"No More Secondhand Art" revisited
Ed Moore in SW VA
>I have finished reading "No More Secondhand Art" by Peter London. At no time does it address creativity versus copying directly. It does make a case against copying implicitly by examining creativity in many ways and extolling its virtues. It does say, in so many words, that copying the style of someone produces lifeless and dull work. To elaborate, the book suggested that if I were to try to copy John Jordan's hollow forms and style the results might be fine technically, but they would lack life and "oomph", unlike John's work. The implicit message then was "Don't waste your time copying."
For me the book may be summarized by the phrase "Don't be afraid to expand your horizons and to dream creatively." In today's jargon it would probably be, "Think outside the box", but I have come to dislike that trite phrase. London's approach was much deeper than that and he employed different exercises to help one learn to create and dream. These exercises were themselves creative, yet inoffensive, and some were more touchy-feely than I can deal with.
I wrote earlier that I might read the book again. At this point I feel that I have extracted that portion of the book that might benefit me and I may not have sufficient discipline to wander down that path again. I am glad that I read the book once, which may suffice.
Respect the bandsaw,
Ed



