arm hollowing setup and a handful of handles for the Thompson gouges I felt were well worth owning... There was more, but the point is, I selected pretty carefully, based on "need" then usefulness.

So far, I don't feel like I went crazy, in fact, I use what I bought pretty much every time I turn.

Cost was IMPORTANT when I didn't have money, and important in my decision making when I did, but with the ability to buy came scrutiny and selective purchasing.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#22

Re: Cost vs. utility

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I try to buy the best I can afford, in 1980 the entire shop looked like a sears catalog TS, BS, lathe, drill press, sander and all the small power tools. Everything was upgraded but most everything for woodworking/woodturning is made in China so you try to find the best of what's on the market. Metalworking tools are made in America so the choice is easy.

I'm a tool hoard but it doesn't bother me one bit to give stuff away.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#23

ebd

Re: What is a "Universal tool"? *LINK*

ebd

>Go to this link.


BCT Supercut Universal Tool

Re: Cost vs. utility

#24

Similar to Rolly Munro's

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>I have not seen thi tool in action, But I saw Rolly Munro's last spring in Saratoga and does a beautiful job on the outside or inside of a vessel. He only uses one tool, no arsenal in his demo.

Re: Cost vs. utility

#25

Re: Cost vs. utility

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Utility comes first and usually I don't buy until there is a job at hand to justify the purchase.

My very first lathe tools and most of my hand tools came from several rust outlets and I still have and use 3 I got in a bundle for $5.00 (1977), a 1 1/4" skew, a 1 1/4" shallow gouge and a 3/8" bedan, The skew and gouge are made of cast steel, so that dates them back to the 1850's or so, before the electric furnace, made in Sheffield. They take a beautiful edge, maybe the best of all my tools, but it does not last as long as some of the new alloys.

I love to make tools myself, but at some point I decide not to do so, but by then I had a bunch of cheap HSS that I planned to grind to special shapes. So I decided to buy the best I can afford, to me this meant Doug Thompson's, first of all they are good, and just as important they are made right here in the USA, by an individual, not a huge corporation.