Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

Posts

Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

steve antonucci

>I may be dense, but am I the only one who roughs out with a bowl gouge on it's side? I read about how folks love this tool because it "takes the stress out of roughing" something round?

As I balance my wood, I turn up the speed to as fast as safe and using my bowl gouge with the flute at 3PM (cutting towards the tailstock) or 9PM (cutting towards the tailstock), I can usually take a 1" wide cut befoe I stall the lathe out. It's bevel rubbing too, so the surface is pretty good.

Turners used to be such a frugal bunch. When did we start buying disposable tools? My main Oneway bowl gouge was roughly 3 carbide inserts, and probably still has 10,000 bowls in left it. Are folks buying these things because they don't know how to use their bowl gouges?

steve

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#2

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

Texian

>Steve, I rough essentially the same way (bowl gouge almost on its side), just much less aggressively than you. Also scrape and shear scrape with it. No way would I buy a specialty "roughing tool". It's all fine for folks who have the resources, but I could not reasonably afford to buy all the tools, jigs, and fixtures that I have made. My home made stuff tends to look rather crude and ugly, but functions very well. And then there is the "dovetail scraper" to make the tenon match the chuck jaws. Good grief.

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#3

Steven Antonucci

How about a beading tool too!

steve antonucci

>I just lead a workshop where we made tools. I made a fluteless gouge ($29 Skewchigouge in catalog), a pyramid point tool($26 in catalog), a round skew, a hook tool,a small square scraper, and I could have made a small set of Ellsworth hollower. The steel cost about $8/rod in 3' lengths, and we made about $150 worth of catalog tools with it.

I brought 2 spindles that I had cut one with the homemade tools and the other with high end "real" tools. I challenged the group to tell the difference. It was impossible.

I wonder if I could get someone to send me a ton of money for the one last tool every turner needs to become good at turning...?

Sheesh.

S

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#4

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question? *LINK*

Fred Holder--MW

>Hello Steve,

I agree that an experienced turner can do almost anything with a bowl gouge. I've also found that most experienced turners scoff at the Easy Woodt Tools, saying they are only a scraper, etc. Most people are saying who needs tool like these. As editor of More Woodturning, I buy tools to try them and report on them if they are worthwhile, especially to a new or at least intermediate turner.

I did exactly that with the Easy Wood Tools: Easy Rougher Ci1, and Ci2, and Easy Finisher Ci0. I approach all such tools with as much of an open mind as I can. I try not to make judgements until I've tried the tool. As I said in another post, I've been turning for over twenty years. I can handle a bowl gouge as well as anyone and better than a lot. The Easy Rougher is an excellent roughing out tool and if the lathe is running at a high enough speed, it will cut almost as smooth as a bowl gouge. I proved this on a goblet that I turned at 3000 rpm and began sanding at 220 grit.

I really feel before people start lambasting a tool they should have given it a good checkout. I doubt if any of the people downplaying the Easy Wood Tools have even used them. I use the Ci1 to rough small spindles like pens. It really works great and you don't need to sharpen, just replace the cutter once in awhile, which I haven't had to do yet and I've even cut into my chuck at least once.

Finally, like they say, the Easy Rougher Ci1 is easier on the body. I have pretty fragile shoulders and it hurts them much less than a bowl gouge on a pretty rough piece of wood.


More Woodturning web site

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#5

Steven Antonucci

It's just one more tool (that you probably don't.

steve antonucci

>need!)

I am sure that it is a very well made tool that can help an average turner complete tasks that they may struggle with, by my gripe is that you are paying $120 for an $8 cutter that you can't sharpen. I would sooner spend $120 on lessons with the basic tools than this magic bullet.

I would also be willing to bet that if you "needed" thi tool, you probably aren't going to be very good with it anyway. After all, it's not a scraper, but I'll bet 1/2 of the users that own one use it that way. If you know how to use the basic tools, this thing is a collasal waste of money. If you don't know how to use your tools, you should learn how to use Google to find carbide cutters and make your own, and then take the leftover $100 for some lessons...

S

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#6

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

john lucas

>I spent the whole weekend roughing bowls. I switched back and forth between the bowl gouge and the homemade C1. Where the bowl was really out of round there might be some advantage to the C1 although I felt like I was taking about the same punishment.

Where the bowl is round and I'm shaping the bowl gouge removes more wood and I can control the shape better.

I can easily see how a new turner with little gouge experience would like this tool because the learning curve is much shorter.

I will be roughing some more the rest of this week so I'll play more.

Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question?

#7

carbide tool usage

john lucas

>I've been playing with the my C1 tool last night. I switched back and forth between it and my 5/8 or 1/2" bowl gouge. Maybe I'm doing something wrong but I can round out the wood much faster with the bowl gouge.

I should preface that with, it depends on how you get a blank to round. On hollow vessels I start at one end and once I get it round I work with the bevel on the round area and go out to the out of round area. This is much easier on the body and goes very fast because the wings on the bowl gouge will remove a huge amount of wood.

With the C1 I find myself pushing it in all the time going from rough to round. I can do the same thing with the bowl gouge and both beat you up doing it this way.

On bowls I do sort of the same thing. I work on the bottom and get it round and then work toward the rim going from round wood to out of round wood.

So far I don't see the advantage of the C1 but will keep on playing with it. It is an interesting tool and has an almost zero learning curve which is what makes it so much fun for a beginner.

The Hunter and eliminator tools are different animals. I find they are not good for hogging off material. I can do that much faster with the bowl gouge or even the C1. What the Hunter tool excels at is the finish cut or reaching into the bottom of steep sided bowls.

The hunter cutting edge is about 25 degrees vs 35 to 55 for spindle gouges or bowl gouges. Consequently if used correctly it will give a very clean cut on problem woods. You need to increase the speed and take light cuts.

The bevel angle of the Hunter tools is about 80 degrees. This means you can cut the bottom of a bowl with the handle almost straight up. I have used it to clean up the bottom of hollow vessels and flat bottom boxes by cutting from the center out. I could not do this with any other tool other than a scraper but you don't get anywhere near as clean of a cut with the scraper.