Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

falling, falling, into commercialism

Posts

falling, falling, into commercialism

#1

falling, falling, into commercialism

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

>Background: I began turning before there was internet, multi media, or a local club to help. All my (early) learning came from slick books and magazines from Barnes and Noble. Many of my "teachers" from these sources happened to be from "the old country" and, "from the old school". (What a no-no to refine a shape with abrasives!)

My father was a tradesman that came up from the old school as well, and I had many of the old school cliches hammered into me as a young man. to this, add that I am, in life, attracted to ancient zen, sufi,and Asian respect for beauty. Yes, Wabi-Sabi is sometimes a part of my work if you know what you are looking for.

It should be no surprise then, that my work on the lathe for many, many years tended to strive always for perfection...(NEVER achieved)..

And I tended to be rather critical of my fellow turners that displayed

works with tool marks, sanding scrathes, tear-out, chuck divots, etc, etc, etc,.

About four months ago, I stepped out of my up-tight mind set, by realizing that buyers, at least the tourist buyers and local homemaker buyers...seemed to give a rat's patootie about almost all of that "old school" do it the time honored way...15 layers of pure tungoil method. Etc., etc. Often buyers had little sense about "how good the piece was" but fussed instead over it's possible fit in Aunt Matilda's Armoire.

I have been released, in a way, from my own narrow thinking. Turning to sell...specifically to sell, requires a keener sense of time/motion efficiencies...there will be a point when you must stop with the finish fanaticism, stop with the jewelers loupe scoping for 1200 scratches, and a time to put it on the shelf.

If I were to teach a class today, I would require my students to plan a project that would utilise Bondo and body file....that would have broke me of sucking eggs I'll bet!!

You comments please!

Mike

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#2

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Russ Fairfield

>You are trying to sell your work in all the wrong places. Get out of the flea-market and find a better venue. There is always a market for quality work, and quality sells.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#3

Mike and Russ, you are ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>both right. Quality does sell, but not at flea markets nor in economically depressed areas where the potential buyer doesn't care about names like Krenov, Maloof, Nakashima, and Moore. On the other hand, there comes a time when you must stop fiddling with the speakers and go ahead and start dancing. I think some turners miss a market because they put their noses in the air and look down on items with a use. There is certainly a place for beautiful turned art. But there is also a place for an Ikebane, a salad bowl, and a serving platter.

Ed

PS: The inclusion of my name above was absolutely intended as humor, and nothing more.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#4

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Bernie Weishapl

>I have to agree with Ed. I think it pretty much depends on where you are at. My son in Richmond has sold some of my what I consider high dollar HF's, vases, and bowls for $125 to $350. Where we live here in Kansas in a rural area they won't buy the high dollar stuff sanded to 1200 grit and finished all shiney. They want a knock around bowls that Aunt Harriet can use in the kitchen. I have several pieces in two galleries that have been sitting now for a year. I have sold a couple of the better pieces but not much.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#5

I turn for my enjoyment and for profit

john lucas

>I do need to make money with my turning. That being said I am also proud of what I do and won't sell something that isn't sanded and finished well. I do my own little time/vs money studies and try to find more efficient ways of doing things. There are other ways to cut the cost without cutting the quality.

I learned to make the best use of the cutting tools. Cutting fast with certain cuts and then clean with others. This both reduces the time takes to make something as well as the sanding time. If I can make that last pass with a clean sharp gouge I can start sanding with 220. It did take longer to make that last pass or two but I've reduced my sanding time and the cost of sandpaper I didn't use.

On my ornaments and mirrors (except for some special woods) it doesn't change their final appearance if I sand beyond 400. Consequently I don't. On pieces that do require sanding to 2000 grit, I have the paper and will do it.

Finish is something I'm always playing with. Trying to find something that's both fast and looks and feels well is always a challenge. especially in my unheated shop with no spray booth.

I find it a matter of honor to say I put my best foot forward. If I don't sell I find a different market. Which I did have to do because the markets around here were just as you described. I could sell a poorly done for $25 before a good quality bowl of $60. I simply refused to sell or make the poor quality work so I had to find new venues.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#6

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Rick_Allen

>Selling our turnings is for many of us a validation of our work. Selling is work itself. So are you validating your work or are you validating your ability to sell?

If you are looking to making money by turning wood then you have three options:

Learn how to sell

Turn architectural items to order

Turn exquisite items that someone else sells for you

Back to validation. Validate your own work. Most of the time we know what is less than perfect about a specific turning. Listen to your fellow woodturners. The buying public has very little to do with validating your worth as a woodturner.

About 11 years ago my wife and I went to a craft show. I was new to turning and had always disliked trolling craft shows. There was a guy with a large booth who sold large hollow forms. I inspected several of his turnings and noticed that the objects were thick and clunky. I thought there was a reason for the thick hollow forms. His selling point was "historical" wood. Each turning had a magazine or newspaper article about where the wood came from. He was validating for the buyer that they were buying a piece of history. I asked him why his hollow forms were so thick (Some places as much as an inch thick). He said that he lost fewer pieces when he left the hollow form thick. This craft show was sparsely attended an he had not made a sale that day.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#7

Steven Antonucci

No matter what, my name is still on it.

steve antonucci

>Funny that you should bring up this question, as I was turning "craft items" for a fair that my wife asked me to makes some "stuff for sale" to support my daughter's dance studio. I first thought of my audience, likely the mother's of the girls and their friends.

While I wouldn't normally turn these types of items with the intent of selling them, I decided on small icicles ornaments and other "under $10" items that could be made quickly. I am a competent turner and I cut very cleanly, so a minimum of sanding (one swipe with 320 grit) was all that was needed.

Yet all of the things I made yesterday were economically infeeasible. Why? Because my "name" was going on them. If a bead was wrong, it had to be fixed. If a piece didn't look right, it didn't come off the leathe until I was satisfied. I owed it to the buyer to do the best work I could for whatever price I assigned that item. For me, the cost of putting out substandard (MY STANDARD) far outweighs the cost of my time.

"Life is too short to make wood crappy."

Steve

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Mike and Russ, you are ...

Keith Tompkins

>Ed, I thought you meant William Moore :)

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#9

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

>Shame on you Russ Fairfield for suggesting that I sell in flea markets! Hop across the sate and find my work in Northwest Fine Woodworking downtown Seattle, Mother Goose in Portland, Ashland Hardwoods, Ashland, and, most recently an exclusive with Hanna Galleries in my hometown.

Perhaps you did not read my posting. Flea Markets! Harumph!!

`

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#10

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Joe Flemig

>Mike,

Every time I travel through tourist areas like northern California, I am appalled at the lack of quality in the turnings. I was recently in a redwoods area gift shop and it had inferior pieces, in my opinion. Tourists might be caught up in the magnificence of the redwoods and feel that a redwood knickknack is the great memory, but I would be embarrassed with these pieces.

Understandably, the market will support this level of turning and if you want to take advantage of it, that is up to you. Given the galleries you are in, I do not think they would represent you with that level of turning.

Ultimately, if you make a living doing it, you need to enjoy it. If you don't, then you will suffer and the business will be more difficult. I would rather sell what I enjoy producing and am proud of, than to down-sell for a lower end market. Joe

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#11

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Russ Fairfield

>Then you already know that quality sells, and I don't understand your question. There is nothing wrong with turning to a market price point, but that doesn't mean the quality has to suffer. Even in the tourist trap venues, quality still sells.

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

#12

Re: falling, falling, into commercialism

Mike Jones

>Joe, You are so right! The redwood coast offers the very worst of the turners products. The VERY worst, is a turner there that uses a "woodworm", or screw chuck, and leaves the hole in the bottom...covered with a pretty foil sticker....of his laquered bowls.