Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A Question For Long Time Turners

Posts

A Question For Long Time Turners

#1

A Question For Long Time Turners

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Have you ever heard of turning tools being correctly called knives?

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#2

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Dick Strauss

>I know that when they make veneer from logs, they use knives to separate the veneer sheet from the log. In essence, this is nothing more than a big lathe turning a log.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#3

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

john lucas

>I don't know if it's correct or not but I love to read the old books that I can find on turning. Many times they refer to them as knives and even chisels.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#4

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks John. I have heard of them being called chisels but didn't know they were ever called knives.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#5

Here is a Back Knife Lathe

Ron in Drums PA

>These lathes are still made today


img

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#6

Good Heavens!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#7

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

E.T.

>Yes, I first heard the term "knives" used at Provo at a conference (1980 or '81) by a couple of local production turners who were doing a demo. Soerenson, I think was/is their name. I think Rudy Osolnik used the term as well.

ET

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#8

Thanks

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#9

banned in California

john lucas

>If we call them knives we probably won't be able to carry them in California. Of course Gouge sounds pretty gruesome as well. Of course the word skew scares the you know what out of most turners.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#10

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Barry Turner

>Only when they are used in an automatic lathe. This doesn't exactly answer your question, does it?

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#11

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It sounds as if they were called knives according to John's old books.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#12

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Cyril Griesbach

>I'll take a guess at this and say that because most very early turnings were done with skews the term knives seemed adequate to describe these tools.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#13

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

>I looked up my copy of Frank Pain's book which he wrote in 1956. he doesn't mention knives but chisels are the term he uses for skews.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#14

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

>Peter Child also uses chisels to refer to skews. Of course, there are the straight across ones which I suppose would have to be called chisels. Do those still show up in catalogs? I had a few in the past and they worked okay, but didn't have the long point of a skew, so weren't as versatile.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#15

Re:I believe the important part of ......

Jamie Donaldson

>....this issue is to use proper current terminology when discribing our different tools. When teaching I make an effort to impart correct names for our various weapons, especially in cases like "spindle roughing gouge," and cringe when I hear another turner use the inspecific "chisel" term. Use of correct tool titles can be a safety issue, and conformity to standard terminology, including measurement of flute width vs. tool steel diameter, would benefit all.

Re: A Question For Long Time Turners

#16

Re:I believe the important part of ......

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Actually the subject came up when a guy who is working in the store said his shop instructor called them knives. He is in his 40's. I told him I had never heard that but would check it out.