>My first choice would be American made Doug Thompson tools. I think his web is www.thompsontools.com. My Nova MT2 is great but I don't know if they make an MT1. Worth checking into. Good luck.
>Basic tools: 1" or 1 1/4" skew (or 1 3/8" + 1/2" skew), 3/8" spindle gouge, standard rectangular parting tool (3/16"-1/4"), 3/4" or 1" spindle roughing gouge. You can add other sizes of spindle gouges, perhaps a beading tool/square parting chisel(3/8"). The size of the work you plan on doing should help determine size - I use 1/2" gouges when I do bedposts, but 3/8" can do a really wide range, down to very small detail.
I too recommend Doug Thompson tools, as well as Crown, and Sorby is pretty reliable top quality for the basics as well.
>Sorby's are very good tools and I have several. I even have some old Sorby's with orange handles in carbon steel. The bad thing is Sorby's prices have inflated dramatically over the years, to the point where I'm not so sure they are still a good value. I can't fault the quality of the tools though.
>I have used all the above mentioned and they are good tools,BUT I don't buy anything but Dougs tools now.I also have the centers from PSI and no complaints there.
I have made a few hundred Shaker spindles in a past life. I just used a 1 1/4" spindle roughing gouge and a parting tool It was a Sorby and did a great job. I could use it with a slight planing cut and get a great surface that could be sanded starting at 220 grit.
Now if you are intending to make the long back posts, It would be wise to get a 3/8" spindle gouge to do the slight cove at the top below the acorn finial.
I too am a big fan of Doug's tools. I am not sure if he has the big roughing gouge in stock right now.
I guess I am saying to gets Doug's tools if you can, but many will do the job on what you want to do. But I would be all over his 3/8" spindle gouge. It is a great one. And your first project can be a handle for it.
Also, as for the spur center, it is not a critical piece when spindle turning. Just go the sears and buy one of their spurs centers. I do know that they use to carry them for the no 1 Morse tapers
>If you going to be doing any finials I would suggest you try Doug's new 1/4" spindle gouge. It is great for those very fine details. I bought one a few weeks ago and it is sweet for that purpose.
>I had this issue when I first got Doug's tools, and I used his 1-1/4" skew chisel to make a handle for itself, then put it together and used it to make handles for the other tools I bought from Doug.
>Scott, If you are worried about being safe. Get yourself a 1" maple dowel rod and drill a hole about 2 1/2" in the end the size of the gouge(Mark St. Leger's SRG} and tape around the dowel with packing tape the string type cut dowel to the length you want and you have a good temporary handle that would be safe. Glue gouge in hole you can cut wood off after you turn a good handle. This may sound dumb but if you are worried about safety its a quick fix for a handle.
Might be wise - before deciding on tools and which ones to get - initially - to have some one who has been turning a while to show you the range of tools, and how their used - and maybe sharpened - correctly (boy is that an opening for a long discussion).
I'm just down the hill from you, near between Lark @ 17 and Camden/San Tomas @ 17. I've got a turning tool case full of gouges and chisels you can play with - or borrow and try out - though I'd STRONGLY suggest you have someone show you how to use them safely - something I haven't done yet - which is why most of them are sitting in the tool case unused - except for three. Those are
- 1" roughing gouge
- spearpoint/diamond cross section parting tool
- 3/4" curved cutting edge skew
I also use three other tools that are too small to fit in the case
- 1/2" curved edge skew from a "miniature" set
- 1/4" regular old bench chisel used as a thin bedan
- thin parting tool made from a SawzAll blade with the teeth ground off - and a blue masking tape "handle" (I AM going to make a real handle for it one of these days - honest.)
I'm using the MiniMonster Captured System at the moment so it's out if you want to try it.
I can show you how to use a roughing gouge, a curved edge skew, a bedan wanna be and the thin parting tool as well as the diamond parting tool. The bowl gouges, spindle gouges, scrapers and the others you'll need to find someone else for how to use them.
As I mentioned earlier, the Silicon Valley Woodturners meet every Wednesday night - the first of Wednesday of the month is the formal club meeting, the in between Wednesday nite's are informal Saw Dust Session where there's no agenda and a great time to ask questions. The club has some really experienced turners who act as mentors to club members.
E-mail me directly, I provide my phone number and we can set something up.
I'm of the Buy Once, Cry Once school for big ticket stationary tools - but for turning tools, well I've got a dozen or so and only actually use a few. So before you buy the best you can afford, find out which ones you like and are apt to use regularly. THEN fork over the cash and enjoy using them.