Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

"No More Secondhand Art" revisited

Posts

"No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#1

"No More Secondhand Art" revisited

Ed Moore in SW VA

>I have finished reading "No More Secondhand Art" by Peter London. At no time does it address creativity versus copying directly. It does make a case against copying implicitly by examining creativity in many ways and extolling its virtues. It does say, in so many words, that copying the style of someone produces lifeless and dull work. To elaborate, the book suggested that if I were to try to copy John Jordan's hollow forms and style the results might be fine technically, but they would lack life and "oomph", unlike John's work. The implicit message then was "Don't waste your time copying."

For me the book may be summarized by the phrase "Don't be afraid to expand your horizons and to dream creatively." In today's jargon it would probably be, "Think outside the box", but I have come to dislike that trite phrase. London's approach was much deeper than that and he employed different exercises to help one learn to create and dream. These exercises were themselves creative, yet inoffensive, and some were more touchy-feely than I can deal with.

I wrote earlier that I might read the book again. At this point I feel that I have extracted that portion of the book that might benefit me and I may not have sufficient discipline to wander down that path again. I am glad that I read the book once, which may suffice.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

Keith Tompkins

>Ed, I've read this, and many other "art" books; this is an area of interest to me. The reader should consider WHO the author is trying to reach: the aspiring artist. Not so much the "weekend warrior" hobbyist, but those who are considering art as a long-term career. For someone with a mild interest, copying other's work is the fast-track to improvement. It's relatively easy to look at a beautiful piece of art and then copy, or draw influence, from it. In fact, that's the way most woodworkers learn...looking at plans, or using good work as a starting point. Not so easy to create from the heart, however. But to truly succeed as an artist/craftsperson, one must learn to put a piece of themselves into the work, and the potential buyer must connect with the work on some level. I use a musical analogy in my design classes....Lets say I'm a very talented musician, and am heavily influenced by the Beatles. In fact, I can perform all their works FAR BETTER than they ever could. But, it's not my stuff....No matter how good I am, I will always be in their shadow. To really succees in a music career, I will have to develop my own recognizeable style that expresses my own life experiences, tastes, likes or dislikes, etc. Sometimes it takes a bit of soul searching to discover the artist inside.

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#3

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

Ed Moore in SW VA

>This book is all about soul-searching.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#4

Ellis Walentine

I hope you will be there for the guest chat... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>... on November 18, when Betty Scarpino will be our special guest. She's the one who suggested London's book as an inspiration for new creative work. I just got my copy yesterday and haven't read it yet, but it sounds like a good one.

Hope to see everyone there on 11/18 for our chat!

Ellis


Guest Chat Announcement -- Betty Scarpino, Nov. 18

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#5

Re: I hope you will be there for the guest chat...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ellis, I haven't been able to get on WC chat line lately. When I try it locks up my PC and I have reboot.

Wally

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#6

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

charlie belden

>If the book is written for aspiring professional artists, it seems to me that a good book on self marketing and self promotion would be more beneficial than getting into Freudian/Jungian psychiatric therapy. Study Dale Chihuly and Garry Knox Bennett or P.T. Barnum - or Prince, the artist formerly known as Prince, Prince.

The author seems to believe that all aspiring artists are insecure, frightened, sensitive or hypersensitive people with very fragile egos and very low self esteem. If so, this book may help them - 'til they encounter the real world of galleries and exhibitions and "shows" - along with art critics, art columnists, agents, lawyers, collectors and the general public. And that typically only comes after years of working in a design firm or an ad agency or Hallmark or the like, or as a freelancer for magazines - all requiring "creating" what the client wants - not the externalizing of deep feelings and getting in touch with your inner/ true self - or the true self you want to become.

If the goal of the target audience is someone who aspires to becoming the next Andy Warhol (a true master of self promotion and marketing) - take up basketball. You have a better chance of being an NBA star - even if you're under 6'6".

At page 118, I'm running out of pencils for making notes in the margins - very very few of which are "NOTE: Interesting!".

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Charlie, the problem with working in such fields as ad agencies, or any other field that requires satisfying customer demands is that you learn to produce what the customer wants, or what the boss wants, NOT what you want. This environment, on a certain level, tends to stifle, not encourage ,creative thinking. I spent twenty years building what designers and architects conceived and planned....I learned to absolutely hate what I was doing. After twenty years, I was stuck on a treadmill. It's not easy to break away and do the things you really want to do....especially when you have a growing family!

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#8

Vocations and Avocations

charlie belden

>If you're very lucky your vocation and avocation are the same. If not, there's no reason to not have an avocation to provide what the vocation doesn't.

What I was trying to get acrossed is that even a very talented, self confident, great self promoting writer, musician, painter, sculptor . . . is probably going to need to write what they think is absolute crap, play Louie Louie - for the three thousandth time, paint cute kitties for greeting cards or make masters for slip molds to make ceramic pieces elderly ladies and little kids can paint and have fired - to keep forever and ever.

And if a meany critic writes something unflattering or uncomplimentary about your work - and you cry for weeks and it takes years of psychoanalysis to regain even the semblence of a feeling of self worth - find another way to make a living - and find some other means of meeting your need to express your inner feelings 'cause making a living, from the get go, as an artist probably isn't in the cards.

If, on the other hand, you're looking for some means of externalizing thoughts and feelings in some art medium - this might be just the book for you and has some theraputic value.

Re: "No More Secondhand Art" revisited

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Vocations and Avocations

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Charlie, I think the trouble with having the same vocation/avocation is that the line between the two becomes blurred, then erased. Many people start out with an interest, then attempt to make it their source of income. People always said to me "Wow, you are so lucky to work at what you love!" Right. Who wants to come home after 10 hours covered in dust and start another woodworking project? I think the lucky (?) ones are those who can create the things they want without outside influence, and manage to make a living at it. That takes some vision and lots of self promotion. I think you are correct, most artists make what will sell out of necessity; too many never get past that point and become disillusioned.