For a few years, I was a very regular contributor here, then rather suddenly dropped off the face of the earth and apparently disappeared.
Truth is, I was starting a business and beginning to build a house, so I have been just too busy to spend much time here -- or at the lathe :~( The two time drains are related: I'm in the solar and renewable energy biz, and this house is a fairly cutting-edge green home.
We're building a straw bale house with a recycled 150-year-old timber frame, passive solar design, and active solar heat, hot water and electricity. This house is a demonstration site for a new solar heating and thermal storage system that I'll be installing around Northern VT & NH.
This is no veiled advertizement -- I don't want to sell you anything -- just thought some may want to see what we're up to, and that a few may even remember me here. Check out the blog (below) for house details as she goes up. I'm not a regular blogger, so it's not so much of a blog yet.
The good news is that when the new house is done, the old house will become my shop! I've never had a heated place to work, so that will be a real thrill.
>I know that timberframing is a premium over stick built, but I wondered what your costs looked like per square foot? I'm not 100% clear on what the hay bale walls look like int he structure, so it will be interesting to see how this works out.
Short answer is that this 1250 sq ft building would cost roughly $225,000, including site work and concrete (northern VT prices), but we'll end up spending around $180 - 190K.
Details: Building a straw bale house only saves you money if you do a lot of the labor yourself. Most straw buildings cost about 10% more than stick built, but that varies widely (and wildly) depending on what holds the roof up. We have a timber frame bearing the loads, while some people compress the bale walls, which then hold up the roof. That's known as Nebraska-style straw bale construction with supporting walls, as opposed to New Mexico style, with a wooden frame. They run threaded rods up through the bales and frame up wooden structures on top of the walls, and compress the walls to a desired amount before the roof goes on. Ours is quite the opposite: the roof must be in place and weather-tight before we start stacking up the bales.
The straw is a waste product that would otherwise be burned or mulched, so it is cool to use a waste product from the grain industry to insulate the walls. Many straw bale builders do all the wall work themselves, and save a lot of money. There are very few builders skilled and experienced in bale work in most areas of the country, so if you don't put in a lot of sweat equity, you'll pay quite a bit to get a crew in to do it. our straw is from Wheat and Barley grown in southern Quebec (only about 75 miles North), and baled for this sort of work at a farm in far-northern Vermont, on the Canadian border.
We're lucky that two very active green building groups are about 30 miles away, in Plainfield, VT: New Frameworks Natural Building and Natural Design-Build. They work with bales, timber frames, and all sorts of natural building, earthen floors, masonry heaters, etc...
Timber framing can cost much more than common stick-built framing, depending on who and how fancy. Stick built work with conventionally-sized lumber is very fast, and pretty cheap. Unfortunately, most stick built homes are poorly insulated, and very leaky. Since I'm aiming for a ZERO energy building, making all our heat and electricity on-site, true R-value* and great air sealing are very important.
*True R-value is decidedly *not* the number printed on fiberglass batts, since air moves so freely through them. An R-23 FG batt in a wall probably *performs* much closer to R-10 to R-12, but that's a whole 'nuther discussion... What we're after is high performance, and that opens up the discussion of up-front cost vs cost of operation.
If you have R-20+ below grade, R-35 or 40 walls, and R-65 - 80 in the cap, you'll spend about 10% more than code-built construction for stick-built structures. BUT, it might save you 60% - 70% or so on your heating and cooling bills forever. If the cash can be found or borrowed, the payback is often instantaneous -- the cost to borrow the money for construction is more than offset by the lower fuel costs, so a positive cash flow from the get-go.
We bought a 150-year-old timber frame removed from an old building that was being torn down. It cost us about $16,000 to have that taken apart, de-nailed somewhat, and trucked to our site. The building is fairly small -- 900 square feet on the ground floor, and only about 1250 with the small upstairs. We originally were shooting for about $135/ft, partly because the general contractor was so interested in the project he was willing to give us a great deal. The excavation costs were higher than we originally planned, and now that we've hired a different crew to work with the bales, the cost will end up closer to $160/sq.ft. or more. That's still pretty reasonable, but we'll end up doing a lot of the interior finish work ourselves over the winter months.
The blog has not caught up with the crew; the bale walls are being built right now, so by this weekend I should have more stuff up there to see.
I can only take a moment here now, but if you look into fire and flame tests of straw bale structures they very easily outperform conventional, stick-built construction. They actually win by miles upon miles...
If you're not familiar with straw bale buildings, they are very densely packed bales, and covered with stucco-like plasters inside and out. We're using natural clay-lime plasters, which end up more than 1-3/8" thick on each side. That leaves a very tightly-packed cellulose structure with no air available for flames.
Actually UN-plastered straw bale walls do pretty well, too!
Good to see your post and learn about what you are doing.
Your price is actually a little better than our price around here. I use $175.00 per square fee as a starting point when figuring out cost for a client, and generally goes up depending on options.
A couple here in this island build a straw bale house about 10 years ago.
I visited and was favorable impressed on the thermal performance, no drafts at all, and the quiet even at th epeak of a winter storm. They have a frame like you do and they platered the straw with mud, like the adobe houses, so it did look good and work quite well. Last year they got rid of the straw and replaced with blocks made out of wood chips and concrete, a canadian thing, the reason? Mice, they had batallions of the critters...
Good luck in your enterprises, I want to stop and visit you in one of our trips to VT, we have a daughter in Middlebury.
>Even though you have popped in from time to time, it's not like before. You are a very knowledgable and skilled turner and I always look forward to your comments.
Best of luck with your business and the house-and the SHOP !
*Usually* rats and mice are no problem-o with well-built *straw* buildings. They have no feed value (seed heads are already gone), and they are so densely packed and plastered in that they don't make good bedding, and there is very little oxygen in a well-built wall.
If the Maine folks near you used *hay* and not straw, or didn't pack 'em in really, really tight (ours get thumped in with a beetle or maul, and are tightened with a come-along or heavy-duty ratchet strap, and straw sheaves are then jammed in wherever possible between bales and along the timbers), or didn't maintain the tough plaster coating, mice could definitely be a problem. Our bale crew had not had a problem with rodents in any of their buildings, but they are very picky about how tightly the bales are forced into the walls, and use a very tough, heavy plaster. The plaster is made of 3 layers -- about 1.4" thick, and then 3 lime washes, which can be pigmented to many different colors. We are not planning to share our home with mousies.
One place that timber/straw buildings have seen premature failure is the formation of cracks where the straw and the frame meet. We're using strapping along the outside of the frame (screwed and sealed with adhesive caulking), and a 6" wide strip of 1/2" drywall sealed to that so it extends 4-5" along the inner wall along the timber frame.
The bales are wrapped very tightly against this drywall fin, and the first layer of interior plaster, which is thicker than the drywall, completely engulfs the drywall. Subsequent layers of plaster (up to about 1-3/8" thick, in total), embed that drywall and seal up against the strapping and timber frame, making a good, tight seal between the plaster and the frame with enough flexibility for seasonal movement. Any cracks that develop should be sealed with an application of lime plaster, or can be repaired with a batch of clay-, clay-lime-, or lime-plaster.
I'll be able to show that much better in photos on the blog when I get a chance to post that wall detail.
Here's a straw bale builder explaining the merits of straw bale construction -- see link, below.
Hope you can make it through sometime on your way to Burlington, Jorge; soon I may even have time to do a little turning!
*Usually* rats and mice are no problem-o with well-built *straw* buildings. They have no feed value (seed heads are already gone), and they are so densely packed and plastered in that they don't make good bedding, and there is very little oxygen in a well-built wall.
If the Maine folks near you used *hay* and not straw, or didn't pack 'em in really, really tight (ours get thumped in with a beetle or maul, and are tightened with a come-along or heavy-duty ratchet strap, and straw sheaves are then jammed in wherever possible between bales and along the timbers), or didn't maintain the tough plaster coating, mice could definitely be a problem. Our bale crew had not had a problem with rodents in any of their buildings, but they are very picky about how tightly the bales are forced into the walls, and use a very tough, heavy plaster. The plaster is made of 3 layers -- about 1.4" thick, and then 3 lime washes, which can be pigmented to many different colors. We are not planning to share our home with mousies.
One place that timber/straw buildings have seen premature failure is the formation of cracks where the straw and the frame meet. We're using strapping along the outside of the frame (screwed and sealed with adhesive caulking), and a 6" wide strip of 1/2" drywall sealed to that so it extends 4-5" along the inner wall along the timber frame.
The bales are wrapped very tightly against this drywall fin, and the first layer of interior plaster, which is thicker than the drywall, completely engulfs the drywall. Subsequent layers of plaster (up to about 1-3/8" thick, in total), embed that drywall and seal up against the strapping and timber frame, making a good, tight seal between the plaster and the frame with enough flexibility for seasonal movement. Any cracks that develop should be sealed with an application of lime plaster, or can be repaired with a batch of clay-, clay-lime-, or lime-plaster.
I'll be able to show that much better in photos on the blog when I get a chance to post that wall detail.
Here's a straw bale builder explaining the merits of straw bale construction -- see link, below.
Hope you can make it through sometime on your way to Burlington, Jorge; soon I may even have time to do a little turning!
They used straw right as it comes from the feed and seed store, they were not compressed it further and they thought that some of the mice came with the bales, and then, around here as soon as there is an enclosure, mice and ants move in.
Thanks for the link, things keep moving in the green housing field and one has to keep tabs on new ideas, products and procedures.
There is a book published in White River Junction about green stuff developed by a group in Colombia called "Gaviotas", that is also the name of the book. I called my attention specially a see-saw that when children play on it, they are actually pumping water from the well, have many other ideas that are worth looking into.
Great that you will have a heated shop, I still have a non heated one.
>Chelsea Green has some great titles. I had heard of this book, but had never seen it, and had long forgotten all about it -- I appreciate the link and the title. This should make a good winter read. Goodness, its already 10 years old!
I hope to get back over Albany/Saratoga way one of these days. My brother has lived and worked as a chef in Saratoga for years, so I have multiple reasons to come down there.
I'm really, *really* new to blogging, so I'm not so sure how this works... If you sign up to "follow" or "join" the blog, don't you get e-mail notices of all updates? I really don't know, and won't have time to figure it all out, but there is some feature for update notification...
I can only abuse my welcome so much with OT posts about my house project here. When the "old house" becomes the "new shop", (with HEAT, no less), well that I'll let everyone know about!
Didn't see your response until this morning -- sorry I wasn't paying attention.
Fires need combustibles and air. The bales are packed very tightly, so they don't get much air in the interior, so they char and smolder on the edges. They resist the spread of fire about 3x better than stick-built walls. When completely encased in plaster (well over 1" thick, inside and out), there's even less oxygen available, and the fire safety is much better than that.
Right now, we have plaster on only one exterior surface, and straw bits and ends piled about 4" - 6" deep throughout the building (from trimming and fitting the bales), so the fire danger is VERY high! We'll be raking up all the chaff, and using it as an additive to the base coat of plaster, so as soon as the stuff is all bagged up I'll feel a lot better. None of the natural builders smokes, but both of the guys working on framing and roofing do, so I want no cigarettes in the house at all!