>I played around this last weekend making some coring tools. I made 3 different sizes and tried out 3 different tips. I silver soldered a HSS tip on one, put a Hunter carbide tip on another and welded a High carbon steel tip on the other. it will be fun to see how they work. I hope to have time to work with them this weekend.
>This is one of the new cutters that Mike is installing on McNaughton tools. I wanted to try them out so I installed one on my new tool. Here is a close up of the cutter.
>Nice John, oh, I hope to see you at Duck River turners club for your turning demo of the mirrors you make tonight. I haven't made the last 3 meetings but I will try my best to be there. See you. DonL
>It is a carbide tip but there are huge differences in the standard metal cutting carbide tips and these. I'm just learning machinist skills so I'm certainly not an expert. I'm told these are for machining Titanium or aluminum. They are much sharper than standard bits for cutting steel. In this case I'm not sure maximum sharpness is as much of a consideration as edge holding. When your coring it really dulls a blade.
>Don Looking forward to finally meeting you. I packed everything up last night and even reground my skew. It hasn't touched a grinding wheel in months but was starting to take too long to hone.
>I used 3/16 x 3/4 for the small one and 3/16 x 1 11/8 for the carbide one and1/4" x1" for the long one. 1/4" is too thick to take that particular carbide cutter and I didn't have any more 3/8" HSS bits that I wanted to sacrifice for this project. I did it mostly to see how well tool steel will hold an edge.
I'd like to know how you bent them ... with heat? Will they be hard/stiff enough? I'll be interested to read how the larger one holds up to use. I want a set that goes the other way -- for coring toward the tailstock from the "right", instead of coring toward the headstock from the "left".
Not a political statement, but I can get a more secure hold on a faceplate on the flat top of a bowl, and work more quickly from the headstock end, not having to reverse each core to make a new foot after it comes off the stack. I currently have the McNaughton large coring set that is curved like yours. Many people don't know that you can buy them with either right or left curves...
At the very least, I'll have to spring for the medium and possibly the small set -- whichever way they curve -- to work on the more common size blanks available.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT -- with 1" on the ground, and more snow falling as I type... does seem a tad early for this.
>Before I had ever heard of the McNaughton system, I made my own. Believe it or not, I bent a piece of steel in a partial circle, filed a point on it and installed a piece of pipe about four feet long as a handle and cored several blanks. Without the gate post part, it was a wild ride. Its a wonder I wasn't killed.
The part you might want to try is the tip. I filed a "V" in the tip so it cut on each side and left a little vee in the middle. Cut like a banshee. Just stroked the inside with a file every now and then. My thought was that the cutter only cut the fibers on each side and just raked the stuff out of the middle. If you could find a cutter shaped like that, it would be interesting.
>They are cold bent using my homemade bending jig which is really just 2 3/4" steel bars stuck into a steel base.
I'll be interested to see how the big one works. I've used the McNaughton in this size and didn't have any problems. Mine is thicker but narrower than theirs.
It wouldn't be any problem to make these in reverse although I don't know how you would feed them. Wouldn't the tool handle hit the headstock?
>Barry That's what the Hunter cutter does. Vega sells a cutter for their duplicator that is ground down the middle like you are talking about. I thought about doing that to mine but just didn't have time this weekend. I've got to finish several other projects and core a bunch of bowls before I have time to grind out those inserts.
From your earlier posted picture it looked like the McNaughton tools had a longer taper in the bars to the tip. I wondered if there was a trade off in their design. Seems the longer taper would make the tool more subject to vibration when cantileverd into a large bowl. I wondered if the longer taper though helped remove the chips easier.
Your's has a much shorter transition. This would make it stiffer but maybe a place for chips to build behind the cutter.
It will be insteresting to see if your short taper is better or plugs more.
Never used a coreing tool in my short turning life but just observations of an old machine design engineer.
>I wondered the same thing when making them. I was careful to smooth the taper hoping the shaving would fly over. I used a similar angle but obviously the narrower bar has a shorter taper than the thick bar. If I don't have to work this weekend I'm going to do some coring.