>I blatantly stole this form from John when I took a class from him at the Appalacian Center for Crafts a few years ago. It's been a form that has worked quite well for me. We found an old pot up in a cupboard when we were snooping around, and John said it was one he had done many years previously. I promptly stole it and made one there in class to practice some new techniques I learned from him. As I recall, it's changed ever so slightly from the original, but that's because my hand is not the same as John's when I turn.
>The whole thing is ridiculous. It's like saying only one person can have an "eye" for a good form and that if anyone else comes up with a similar form in their turning, they are copying and can't possibly have the "eye" to come up with that form on their own. Out of curiosity, I went to the particular judge's web site (for the first time, I might add) to look at his gallery. I suppose all of my tiny vessels that I just call "minis" are direct copies of his "Spirit Vessels" which I had not even seen before. Bull. It's all BULL!
You bring up a good point....the vessel shape is simply a blank canvas; it's how you treat the canvas that makes it your own. For example, a platter, small box, or tall hollow form with the galloping horse motif would all be readily recognizable as "Molly" style pieces.
Now, here's the sticky point....say, hypothetically, that you teach a class on pyrography, and one student is particularly adept at replicating your horse motif and begins to blatantly use it, or something similar, in their work. His work begins to show up in galleries and in exhibits. This does happen, and the explanation is usually "Hey, I paid you to show me this technique, it's now MINE!"
Is it fair? Is it ethical? Should the AAW adopt guidelines ? Should someone ask permission to use a particular motif, or at least give credit when due? I believe that is where the real "plagiarism" issue lies.
>Seeing that it's stolen, you probably better turn it over to me and I will make sure the propery authorities are notified. We don't want you getting into any kind of trouble. Yes, I would do that for you :)
>First I had to decide whether I would respond to your questions for fear of continuing what I believe to be a silly debate. I think this whole issue is blown way out of proportion, and tends to stifle people from trying new (to them) things. But I don't want you to think I'm ignoring you.
When I teach a class on pyrography, or do a demo at a symposium I encourage folks to copy my techniques as a learning opportunity if that's a way for them to solidify the technique. Then I ask that they explore the technique in expressive ways that are unique to themselves, and their own interests. If horses start showing up in exhibits and galleries, well that's the chance I take. I don't have a monopoly on horses. Truth be told, I'd probably be a big admirer of the work. I like horses. I like to see other interpretations of horses. Should someone ask me for permission? Oh please! Does someone have to ask Andi permission to use a flower or leaf? Give me a break!
I've yet to see someone 'copy' another artists style, and have them consistently reproduce the original style, so that their work is indiscernable from the original. We can't help but express our individuality in our work. It will always come through unless a person is consciously, painstakingly, reproducing forgeries of the original artist.
Do I believe inspiration or credit for technique should be recognized and given it's due? Certainly. Do I think it should be done on every piece the person creates for the rest of their career? No. At first, yes, later as it evolves into their own style, that would be silly. If they don't give acknowledgement at first I think it's poor form (no pun intended), but to call it unethical is a bit extreme.
And for heaven's sake, keep the AAW out of it! The last think we need is more bureaucrat BS that can't be enforced anyway.
>I tend to agree with everything you say; I'm playing devil's advocate here....trying to draw a line between what is acceptable, and what is not. On one hand, even a simple form is off-limits; on the other hand, everything goes.
>...Ellsworth's copy comments, repeated several times in the judging remarks. I've known David since taking a class with him in 1991 and hold him in highest regard, but several times he has stated that when someone replicates the work of another like himself, it's time for him to try harder. When turners so often teach their own techniques there are going to be some who will copy as part of the learning process, and that's natural. When the copying becomes a problem of continued reproduction, that's when I begin to draw the line in the sand.