Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

practice makes perfect

Posts

practice makes perfect

#1

practice makes perfect

john lucas

>How many of you right handers have trouble turning with your left hand and Vice/Versa. Me too. I turn with my left hand a lot but want to improve so last night I turned a Christmas tree ornament with nothing but my left hand. OK, I did have to hollow with my right, I don't have any left hand hollowing tools. I did turn the outside and all the finial parts left handed. It is a wonderful exercise and I highly recommend it.

It makes you think about how the tool cuts and how you control the cut. I learned this when I was playing handball (whatever happened to that, everyone plays racket ball now) I had to learn to throw left handed to be successful at this game and spent hours in the court just throwing and catching the ball left handed.

Re: practice makes perfect

#2

Re: practice makes perfect

Don Orr

>I know I should practice with my left hand turning more-I am very right side dominant. I get stuck up by the headstock trying to get certain cuts which would be much eaisier if I just switched hands. I did try the other day with some success.

I used to do the same thing when learning handball. I'd go early and toss the ball into the back left corner and practice digging it out over and over. Never got any good at handball though.

Re: practice makes perfect

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: practice makes perfect

Rob Wallace

>Same here John!

I just proved this (again) when I completed a set of replacement balusters last week. It doesn't matter whether I use a skew or a gouge - nearly every bead I roll is - slightly - asymmetrical. I can see it, but apparently most others can't. (The contractor that I supplied them for said they are "perfect" but I know they aren't.) When I took Alan Lacer's skew class, he said this was normal, and that lots of practice was needed to overcome the natural 'handedness' of humans. Maybe I should try to turn a bowl from start to finish left handed, just to see how the other 7 to 10 percent of the population turns?

Perhaps I just need more practice doing spindles (I do FAR more bowls, vessels and HF's), but I only do these on an as-needed basis.

Interesting topic...

Rob

Re: practice makes perfect

#4

I didn't say I was any good at handball :)

john lucas

>

Re: practice makes perfect

#5

Re: practice makes perfect

john lucas

>Rob I grit my teeth when turning the left side of a bead left handed. Just like you the beads vary slightly from the left side to the right side even if I use my right hand for both. I agree, nobody but me notices. When I turn a lot of them I get pretty good but then a month later I'll have the same problem.

Re: practice makes perfect

#6

Re: practice makes perfect

Lan Brady

>John,

This is one of the few places where us natural lefty's have the advantage. We had to grow up in a right/opposite handed world. We have adjusted and improvised our entire lives.

I hope no one reads this wrong because I am not complaining. Actually, I am celebrating. Just try pouring punch with the rounded side of aladdle without spilling any on the lace table cloth. It is not that easy!

Practicing the correct way makes you perfect. Practicing the wrong thing just makes you really good at being bad!

Time to go practice some more. I sure do like making shavings!

Lan

Re: practice makes perfect

#7

Hey Lan...

Don Orr

>...always remember-Lefties have rights too. ;-)) We have a lot of left handers in out turning club-possibly up to half the members (small club). Definitley an advantage in many situations.

Re: practice makes perfect

#8

John, try bowling!!!

Richard Jones

>Due to arthritis and impingement syndrome, I can no longer bowl with my right hand, soooooooooooo............now I bowl left handed. Talk about strange, and this from a guy that can't even blow his nose left-handed. After a few weeks, tho', it's beginning to feel more 'normal', and I'm currently carrying about a 115 average.

That being said, I think practice can only go so far, as some of us are genetically engineered to only do one hand really well. We can gain proficiency with the weak hand, but for me, I don't think it will ever be the same. I used to shoot 'a lot' of USPSA and did well with my weak hand, but it never felt "normal".

I've also practiced with the left hand at the lathe, and it comes in darn handy for some issues. Since I've been doing OK at the bowling alley, maybe I'll try a bit more at the lathe.

Great thread, thanks for making us think!!

Rich

Re: practice makes perfect

#9

Re: practice makes perfect

Don at Central Illinois

>I've often heard (from my left handed friends) that since the opposite side of the brain controls the handedness, that lefty's are the only one's in their 'right minds'.

Re: practice makes perfect

#10

Re: Hey Lan...

Ned Bulken

>Don,

when you were showing me how to turn a bowl (sadly, my one and only to date) you suggested I try to turn left handed, and it worked pretty well for me. But then I'm supposed to be left handed anyway. have to see which works better for me once I get my lathe stand finished.

Re: practice makes perfect

#11

Re: A Safety Warning

Russ Fairfield

>Always be aware of what your Right Hand will do as a reaction to a problem. You may be turning Left Handed, but your involuntary reaction will always be Right Handed. That could mean you are pulling the tool into rather than out of harms way.

You will know what I am talking about when you are turning Left Handed on the back side of a bowl and get a catch; and rather than the Left Hand pulling the tool away from the wood, the dominant Right Hand pulls the tool into the wood.

Left handers have the same problem in the opposite direction when they turn Right Handed

Re: practice makes perfect

#12

Steve Kubien

I've been lucky...

Steve Kubien

>...because I do not know what you mean by turning with your left or right hand. Are you talking about the hand up close to the toolreat or the trailing hand? I guess I never thought much about it. I am a lefty in most things but when I commit golf, I do so right-handed. Same when I used to attempt to play the drums. I shoot a hockey stick and swing a baseball bat left. I cut with a sword right-handed but that is because there are no left-handed swordsmen in the Japanese arts.

Havving said all of that, my beads look better if you only look at the right side. :)

Re: practice makes perfect

#13

I'd probably kill myself and the guy next to me.

john lucas

>

Re: practice makes perfect

#14

Re: practice makes perfect

Darrell Feltmate

>I remember handball. The queen of the racket sports but without a racket. I like to use a skew left handed a lot. It amazed me when I watched a Raffan video (some incredible turning there!) how hard he worked to do things right handed.

Re: practice makes perfect

#15

Mike Stafford

Totally ambidextrous.....

Mike Stafford

>I am totally ambidextrous except I can't do everything I do with both hands. Turning is one of the things I can do with both hands. When I was tested for military service I was told I had exceptional night vision but I don't seem to be able to see things in the dark.

When I am cutting to the left I hold the tool in my right hand and when I am cutting to the right it is in the left hand. Cutting the left side of the bead the tool is held in the left hand with the left forefinger on the top where it remains as I roll my wrist to the left. Doing it this way is a very comfortable movement for me. Likewise, rolling a bead to the right I use my right hand with the right forefinger on top....again a very comfortable move. This is particularly true since I have made shorter handles and can now work with the tools in front of me instead of resting at my side.

I think even if you are ambidextrous there is some things that you will find you do better with one hand over the other. I think this has to do with which is your primary eye. I have to cut the flange on the body of my boxes with my right hand because I can see the cut better when I am sighting over my hand with my right eye. I can do it left handed but I am more likely to cut a tapered tenon when I do because the dominant eye is not lined up properly.

Re: practice makes perfect

#16

Re: Totally ambidextrous.....

David Walser

>I'm ambidextrous, too -- just as bad with either hand.

Re: practice makes perfect

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Totally ambidextrous.....

Keith Tompkins

>Me too....I've got two left feet.

Re: practice makes perfect

#18

Re: John, try bowling!!!

Bill Crommett

>Speaking of genetic engineering, I submit myself as an example. An example of a Lobster; one claw is for holding and the other is for working.

Re: practice makes perfect

#19

Re: Totally ambidextrous.....

Bill Crommett

>That David ! My kind of guy !

Re: practice makes perfect

#20

Re: Totally ambidextrous.....

Michael Mocho

>Jeez, I'd give my right arm to be totally ambidextrous .......

....but on the other hand ........

Re: practice makes perfect

#21

Doesn't that fall under- Don't ask, Don't tell

john lucas

>

Re: practice makes perfect

#22

Re: John, try bowling!!!

Bob Macgregor

>I used to bowl with a friend who was a lot better than I was. To even things up a bit, I suggested we both bowl left-handed. It worked; we were both lowsy then.

I also used to carry a single left-handed iron in my golf bag for those times the ball was lying on the wrong side (ie, no place to stand and hit right-handed) of some obstacle--usually a tree or water. I figured 20 or 30 yds (a fairly good lefty shot for me) was still better than a lost stroke.

BOB

Re: practice makes perfect

#23

Re: practice makes perfect

Carole Valentine

>I don't even think I think about it, even when I am turning from the back side of the lathe...I switch back and forth automatically. That is weird because in any other situation I am a total klutz if I have to do something left-handed.

Re: practice makes perfect

#24

Dick Hines

Re: Doesn't that fall under- Don't ask, Don't tell

Dick Hines

>I have never thought about it. I do use my left hand at times while turning. My left hand gets more of a work out while I am reading though. I use to pick up snacks.

Re: practice makes perfect

#25

Mike Stafford

LOL, Dick...what to do with you.....

Mike Stafford

>