Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

Posts

Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#1

Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

charlie belden

>This book, by Peter London was recomended reading for the November WC Chat with Betty Scarpino. I bought the book and frankly, it's been a struggle to make it to page 47. Seems like a time traveler's trip back to some of the Sixties with many of the buzzwords and wise sayings so often used at the time - self expression, deep thoughts, I'm OK-You're OK, release the True You Hidden Inside, Encounters (what was also called Expriences). Oddly, Be Ins don't seem to have made it into the book - at least not by page 47. The book has 187 pages and hiking through the remaining 140 pages looks to be a bit of a chore.

Rather than slog through more of the same of the first 47 pages I read consecutively, I tried going to chapters that I thought might be interesting. That wasn't much help either - though there were some interesting ideas buried in a lot of text that seem to be written to encourage and reassure someone who is insecure and depressed to Externalize their feelings and feel better about himself/herself - which is a good thing, I wasn't expecting a book or Art As Therapy.

While psychoanalysis and a good psychologist can be of value to some, perhaps everyone, and I very much agree with the main theme of this book - we're all born with creativity and that "art" is not the sole domain of "artists" identified as such by erudite scholars and critics - getting to what I hope is the useful info in this book hasn't been easy or much fun.

I have googled Rollo Mays and a few other folks (Famanke what's his name made for interesting reading - on hw to create a persona - for fun and profit) quoted throughtout the first 47 pages, but I don't seem to be cut out for erudition.

So - if you've gotten through this book and found some gems - please - share - maybe referencing a page number or two?

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#2

I have tried. I am on page ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>100 and share your stated opinions. I am conservative and expected to be offended by some of it - and to my utter surprise that is not the case. There are no put downs of those with religious principles. To the contrary, it seemed as if such things were expected. I was expecting a few core concepts that I could hang my hat on. To date it has been like nailing Jello to a tree and I am sure that a lot of it has eluded me as my eyes glazed over and I awakened later.

It is my intention to complete the book and then start over and read it again. It is very well written and there is a subtle humor that I enjoy here. I believe the author to be very bright and erudite. At one point I grinned as I realized that this book is essentially pre-computer and I really liked that flavor.

If we think that we are going to find that clarifying statement about creativity versus copying that was implied in the WC post, well, I think we are peeing in the wind because I don't think it is spelled out for those of us who are intolerant of blather and obfuscation.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#3

Nice turn of phrase

Texian

>"nailing Jello to a tree" -- Nice turn of phrase Ed. Hope I can remember it when needed.

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#4

Nice turn of phrase - thank you.

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Texian, I could also have used "grabbing smoke". Being task-oriented and focused on the sequence of steps involved, some of the psycho-babble eludes me. But to be fair, I truly feel that the author knows exactly what he means and that he says it very accurately. His intent seems to be to have a fledgling artist identify who they are and to step out from the usual bounds. It isn't always applicable to woodturning, but what the heck.

Some things are learned by digging deeper and deeper until you understand. Others are like a bulldozer leveling a parking lot. Skim the surface until you get it level. I am hoping to eventually understand the big picture by reading this book again. Maybe that will work and maybe not.

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#5

Bad egg . . .

Doc Green

>Ed, You're a lot more devoted to the task than I think I would be. The phrase that I often abide by is, "You don't have to eat the entirety of an egg to determine that it is bad."

~Doc (PS: I'm not familiar with the book in question, so I'm not tossing pebbles.)

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#6

Doc, it isn't clear that the egg...

Ed Moore in SW VA

>is bad. I hold out hope that there will be a golden egg near the end. Had the author offended me earlier I would have discarded this optimism a long time ago and bailed out.

As I mentioned above, some subjects aren't best learned by digging deeper. When teaching Matrix Theory I realized that if a student prepares for each of the tests and does badly, they may actually do well on a comprehensive final exam because when they go over the material for the fourth or fifth time things may fall in place for them. Each time they skim a little and eventually the parking lot is level. I had a bright electrical engineer get straight D's on the hour tests (possibly on purpose) and then ace the final with a 97/100. As I had promised, he earned an A in the course. To use the art setting of the book, he could not have painted that picture without obtaining a real understanding of the concepts espoused by the author.

Since I am wading in uncharted waters, for me, a second trip through the book might actually teach me something. One lesson might be that I am unable to read it a second time. ;^D

Respect the bandsaw,

Ed

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#7

Slogging along......

David Belser

>made it to page 56.

I suspect that the author has a lot of interesting and valuable ideas and perspective on art and creating. Unfortunately the wordy writing and use of suqishy (ambiguous, vague, nebulous) words make it quite hard to grasp the points being made. Like Ed said, "nailing jello to a tree"

What I have gleaned so far is stuff that I already knew or have internalized:

- Explore the boundaries of you "safe" zone in life and art

- Creating can/should provide anxious moments

- Everyone is creative

- There is always someone "better" don't judge you creativity by trying to measure up to another.

I was hoping some "clarifying statement about creativity versus copying" that I could use when the discussion comes up.

My background doesn't include any formal art training or study of art. I think perhaps that this book is geared more towards a collage art student. Clearly it is written to help people who feel that they aren't creative/creative enough to find it with in themselves.

Perhaps the latter section of the book about "creative encounters" will have some more practical advice on creativity.

If I can make it that far!

- Dave

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#8

Not rotten, just opauqe

David Belser

>to this uninitiated mind.

I agree Ed, it may take several reads to appreciate/learn what the author is saying.

I wasn't expecting this experience to be a college level course! It would be nice to have an instructor who could offer a little direction.

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#9

Re: Slogging along......(did you mean...)

Mike Jones

>David!

Did you mean "College art student" or "collage-art student"? Is the book really about collage?

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#10

Re: Slogging along......

charlie belden

>Looks like David found several of the needles in the haystack when he wrote:

What I have gleaned so far is stuff that I already knew or have internalized:

- Explore the boundaries of you "safe" zone in life and art

- Creating can/should provide anxious moments

- Everyone is creative

- There is always someone "better" don't judge you creativity by trying to measure up to another.

I was hoping some "clarifying statement about creativity versus copying" that I could use when the discussion comes up.

========================================

Given the deep metaphysical, spiritual, psychological, erudite writing style of the book I was looking for The Wisdom Of The Universe I could use for a future piece. Guess I overlooked the obvious buried in all the verbosity - which often required a trip to the dictionary in order to try and understand what the author was attempting to convey.

As for creativity vs copying - the author keeps saying that copying is a recipe for disaster, failure - and by implication - a route to low self esteem - since none of us can BE Van Gough or Beethoven or Michaelangelo (DUH!. In the vernacular of the Sixties he's saying Do Your Own Thing.

Could've got those ideas acrossed in a lot fewer pages using more readily understood words though.

Re: Anyone read "No More Second Hand Art"

#11

Re: Slogging along......(did you mean...)

David Belser

>Spell checkers are great, at least the words are correct. Hey, I find creativity easy, it's written communication that I have trouble with! So I guess I can understand where those folks that have trouble being creative come from.... : )