>Paul's "burl from h*ll" post reminds me of msomething I've been meaning to ask about scrapers and shear scraping...
When using a scraper at an angle, do you drop the handle or are you still holding the tool close to horizontal? I have ZERO love when using a scraper to shear scrape because of the unsupported edge (catch-a-rama!).
I know I can use a gouge to shear scrape as well. I get way better results this way but I want to learn to use the scraper as well.
Cheers,
Steve
-who doesn't want to start the gouge vs scraper debate.
>Steve I hold the handle higher than the edge of the tools when scraping. When shear scraping I hold the handle higher AND I lead with the handle. In other words the handle is always ahead of the cutting edge.
I also use a technique that is different than most others. I hold the handle up very high, almost 10:30 if your looking at a clock. I have the blade at a shear angle and the tool is off the tool rest. I use my left hand to sort of push the tool into the work and push it along. I know it doesn't sound safe but the tool is at such a high angle you can dangle the tool against the wood holding just the handle and not get a catch. I've been using the tool this way for many years to clean up my mirrors. Don't try this if you don't understand it or are worried about it. I don't want anyone getting hurt. You need to see a photo or video to understand what I'm doing. I'm without a computer for the next few days so I can't download an image. I'm using my work computer right now.
>A shear CUT can be done with scrapers or gouges. I don't think it is possible to do a shear scrape where you are doing both cuts at the same time (personal rant) with any tool. It is a pull cut where the handle leads the way. Some times I will have the handle more level, some times down. I don't like to work above the center line of the tool. This means that if you are using a round nose scraper, use the bottom half of the cutting edge. If you go above the center line, you can get out leveraged with the wood against the steel, and the scraper can slam flat back onto the tool rest. Bad words will be said! You will have to have the handle level or down. If I am using a swept back grind scraper (quater round profile on the nose, and long grind on the left side), then I use mostly the swept back part. This is partly due to leverage and wanting to work below the center line of the tool blade, and partly because I have used the nose for roughing, and it is too dull for a finish cut. This is not a bevel rubbing cut, though you could if you wanted. This would be a push cut, and the handle would follow the steel. I do this on the inside bottom of bowls some times. Also, a shear cut is for clean up work and not for stock removal. You want several passes to remove tool marks, not one. I do pretty much the same thing on the inside of the bowl, except I pull from the bottom of the bowl up to the rim. I know this is backwards, but it works because you are taking such light cuts.
>Hmmm, maybe I've got the terminology wrong (Or I am writing in metric vs imperial! :))
When I say a shear scrape, I am referring to using scraper (in this case) where instead of being flat on the tool rest, the tool is held at an angle and, effectively, rolled counter-clockwise and worked from centre to the rim. At least, that's what I always thought a shear scrape was. Witha gouge rolled over for scraping, you drop the angle of the handle so the cutting edge (or scraping edge) is at 45 degrees to the work (or thereabouts).
Robo, are we talking the same thing here? Maybe I am just being thick and need to get some sleep.
Peter Hyde------WebKitFormBoundaryC53+kMQx7yAS2Dr4
Peter Hyde------WebKitFormBoundaryC53+kMQx7yAS2Dr4
Guest
Re: Shear scraping question
Peter Hyde------WebKitFormBoundaryC53+kMQx7yAS2Dr4
>Steve I just did a day with Al Stirt and shear scraping was one of the subjects covered.
Using a square nosed scraper with the top edge ground skewed about 15� to the left like a skew, the bevel is ground at around 70�. The edge is made slightly convex. Sharpen on a grinder, remove the burr with a hone on the top, then pull up from the back with the hone to make a finer burr. Use the tool with the blade rotated 45� CCW and the handle level. The tool rest needs to be adjusted so the cutting is being done on the bottom 1/3 of the edge. Hope this makes sense. Worked for me and I was the total non scraper user:)
>I think we are talking about the same thing. When the scraper is flat on the tool rest, you are scraping. When it is at a 45 degree angle, you are shear cutting. I use the burr straight from the grinder. My grinding wheels are fairly fine (CBN cubic boric nitride) and leave a very nice burr, suitable for roughing and shear cutting. I do remove the old burr on a diamond stone before making a new one, and I do press into the grinding wheel when making the new one.
>Steve I'll try to do a photo or maybe even a movie in a few days. My home computer is dead and off to the shop so I only have my work computer to play with right now.