Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Comparing English M2 Tools

Posts

Comparing English M2 Tools

#1

Comparing English M2 Tools

DC Powers

>I'm curious if anyone has noticed a difference in the performance of one brand of turning tools. Specifically, between Crown, Hamlet, Sorby, and Henry Taylor. I've got a few of each. I'm starting to come to the conclusion that my Henry Taylor tools keep and edge longer and sharpen easier than the Sorbys.

No way of quantifying absolutely, just something I've noticed.

Anyone else have any thoughts or prefer one of these brands over another?

BTW, I'm only talking about M2, not Kryo or Powdered metal, Thompson, etc.

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

#2

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

ET

>Yes, I have noticed that Sorbey M-2 HSS gouges do not stay sharp as long as my Henry Taylor ones.

ET

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Not being awkward but I too have a selection of gouges from those makers and find that the grind I put on my Sorby gouges tends to last longer than my others, especially the one that is Titanium coated.

Regards, Peter.

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

#4

Re: Comparing English M2 Tools

Russ Fairfield

>For me, the shape and finish of the flute, and the handle, is more important than who made it. I have never been able to tell any difference between Crown, Hamlet, Sorby, or Taylor when it comes to how easy they are to grind or how long they hold an edge.

I prefer the parabolic shape of the Superflute bowl gouge by Henry Taylor and others that use a similar flute. I have never liked the wider "U" shape of the Sorby bowl gouges.

The finish of the flute is important because the smoother the flute, the easier it is to get a sharp cutting edge. Some of the tools have deep grooves in the surface of the flute. The flutes in the Sorby gouges tends to be quite a bit rougher than the others.

Having said all of this, I have more Sorby tools than any other, except bowl gouges. None of my bowl gouges are by Sorby, but for everything else there isn't enough difference to matter, and the Sorby tools are always available at Woodcraft, and there is a Sorby sale every year.