>Good morning, folks. Well, our esteemed judges have reached their decision, and the "Elegant Forms" contest is now in the record books. Check out the contest results and read the judges comments on the entries.
Congratulations to the winners and all the folks who entered the contest, and special thanks to the judges and the sponsors.
>In my completely not humble opinion - You HAVE to be kidding. The piece # 852 by Janice Levi is way more elegant than the stuff selected, as were a few other pieces.
In the words of Jackson Browne at the Binghamton, NY concert - Sorry to be so honest.
>The entries were stupendous, one and all, and the contest a rousing success. I was most interested in the judges comments as I wondered if my eye was so in-elegant as to have guessed only one of seven of the winners correctly. The judges comments seemed to include just about every aspect of each piece, other than what made it "elegant" (in their collective opinion).
Alas, as a result today, I still haven't a clue as to what makes one turning more elegant than another. It would be REALLY interesting to see what the results of this contest would be if judged by members at large.
>I agree. At first I only looked at the entries very quickly -- stealing time away from a super-busy day, and took a closer look at only a few of them that caught my eye.
The off-axis hollow form with detached spindle that won first place didn't seem outstanding at first glance, but after looking at all the close-up photos, I was really impressed -- that's an awesome piece of work, and well deserving of the award.
We may not all agree on which piece is the best (in our view), but we can certainly all agree that these are beautiful turnings that are a pleasure to behold.
These contests can sometimes bring out a little too much of the competitive, and maybe not quite enough of the cooperative spirit. Just looking over the entries gives me ideas of some projects I'd like to try one day, and since I don't have time to turn much, it was a great pleasure to look over the entries.
>Getting feedback from any one of these judges is valuable. From all three even more valuable. And selected editing of comments from well established and well recognized artists/turners might make a nice quote on a resume or application to a show . . .
But it appears to me that not much time, if any, was spent on reading the text descriptions contestants provided, though poor photo quality was duly noted for several entries, mainly about hot spots and distracting backgrounds.
Granted, we are working in a visual medium (and thought of only as STATIC, any "movement" having to be implied) so What You See is important. But the title of the piece and an accompanying "artist's statement" / "story behind the piece" also can be important to selling the piece or noting something about the piece that still images can't convey. And if the piece is actually dynamic as opposed to dynamic by implication, still images, by themselves, can't adequately convey the piece - which is where the text becomes pretty important
It's interesting that while CD and DE commented on form and scale and proportions and "look", TB seemed to note things that are different from "the norm", not merely a variation of something familiar, but something not familiar at all or used in an unusual way.
Paradoxically, the winner chosen violates all the "classic rules" and classic shapes and forms. Everything about the piece is vaguely familiar - but different - pleasantly different - and yet somehow oddly elegant in a way you can't quite put your finger on. The fact that it's also technically tricky to do also appeals - at least to me.
Not sure how "whimsical" and "elegant" should be mutually exclusive yet "whimsical" is used in several of the comments as being a plus.
Next time I enter a contest I'm going to make a piece specifically for the contest instead of entering a piece done for a silent bid auction - which happend to be designed to be playful and whimsical - and happened to be kind of elegant.
I wish there was a way of doing a contest for actually dynamic pieces because including actual movement(s) could add a whole new dimension to turning. And an audience participation/interactive show could be a hell of a lot of fun - for both the audience as well as the contest participants.
Alas, it seems Look - But DO NOT Touch is where we're at - for now.
>As Barbara says above, what makes something elegant is subjective. However, that doesn't mean the word doesn't have a widely accepted meaning. It's ONLY on that basis that I might disagree with the judges' decisions. The winning entry is a wonderful turning and something I would be proud to own and even more proud to have made, but to my mind it exemplifies a lot of fine qualities none of which is elegance. It might be intricate, complicated, or ornate, but elegant is not the first adjective I'd apply to the piece. I doubt I'd ever use that word in connection with it.
None of this makes the decision of the judges wrong. The introduction to the contest makes it clear that elegance is a subjective term and that each turner should play with in coming up with a suitable entry. Fine. I'm simply saying (if not so simply phrasing) that I was more than just mildly surprised by what others consider elegant.
Here, by the way, is a definition of elegance that I found on Wikipedia. It does a good job of summarizing my understanding of the term:
Elegance is the attribute of being unusually effective and simple. It is frequently used as a standard of tastefulness, particularly in the areas of visual design and decoration. Elegant things exhibit refined grace and dignified propriety.
Some westerners associate elegance with simplicity and consistency of design, focusing on the main or basic features of an object, its dignified gracefulness, or restrained beauty of style.
Others understand the word in an opulent light as in tasteful richness of design or ornamentation "the sumptuous elegance of the furnishings."
The proof of a mathematical theorem is considered to have mathematical elegance if it is surprisingly simple yet effective and constructive; similarly, a computer program or algorithm is elegant if it uses a small amount of intuitive code to great effect.
In engineering, a solution may be considered elegant if it uses a non-obvious method to produce a solution which is highly effective and simple. An elegant solution may solve multiple problems at once, especially problems not thought to be inter-related.... [Internal references and links omitted. Emphasis in original.]
>When I think of "elegant", I think "feminine". Charming, refined, cultured, etc. When I turn a piece, feminine characteristics are almost always a prime consideration. Crazy? Picture any of us guy turners in a skirt...NOT a pretty picture! :)