How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?
charlie belden
>How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?
In an earlier thread "Pucker factor: new thread", Keith Tompkins posed the following question
"In the case of the turner, suppose we compare the progress of two turners.. one continued to learn from his mistakes, while the other took lessons from a skilled turner. After a period of say, a year, who do you think has made the most progress?"
And Keith followed that by making the following point
"... practice doesn't make perfect, proper practice of good technique makes perfect...."
That got me to thinking about �progress�. I looked up the definition of progress in the Random House Dictionary and found eleven definitions. The first definition seems to be most suited to Keith�s context and implied arguement - The Taught will make more progress [in technique] than the Self Taught.
1. a movement toward a goal or to a further or higher stage: the progress of a student toward a
degree.
But the eleventh definition better defines what progress is to me.
11. to grow or develop, as in complexity, scope, or severity; advance: Are you progressing in your piano studies?
And the synonyms better differentiate the two views of progress
Synonyms:
1. advance, progression. . . .11. proceed; develop, improve, grow, increase.
The Piano Playing Analogy seems a good one for comparing the two definitions.
The formally trained pianist knows the theory of music - at least the theory of music in his cultural context (different cultures can have quite different theories of music - compare Beethoven�s symphonies to the ragas of Inida - VERY different). And she/he knows how and why a piano does what it can do - which key, struck how hard, and allowed to vibrate unimpeded - or dampened by a foot pedal, how to read and write music using standardized format and notes. The formally trained pianist will also have studied both the music of the master composers as well as the techniques of the master pianists. And there�s practice, practice and more practice behind every pianist. A pianist is the product of a very structured training process
The self taught piano player on the other hand, lacking the formal structure and theory of music �plays by ear� - �this key, played this way will produce this sound� - �these four sounds, played in this order and at this rate (tempo), this loud, will sound nice, or interesting, or Grooves�.
Today, we have a very broad range of types of music available to listen to - to experience - and/ or to try and play. Who do you think is most responsible for what is argueably progress in music - the taught - or the self taught?
For me, as basically a self taught turner, never having taken an actual turning lesson - from a skilled turner (sure, I�ve read - and looked at the pictures - books, magazine articles, and yes I�ve attended demonstrations by a few well known turners) - I measure my turning progress by the range of pieces I�ve turned and the ideas I�ve been able to actually make a real object more or less as I envisioned them - or that I recognized while �just turning�. None of my stuff would ever be described as technically perfect from a technique view point. But I�m not focused on technique. What I�m after is turning things that interest me - and maybe interest someone else. HOW I get there is far less important than getting there.
So how do YOU define progress for YOUR turning journey?



