>When it comes to the proportions for a hollow form, there are all kinds of Rules and Rules of Thumb floating around. Visualizing the text versions of these "rules" is tough for a visual learner like myself - and probably others.
So - I put together an illustrated table which has The Rule of Thirds and The Rule of Fifths and the "fill ins". Starting with the Maximum Diameter of the blank, I worked out the Total Height of the piece then filled in where the shoulder should be using The Rule of Thirds and The Rule of Fifths and illustrated the resulting shape.
The attached illustrated table will fit on an 8 1/2" x 11 piece of printer paper and I plan on putting a copy on the wall near my lathe and, over time, work my way through turning each of the twenty five shapes, labeling each one as it's completed.
Since I've completed the first cut at this illustrated "table" I figured I'd share it and maybe get some feedback on how to improve it. Comments, suggestions, constructive criticism solicited.
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
>OK - so I've done an Excel Spreadsheet that let's you plug in your Maximum Diameter and it fills in a matrix
- Derived Height from 1/3rd to 1 4/5ths of Max. Diam. down the left side
- Distance to the Shoulder of Hollow Form from 1/3rd to 4ths acrossed the top.
Don't know how to attach a spreadsheet here so I've put up a web page on this stuff - with a link to the spreadsheet you can download. The link is just AFTER the illustrated table like the one I posted earlier.
Let me know if you either successfully download the file - or not.
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Heig
Carole Valentine
>Or your eyes. Look at the thing...if it looks good, finish it. If it doesn't, fix it. If you don't know, ask the opinion of someone who does and be sure you ask for an honest opinion. I don't see any need for creativity to be stifled by a bunch of "rules".
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Heig
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>I agree Carole. Designing a vessel from a chart leaves no room for putting your individual stamp on the piece. I do often draw sketches before turning a piece. The chart leaves no room for designing a rim or neck, which I often like to feature. When examining a piece to see if the design is balanced I find that it helps to view the piece while it's upside down. If it doesn't look right, it probably isn't.
Wally
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
>My intent is not to try to impose a set of "rules" on anyone, or to give the impression that by following one set of any of the "rules" you'll find in books or magazines or on line guarantees prefectly proportioned hollow forms. What I AM trying to do is provide visual aids that SHOW what a shape looks like that follows one of these two (of many) sets of "rules".
One of the hardest things for new turners to find is the really basic stuff about turning which "everyone assumes everyone else already knows - so it isn't worth mentioning - let alone pointing out - or publishing."
Old hands at turning have gotten this "really basic stuff" long ago and now apply them without thinking about them - at all. But somewhere way back when, this "really basic stuff" was learned, either by a lot of trial and error, or from a conversation with an old hand offering some suggesations - or from a demonstrator or teacher.
Granted, a few are born with "the eye" for really nice forms and proportions, or maybe we're all born with "the eye" and loose it because we haven't used it much - or at all. Having visual examples of potential hollow form shapes CAN help - at least to identify what DOES NOT look right - and maybe what DOES look better - or "right" - to "me". Given the infinite number of possibilities, illustrations like this can narrow down the focus and assist the convergence on a shape and proportions to try on the piece of wood currently on the lathe.
When I was doing custom jewelry, extracting a client's preferences in jewerly was one of the hardest things I faced. Eventually I stumbled on a method that worked quite well. I gave them a jewelry manufacturer's catalog of piece - had them go through all the rings if it was a ring they wanted, and write down the catalogue number of all the pieces they found attractive. The client would take the book home and a week or two later we'd get together to go over their list of rings they liked. Their preferences usually had two or three types of common shapes or elements or details - lumpy bumpy asymetric "organic" or very smooth and simple and symetric. Once the common factors were noted, converging on what they wanted - in some detail - would go fairly quickly. I'd then "sketch" in wax (I used the lost wax casting method) the basics of what they wanted and - with an actual size - 3D object in hand, they could actually SEE what the ring would look like - sort of. Desired changes might be wanted and I'd make the changes - still in wax (additive scultping is a lot easier than subtractive sculpting). Once the major look of the ring was accepted I could do the detailing and have it ready for the next appointment. Final tweeks might be required - then the piece would be cast, finished, polished andpicked up.
From "I want you to make me a ring" - to - "THIS is the ring I wanted you to make" took much less time than the Goldylocks "This ring is TOO BIG. This ring is too small. This ring is too smooth. This ring is too lumpy bumpy" method of arriving at the piece the client wanted.
I guess where I'm going with all this is that I'm attempting to provide a few of the many ways to converge on nicer hollow forms quicker - than randomly cutting away wood "'til it looks right".
The idea here is not to stifle creativity, or dictate what is and isn't "right" - but merely provide some images of hollow forms - with the number behind them - to be used as starting points for the next piece - or not.
The old saying "You gotta learn the rules before you can break them - successfuly." might be applicable here.
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
>Thanks for providing some ideas and shapes to think about before plunging in to make an object. More times than not, the "design" will be modified as the shape progresses by tool handling errors, surprises in the wood, etc..
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
Re: Baby Steps - Walk - Run - Sprint . . . Fly? *LINK*
Russ Fairfield
>There has been a lot written about design over the years if one cares to look for it. Many of us discuss these rules in our demonstrations, and most turning clubs have a design presentation every year or so. This article has been here on Wood Centeral for about 8 or 9 years.
>Thanks for the reminders. While much has been written, it is not always remembered in the midst of turning. I guess a conclusion is to keep practicing until the "rules for good design" become 2nd nature.
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
So YOU're the guy who I got The Rules of Thirds from. I saved the text - but forgot to save the source. I've made an attempt to illustrate the application of your suggested Rules of Thirds for hollow forms. Does the attached illustrate the Rules of Thirds in your WC article? I've put it up on my personal site - having done the illustration many months or a couple of year ago based on my interpretation of your text description.
Yes, there's a lot of information on Design available on the internet, as well as books, magazines and multiple posts here and in other forums. Finding it however is not always as easy as one might think.
Alas, I'm a Visual Learner and just a text description of a concept often escapes me. But if I can illustrate what the text is describing - I GET IT, and maybe others will as well.
Great article - thanks sir.
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Height
Re: Visual Aid - Height to Max Diam, Shoulder Heig *LINK*
Keith Tompkins
>Charlie, Seems like you really didn't receive much help from some of the responses. Here is a link that goes beyond the basic rules and may help you out.