Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Home made McNaughton tool

Posts

Home made McNaughton tool

#1

Home made McNaughton tool

john lucas

>Ever since getting the Coring tools I have wanted more to help control the shape and make some smaller ones. I have also been using heat to bend my tools up until now and I wanted to be able to bend them cold. I built a bending jig out of steel and it worked great so I built one out of steel and plastic Decking. It also works.

My first test was to build a smaller coring tool with a tighter circle. I also put a carbide cutter in the tip. Mike Hunter is re-tipping the McNaughton cutters with his carbide tips. They work like a charm. I wanted to try and mount one myself. The only way to learn to use my metal tools is to do the work myself so I got one of the cutters from Mike and then milled out the slots and drilled and tapped the holes. I definitely need to learn how to set my milling vise to 30 degrees. I'm sure the way I did it wasn't very accurate. It worked out but I had to sneak up on it.

Below is the photo of the large McNaughton tools along with my new one.


img

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#2

Bending jig

john lucas

>Here is a photo of the bending jig that I made out of Plastic Decking. I used 3/4" Hot rolled steel to make the pins. You simply put the steel inbetween the pins and bend. Move it 3/8" or so and bend again. If you sneak up on the shape it works out pretty well.


img

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#3

Close up of tip 

john lucas

>


img

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#4

Re: Close up of tip

ken ward

>Looks like you got it goin the John,looks pretty good.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#5

Re: Close up of tip

Mark Wollschlager

>Hi John,

Looks really nice.

It looks like the new cutter has a bit thinner kerf than the standard cutter.

How is it for chip/shaving clearance in comparison?

Mark.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#6

haven't use it yet. I'll let you know.

john lucas

>I haven't used mine yet. I'll let you know.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#7

Re: Bending jig

Barry Irby

>John, I have not made my own, but a friend and I repent mine and they sure work better.

I think you need to draw two concentric circles at the inner and outer radius of the cutter. Visualize the cutter cutting the circle. The blade has to fit in the kerf. The kerf has to be wide enough so that the vertical part of the blade will fit loosely into the kerf. Think of the blade as being a tangent to the circle. I'm not making this very clear, but I thank you will get it when you use the cutter. The blade should be a section of a sphere that matched the radius of the blade.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#8

Shine the metal,

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>and it will cut easier.

Good job!

Lets us know how it works.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#9

Re: Shine the metal,

john lucas

>I am going to clean up the hot rolled steel. I couldn't find any cold roll around here conveniently. Before I make any more tools I'll order some. It would keep me from having to sand the outside to get it smooth.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#10

Rob Wallace

Re: Bending jig

Rob Wallace

>Barry wrote:

"John, I have not made my own, but a friend and I repent mine and they sure work better"

I am sure if the blades have sinned and repented, they certainly should work better with the Big Guy on your side!

Amen.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#11

Re: Bending jig

john lucas

>I understand perfectly. Different arcs produce a lot of different bowls depending on how you start it into the wood. You can also feed it into the wood differently on several passes to enlarge the kerf and change the shape slightly. You do risk making either a funnel of a thick bottom so you need to experiment with this. Since I only had 2 cutters to begin with I had to experiment with this a lot.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#12

Reminds me of the joke-repaint and thin no more

john lucas

>

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#13

Gotta love Spell Checker......

Barry Irby

>Apparently Google Spell Check does not recognize rebent and changed it to repent. Some of the other substitution it has made over the years have been even funnier.

I should repent from some of the things I have said while struggling with the coring system.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#14

Re: Bending jig

Barry Irby

>I'm having trouble explaining this. My point is that right at the track of the knife, the knife is sliding into a space that it shaped like (( not ||.

I also persist in believing that the curve of the knife MUST be a segment of a circle. You can change the shape of the bowl to something other than a perfect segment of a sphere by changing the angle at which you insert the knife into the blank, but the path of the knife must be a segment of a sphere, unless you widen the kerf.

Polish the knives to make it easier to slide them through the gate.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#15

Rob Wallace

I thought about EXACTLY the same joke John!

Rob Wallace

>

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#16

Re: Bending jig

john lucas

>I agree that the knives should be a partial arc or a circle. I'm not sure it's necessary to polish the sides (I'm going to do it anyway) When I'm working with it as long as I'm cutting correctly the sides barely touch. If it does it's usually the bottom left and top right where the torquing of the blade makes it rub.

I always appreciate your input, thanks

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#17

Re: Close up of tip

robo hippy

>John,

I got one blade from Mike to experiment with and he had a long pointy tip similar to the one on your blade, and the blade looks similar to yours. I went with a square cutter. I ground off more of the heel of the blade as it would cut fine down to close to where you can break the blank off, but wouldn't go farther. Grinding off the heel helps this. Also, the cutters need to be 3/8 inch wide or there abouts. If it isn't that wide, you will need to cut a kerf and a half to get all the way down. The only problem I have with the Hunter tips is that we can't sharpen them. I know, I am a cheap b******.

The blades do need to be an arc of a circle. If they aren't it is almost impossible to core because the blade will not track in a circular path so you will have to do a lot of adjusting to the cut to get all the way down. This is one of the problems with the McNaughton system. The blades are stamped, and the bends are inconsistant. Having a blade bender like yours is a big help to fine tuning the blades. Having a template to check them with is good as well.

robo hippy

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#18

Re: Close up of tip

john lucas

>Thanks for the input Reed. I am drawing the arcs on paper with a compass and then matching this. I finding that you have to be careful when bending because it's very easy to twist them if you pull up or down slightly. Fortunately it's easy to correct with a large crescent wrench.

Re: Home made McNaughton tool

#19

Re: Close up of tip

robo hippy

>When I bend mine, I have them in the handle. When they are twisted from heavy use and catches, I clamp them in a vice, and apply a little armstrong presuasion with a big monkey wrench, just like what you are doing.

Kids and their toys!

robo hippy