>When I'm looking for inspiration for a turning I think in terms of wood turning pieces - and ceramic pieces.
But looking at a turned goblet in the recent Elegant turning contest here at WoodCentral, something about the piece just didn't look right - to me. The foot appeared too small for the top's diameter and visual mass.
Now it may be that I grew up in a different time and place, but stemware shapes and sizes that I'm familiar with were all "leaded glass" or crystal. And when I think crystal and stemware - I think Baccarat and Waterford as the standards, in materials, craftsmanship and form/proportions (Mikasa hadn't arrived on the scene yet).
Though I haven't downloaded sample images and worked out the proportions of the various types of stemware, I suspect there are accepted or implied "rules" of proportions for each type of stemware, each developed for a specific purpose and refined to a T over the years. The rules for a water goblet are probably different from those for a champagne glass, a wine glass, a licqeur glass or a brandy snifter.
Now we call them "hollow forms". Ceramicists probably have another name "pinch neck" coming to mind. If they're crystal they probably have more specific names - decanters.
I'm going to be spending time looking at and studying Baccarat and Waterford and I suspect there's much to be learned from them when it comes to shapes and forms - and proportions.
>THere's a lot to be learned from looking at other styles of work. However you do have to take into account that these must be functional. When we make a purely show piece the size of the base as far as being functional can be tossed.
The proportions still have to work and I agree with you on the piece mentioned. I thought the base was a little to small. Very well done piece but the top feels heavy when compared to the base.
Of course if what you are trying to convey is a feeling of lift and a light and airy top then a small base may be the way to go. However the base has to make your eye go up toward the top instead of anchoring it to the table and that's hard to do.
Re: Stemware - Look to Baccarat & Waterford? *LINK*
While I understand that pieces turned for a contest or exhibit don't need to actually be functional. But when a piece looks so much like something which may be familiar to at least some of its viewers (do people still use stemware much anymore - that isn't plastic?) it seems at least a better nod to function should be considered.
There's a fine line between the appearance of "lift" and "light" and "airy" - and a hot air balloon (which is why I think HF christmas ornaments look better with a finial than just with an "icicle").
It's funny how we have images of iconic things and when what we see that looks familiar doesn't match our iconic view - we sense something is wrong. Take the iconic image of Santa - and then compare it with a plywood cutout and painted Santa on someone's lawn or roof around Christmas. Make him too thin, or too fat, or if his beard is too short or way too long, or his belt is too high - or too low - and someone's going to point that out and say something like THAT doesn't look like Santa. On the other hand, I did an 8 foot Frankenstien, again cut out of ply and hand painted with house paint and all the comments on him were "that's a great Frankenstien!" Could be we've been bombarded with images of Santa EVERYWHERE around Christmas, but not much air time for Franky around Halloween. So ourmental image of Frankenstien may lack many of the details that our image of Santa has.
The point I guess is that when you're doing an iconic piece, there's less artistic license you can get away with.
There also seems to be a limit on the appearance of lift - my Elegant Tight Rope Walker piece looks like the "walker" IS actually floating, though that wasn't my primary intent, but rather a necessity for the range of actual movement I wanted the piece to have - and does have. (actual movement as a "4th dimension", to use a term Peter Rand used to describe what actual movement in a piece adds, is something still photos can't adequately convey but can be another dimension for turning exploration).
I took the thumbnail image of the piece and tweeked it in PhotoShop just to see what it would look like with "stemware" proportions. Initially I just copied and then scaled the top of the copied image to find a size that looked right for me. I then realized that merely scaling the top kept all the dark grain of the original - something that could not have actually been done. So I made another copy of the top of the original and trimmed off what I think needed to be removed. That Side By Side comparison is in the attached image. With the smaller "top", the piece could probably use a longer stem - but I'll leave that image tweek to someone else.
But back to the idea of referencing the source of iconic forms - like stemware, decanters and the like - Baccarat and Waterford are good places to start if the piece is inspired by leaded glass or crystal originals.
Re: Stemware - Look to Baccarat & Waterford? *LINK*
>Others may have a different experience, but it didn't take me very long to learn something about goblet bases from peoples comments and by what they bought at the art fairs. Most people approve of the base being close to the same diameter as the bowl at its widest point. Very long stemmed goblets are best when they are up to 1/3 larger than the bowl. Short stems can have a smaller base, but no smaller than 2/3 the bowl diameter. Those that met that criteria were sold, and those with small bases always came back home with me.
Re: Stemware - Look to Baccarat & Waterford? *LINK*
Clearly it's OK to discuss (in Text Only) a piece and note things you like or don't like, perhaps suggest changes to parts of it, wood, details, finish, etc..
And it's true that sometimes, a picture is worth a thousand words - or if done well - more than a thousand words.
But if you use an image of the piece and illustrate the change you would have described in a much longer text message THAT might / should require the permission of the maker of the piece prior to making the illustration "public"?
This piece was posted here earlier with photo attachment and though I searched this site for the name given for the contest, I wasn't able to find that message. Looked in the Members list and couldn't find the name either. I don't recall the subject line of the post with the attached image though I've so far searched through to and including "page 10" of this forum and haven't found it.
So - if anyone would knows the e-mail address of the maker, please e-mail it to me and I'll see if he/she has a problem with my posting a tweeked version of the piece alongside the original image and a link to my post.
If he/she objects then I'll ask Ellis if he'll take it down because I don't know how to withdraw a message I've posted here.
If, given the recent threads on "plagarism" and "who owns a shape", you may have had your tongue firmly planted in your cheek when you wrote your contribution to this thread. If not, the question might make a good topic for discussion in another thread.