Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Fair price for an 18" platter?

Posts

Fair price for an 18" platter?

#1

Fair price for an 18" platter?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Last week I was just setting up and a fellow glanced to an 18" x 2 1/4" black walnut platter I just made the night before and had to have it.

I asked $300.00, it has a very nice shape although the wood itself rather plain, it took endless sanding to get rid of all marks, a humble walnut oil finish, and it sold in less than 5 minutes. I am not complaining about that, just wondering if my price was too low.

Later on the day, a lady came to my house and grabbed a 13" x 3" curly maple bowl, with a knock out figure and a very nice shape. Sold st $250.00

Are my prices too low? This 2 pieces sold so fast I did not even had a chance to make pictures. So I wonder...

I have more walnut platter blanks, 16", 18" and a 20", also more of the same curly maple.

What would be a fair price for each?

TIA for all suggestions

Jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#2

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Barry Elder

>Who knows! Maybe we have shoppers who have been hoarding their dollars for fear of a depression for so long that they are beginning to get cabin (shopping) fever. Last week the man who rents the space next to me asked if his wife could come in and look at the pieces I was making and I said it was OK, but she should be aware that it is a working shop, not a studio or gallery. Thirty minutes later she came in and I showed her some very nice pieces but she spied a small "hollow form" of Norfolk Island Pine that was covered with dust and dirt from just sitting around. She asked to see it, I wiped it off, and she offered me $300 for it. After I got up off the floor, I told her I would be happy to sell it to her after it was finished. Who knows!

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>A fair price for an 18" Walnut platter?

I think you are about right but of course it depends on the quality of the timber and all the rest! (Currency Converter gave me �188.00 UKP which is high but not unreasonable)

I have seen some real rubbish at way over prices but for some reason the members of the public pay out!

I wish I knew the secret!!!

Peter.

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#4

They paid it. . . .

Charles Yawn

>You took it.

That makes it a fair price, right?

Charles

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#5

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barry,

I hope you are right and people are ready to spend some, we can use it.

Thanks for the chuckle!

Jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#6

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Peter,

The timber is excellent, dense and very dark, but little figure. I got it from a dealer that claims it was harvested 80 years ago and it was an expensive blank. It is the first 18" platter I ever made, so I was not sure of how much to ask, nice to know I was more or less on the mark. Hate to over charge.

Thank you very much, much appreciated.

Jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#7

I guess...

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>You are right.

Thanks,

Jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#8

Re: I guess...

Barry Irby

>You have to ask yourself Which would I rather have, $300 in hand or a nice platter with a $400 price tag on it?

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#9

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>That's about what I sell my platters for. I have went up or down from that by $100 depending on figure etc.

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Congrats on the $550

steve antonucci

>Mark the next one up to $400 and see what happens. Put it next to a $300 one and make any excuse you want why there is a difference. If you can talk someone into the extra $100, then you are priced too low.

Steve

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#11

Re: Congrats on the $550

Mac Ray

>If you are happy with that,it's the right price....your quality is right up there.......

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#12

ebd

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

ebd

>I don't think it's likely that "we" CAN overcharge. If you consider the years of study and practice involved and the wood wasted. If you consider the time and concentratation to produce the work involved. If you consider the amount and cost of the equipment involved. Sorry, I don't think almost any buyer pays anywhere near a fair price. We almost always get less than fair value. We sell at the price we can. People buy or do not. I doubt it's ever very fair. It's what we accept.

That being said for the "unknown" turner, I think that the prices demanded by the "fame & name" turners are quite outrageous, both for their goods and their "educational opportunities" based on a quality differential. Could that be envy - perhaps - BUT I think not. It's the same logic that tells me that no sports figure, no head of business, no one in any field is SO much better, SO superhuman that they are worth huge millions or billions over the very next guy down. Sorry to bust anyone's bubble, but there just isn't any where near that much variation in human ability. The brand name in guildgraft, as elsewhere, is most often just pure bullshit, who got there first, who had the best promotional publicity, who had a fad, or who said most strongly "look at me - I'll show you the way". Ellsworth at the expense of Raffin - I could go on but enough said.

Sorry to be so honest.

The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by

those who have not got it.

-- George Bernard Shaw

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#13

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>In my area, $300 for an 18" 2-1/2" deep platter is slightly on the high side of normal, unless it's exceptional. Remember, most people don't know and usually don't care how much work you put into it. They just know if they like it or not. However, that price is probably low for an quality 18" bowl. A lot of people do like larger size works, and my larger pieces seems to sell quicker than the my smaller stuff. Your area may be different.

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#14

Agree With That!

Texian

>

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#15

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Nice to know Gary,

How much would you ask for a 20" black walnut, very dark but plain?

I have 2 blanks from the same stock as the 18" sold.

thanks.

Jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#16

You hit the nail on the head

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barry,

That is why I prefer to sell directly to the people, and have the cash to buy more wood and do it all over again. : )

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#17

Re: Congrats on the $550

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Thanks Steve.

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#18

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Hi Bruce,

Around here is the same, both with the prices and with the fact that the bigger pieces sell a lot sooner than the small ones. My best sellers by numbers, are the 14" bowls or platters, priced at $175.00, I sell about 4 of those for each $35.00 7" bowl.

Thanks

jorge

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#19

Re: Congrats on the $550

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Thanks Ray,

see you soon.

Re: Fair price for an 18" platter?

#20

You are right

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>