Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Couple of new boxes

Posts

Couple of new boxes

#1

Couple of new boxes

Richard Jones

>I posted this earlier on a different board, had zero comments, so I'm thinking that maybe they are no good? Anyway, here's what I had:

Mahogany is some Honduran that I scoffed from my dad's stash, not really sure how old it is, but he probably got it in the '50's. I was playing with the shape of the top, found out later that I really don't like this inverse shape. Makes the lid look too flat to me and it makes it really light in weight. I've found that altho' I can do really thin stuff, I actually like a bit more weight.

Cherry is just some scrap from one of the local cabinet shops. I love the streaking, altho' I know some purists would have tossed it. Both boxes are approx. 3.5" dia x 3.5" high.

These have been really fun, and I enjoy the challenge of doing the beads, coves, etc.

Critiques welcome, am always interested in how others view my work, especially the design. Form is everything, for sure.

Thanks for looking.

Rich


img

Re: Couple of new boxes

#2

Re: Couple of new boxes 

Richard Jones

>


img

Re: Couple of new boxes

#3

Re: Couple of new boxes 

Richard Jones

>


img

Re: Couple of new boxes

#4

Re: Couple of new boxes 

Richard Jones

>


img

Re: Couple of new boxes

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Couple of new boxes

Mike Stafford

>Richard, it is a nice looking box. In my opinion it would be even nicer looking if you would reduce the volume of the knob. The knob seems to be too large and over powers the box. I bet if you made the knob half as large it would be just right. I am assuming this is not a tight fitting lid that requires a lot of knob to pull the lid off the body.

The details inside the box are always a surprise and can make or break a sale. Keep up the nice work.

Re: Couple of new boxes

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Couple of new boxes

Mike Stafford

>Richard, I hate to sound like a broken record but my comments about the mahogany box are the same as the ones I made about the cherry. In this case I think the knob is way too large.

I went through this exact stage when I was turning a lot of side grain boxes. The knob was the weakest point of my design and the weakest point of the box. As I made the knob smaller it became more and more prone to breakage and would snap off as the smallest diameter of the "shaft" supporting the knob is very short side grain and has little strength. Thus I found it necessary to turn my knobs in the spindle orientation and insert them in a little drilled hole in the lid. This offers many design opportunities and is well worth exploring.

Also, when designing your box think about what a user might put inside. Then test the box and see if it works. I learned a long time ago that some boxes I made to hold men's watches would not hold all men's watches because they would not lay flat. Design with a use in mind and change your designs and dimensions in height/depth and diameter to offer your customers variety.

Keep up the good work. I like to see everyone's boxes and these are no exception.

Re: Couple of new boxes

#7

Re: Couple of new boxes

Richard Jones

>Mike,

No broken record, it is what it is. I think the knob on the cherry box looks overly large, at least to some extent, because it's not defined at the juncture very well. Too much swoop, as they say. But I would agree that they are too big. My wife said the same thing.

And the mahogany knob does look huge!!

I'll try some with them smaller, and with some spindle-turned knobs. That sounds like a good way to use up some smaller scrap and look good as well. Maybe some contrasting woods are in order?

I appreciate your comments.

Rich

Re: Couple of new boxes

#8

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Couple of new boxes

Katherine Kowalski

>Actually, I think the knob on this piece is a very good size -- what catches me attention is the transition between the lid and the knob -- it isn't defined. The curve doesn't look quite right. As a suggestion -- make a bead there instead, adding definition with a couple of v-grooves. Alternately, change the shape of the curve. (Try possibly undercutting the top of the knob more to give a more dramatic shape to the curve).

BTW, the "streaking" is actually mineral staining, which happens often to cherry that grows in certain conditions. I personally *love* this type of natural feature in wood!

Lovely box -- I really like the details you turned on the inside.

Re: Couple of new boxes

#9

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Couple of new boxes

Katherine Kowalski

>Richard, in general I like the shape of this box -- the proportions look good, and the detail at the bottom complements the design at the lid/box juncture. It appears also that the bottom diameter is smaller than the top, giving it a nice flowing line.

The only thing that I would change is the knob. This knob is far too tall -- I think maybe 1/2 or 1/3 of the current height would be just perfect. The curve transition, (as on your other box), is weak here as well. It doesn't have that same implied line or flow, and looks as though it doesn't belong with the rest of the piece.

Besides what I recommended for the other box above, and shortening the knob, this piece might also look good with a v-groove detail near the top of the knob to carry the theme of the piece through.

Love the details on the inside -- it gives a sense of intimacy to the viewer, as though they can step *inside* the box and explore every little feature! Very nice pieces!

Re: Couple of new boxes

#10

Re: Couple of new boxes

GalenV in Iowa

>Richard:

Don't think that if someone does not post a comment on your boxes that they have no interest in them. I'm too much of a greenhorn to comment, but I do look at them and try to learn. I learned Mike Stafford's critiques are helpful to me even though it is not my turning. He make some good comments or suggestions.

I saved posted boxes by Mike till the light came on and I found them on his web site! Really helpful to see them in the enlarge pictures to see the wood grain, details and lines of each box.

Your detail on the inside of the box is something I always wonder about Mike's cause he does not post many shots of the inside, (Hint).

So far I rank my boxes as some plain Jane boxes. (Oops, better say plain Person boxes). None have your inside details, so I should try.

Galen

Re: Couple of new boxes

#11

Mike, ? for you........

Richard Jones

>Did the hole go all the way through the lid or was it stopped? I'm thinking maybe better to have it stopped, would limit my design choices for the inside of the lid?

One nice thing about these lids is that you can re-chuck them, which is exactly what I intend to do. Round 2 soon.........

Thanks.

Rich

Re: Couple of new boxes

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Mike, ? for you........

Mike Stafford

>Richard, I stopped the hole and did not penetrate the lid. However I have seen others drill all the way through and use the tip that penetrated as a design element. All ways are good depending oh how you finish it off.