Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

McNaughton Cutter question

Posts

McNaughton Cutter question

#1

McNaughton Cutter question

Barry Irby

>I loaned my McNaughton system to an acquaintance. He kept it several months and dropped it off at my shop. When I looked at it, I was astounded that he had completely disassembled and put it back together in a very strange ways. I put it back together correctly and put it away. He had taped the sharp ends. I took this to be a good thing.

Today I used it for the first time since it was returned. The cutter dulled almost instantly. I sharpened it and it dulled again. This is a pretty snarly piece of walnut, but it nearly knocked the end off the sharp end.

I finally looked at the cutter closely and realized he had ground the top surface. On this cutter he ground the hardened surface insert completely away. On the others, what is left appears to be very thin, maybe a 1/32"

I have the "standard" set, Its the middle one that is ruined. It cuts about a 10" bowl.

What can I do? Can somebody silver solder or braze a new insert on it? Can I order a single knife? Any idea how long the others will hold up with half the insert thickness ground away?

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#2

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

john lucas

>Barry You can have someone silver solder or braze a HSS cutter on it and then grind to shape. You can also have Mike Hunter put one of his carbide cutters on the tip. I have limited experience with these but man do they cut better than the original.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#3

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

Carole Valentine

>Barry, you can order single knives. Better yet, have your "friend" order it!

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#4

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

robo hippy

>Two choices, like said before, Mike Hunter can put a new tip on it. I had him do one for me. I prefer a square cutter, which you can turn 180 degrees when it gets dull, not the long pointy ones. Or your friend should get you a new one. You did tell him to sharpen only on the face didn't you? I don't think there is a lot of difference in how the carbide tip or the standard tips cut, but the carbide does stay sharp longer even though you can't resharpen it. About a toss up between which is more cost effective. I do like the tips on the Woodcut system, but don't know if you can buy them. I had some carbide tips brazed onto some old blades of mine, and they just didn't seem to cut right, but need to experiment. The tips do need to be tapered, wide in front (3/8 inch), and narrower in the back (1/4 inch). I know you can get single blades from Craft Supplies, don't know if Lee Valley or Woodcraft sell the singles.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#5

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

don lewonczyk

>That is exactly why I don't loan my tools out!! Sure in my shop but not out the door. I can't afford to replace my tools once I finally get them. That was real nice of your (friend)? to tape up the sharp end of your cutters so as not to damage them. I hope you realize that if he comes by again for something else to screw up he'll leave empty handed and maybe a boot in the pants as he goes out the door. Just my way of dealing with dipsticks. Hope you get this resolved, if not I'm for hire!!!! DonL

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#6

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Check the local tooling sharpening services. I take my saw blades to a place like this and they replace chipped/missing carbide teeth, so it would probably be just as easy to replace your missing cutter tooth if you could explain what it should look like.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#7

Send them to Mike Hunter *LINK*

Greg Haugen

>Barry,

I'd recommend sending the set or at least your most used knives to Mike Hunter and have them tipped with the new carbide tips. I was the first person to test his carbide tip on an actual McNaughton knife. I was really, really impressed with it. It was even tested on a piece of dried mesquite and it cored it like it was butter and didn't drift at all. They tracked a lot better than the standard knives and were really effortless. Johannes Michelson uses the same Spear shaped/triangular tips on his new tool for coring off sections out of the his turned hats, with a straight knife style of tool. I'd spend the extra money instead of having a tip brazed on-that doesn't make much sense to me since you could simply unscrew a machined and tapped tip to rotate it or replace it instead of the going through the troubles of brazing or replacing the knife. You've got the knives already-why just throw them away, you've gotten them worn in nicely-why start over with new knives. Just get them re-tipped. Give Mike a call/email and see what he can do for you.

I don't work for Mike in any way, just a happy customer with his tools and turning kits.

Greg H.


Hunter Carbide Tools

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#8

Thanks, and......

Barry Irby

>You should see what the cutter does without the hardened tip. Think lead. You press it into the cut, a little dust flies and then it won't cut. The tip went from a diamond point to round in about 0.2 seconds.

I will contact Mike Hunter later today and see what he will charge. It would be nice to have them fixed, but man, this expense could not have come at a worse time.

When I loaned them to my "friend" I actually took them to his house, set them up on his lathe and showed him how to use them. Explained about the cutter height and whatever. Took him a diamond hone and showed him how to use it. Never in a million years did I think he would "re-engineer" this thing.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#9

I just spoke to MIke......

Barry Irby

>Don't post anything bad about Mike, he reads this stuff. He had read this post and knew who I was when I called. I've never met him in person, but he is a heck of a nice guy over the phone. I will be sending him my most damaged knife and he will be putting a new tip on it. Then if that works as well as I hope, I will send him the others.

Thanks for the help, Mike.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#10

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

Lance Kanaby

>Hello Barry: I am sorry to hear of your bad experience of loaning your tools out to someone who did not know how to use them. I was alwasy taught that if I borrow something it will be returned in the same or better shape. I would ask this person to replace the tool that they ruined and remember that in the future not to loan out your tools. There is an old Jewish saying that goes something like this; cheese is chees, but it still costs money. I know that there is a lot lost in the translation, but I think you get the idea.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#11

Denis Putland

Re: Awe Come on fellows

Denis Putland

>what kind of world would this be if we did not lend , give or help ones neighbor or friend!!!!!!!!!!

I thought we were/are a community of sharers???

So it might cost you something, friendship or neighborliness is not free!!!!!!

Do not mean to high jack the thread but this thread does include some negative comments along these lines.

Denis

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#12

Re: I just spoke to MIke......

Greg Haugen

>Mike is one of the nicest guys around. His incredible tools and turning kits are icing on the cake. :-)))

Enjoy it.

Greg H.

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Thanks, and......

Dick Hines

>That's what you get for loaning your tools to Harry. Like he needs to use some one elses tools. LOL

Re: McNaughton Cutter question

#14

Well personally Denis this is why...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I don't lend out tools. At all. That's why my friends are still my friends and I'm still neighborly with my neighbors.