Re: Ci0 and other carbide cutter tools question? *LINK*
Fred Holder--MW
>Hello Steve,
I agree that an experienced turner can do almost anything with a bowl gouge. I've also found that most experienced turners scoff at the Easy Woodt Tools, saying they are only a scraper, etc. Most people are saying who needs tool like these. As editor of More Woodturning, I buy tools to try them and report on them if they are worthwhile, especially to a new or at least intermediate turner.
I did exactly that with the Easy Wood Tools: Easy Rougher Ci1, and Ci2, and Easy Finisher Ci0. I approach all such tools with as much of an open mind as I can. I try not to make judgements until I've tried the tool. As I said in another post, I've been turning for over twenty years. I can handle a bowl gouge as well as anyone and better than a lot. The Easy Rougher is an excellent roughing out tool and if the lathe is running at a high enough speed, it will cut almost as smooth as a bowl gouge. I proved this on a goblet that I turned at 3000 rpm and began sanding at 220 grit.
I really feel before people start lambasting a tool they should have given it a good checkout. I doubt if any of the people downplaying the Easy Wood Tools have even used them. I use the Ci1 to rough small spindles like pens. It really works great and you don't need to sharpen, just replace the cutter once in awhile, which I haven't had to do yet and I've even cut into my chuck at least once.
Finally, like they say, the Easy Rougher Ci1 is easier on the body. I have pretty fragile shoulders and it hurts them much less than a bowl gouge on a pretty rough piece of wood.
More Woodturning web site