Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

Posts

How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#1

How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

charlie belden

>How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

In an earlier thread "Pucker factor: new thread", Keith Tompkins posed the following question

"In the case of the turner, suppose we compare the progress of two turners.. one continued to learn from his mistakes, while the other took lessons from a skilled turner. After a period of say, a year, who do you think has made the most progress?"

And Keith followed that by making the following point

"... practice doesn't make perfect, proper practice of good technique makes perfect...."

That got me to thinking about �progress�. I looked up the definition of progress in the Random House Dictionary and found eleven definitions. The first definition seems to be most suited to Keith�s context and implied arguement - The Taught will make more progress [in technique] than the Self Taught.

1. a movement toward a goal or to a further or higher stage: the progress of a student toward a

degree.

But the eleventh definition better defines what progress is to me.

11. to grow or develop, as in complexity, scope, or severity; advance: Are you progressing in your piano studies?

And the synonyms better differentiate the two views of progress

Synonyms:

1. advance, progression. . . .11. proceed; develop, improve, grow, increase.

The Piano Playing Analogy seems a good one for comparing the two definitions.

The formally trained pianist knows the theory of music - at least the theory of music in his cultural context (different cultures can have quite different theories of music - compare Beethoven�s symphonies to the ragas of Inida - VERY different). And she/he knows how and why a piano does what it can do - which key, struck how hard, and allowed to vibrate unimpeded - or dampened by a foot pedal, how to read and write music using standardized format and notes. The formally trained pianist will also have studied both the music of the master composers as well as the techniques of the master pianists. And there�s practice, practice and more practice behind every pianist. A pianist is the product of a very structured training process

The self taught piano player on the other hand, lacking the formal structure and theory of music �plays by ear� - �this key, played this way will produce this sound� - �these four sounds, played in this order and at this rate (tempo), this loud, will sound nice, or interesting, or Grooves�.

Today, we have a very broad range of types of music available to listen to - to experience - and/ or to try and play. Who do you think is most responsible for what is argueably progress in music - the taught - or the self taught?

For me, as basically a self taught turner, never having taken an actual turning lesson - from a skilled turner (sure, I�ve read - and looked at the pictures - books, magazine articles, and yes I�ve attended demonstrations by a few well known turners) - I measure my turning progress by the range of pieces I�ve turned and the ideas I�ve been able to actually make a real object more or less as I envisioned them - or that I recognized while �just turning�. None of my stuff would ever be described as technically perfect from a technique view point. But I�m not focused on technique. What I�m after is turning things that interest me - and maybe interest someone else. HOW I get there is far less important than getting there.

So how do YOU define progress for YOUR turning journey?

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#2

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Like you (quote): For me, as basically a self taught turner, never having taken an actual turning lesson, (unquote) I am exactly the same.

But that is where we differ, I have been turning bowls, dishes and platters only for the past 16 years and I measure my progress not in the diversity but in the consistency of quantity of output with consistent quality!

I still have the very first bowl I ever made and it is good to look at it now and then and congratulate myself that quality has definitely improved.

Regards, Peter.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#3

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

charlie belden

>So in your case, do you think taking lessons from a skilled turner would have gotten you to techniques which in turn would have made your progress quicker or was finding techniques through trial and error or developing your own techniques that worked for you a key component of your progress?

Did you start out wanting to make bowls, plates and platters and then concentrate on just those forms - or did you try all sorts of turning before focusing on these types of turning?

I think other turners can act at inspirations rather than teachers of technique(s).

Not having taken lessons, were there a few turners whose works you were attracted to and chose to initially emulate before finding your own "voice" or did you independently develop your own methods and techniques to create ideas you came up with?

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#4

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I have been turning for 7 years now and haven't made any progress at all. I'm still searching for what I want from woodturning.

Now, having made that statement, I'll try to explain. I started turning because I wanted to turn bowls. So, I bought a second-hand lathe and a set of tools and turned a bowl. I had no idea what I was doing, but I actually had a bowl from that first piece of wood. I scoured the internet for sources of information about turning and found Badger Pond. I had access to more information than I would have ever believed existed. I found our local club and joined. At meetings, I listened and asked questions. I've attended several local and regional gatherings, AAW symposia, and spent time with fellow turners.

My formal education is in Art History and I've "played" around with several of the different fine arts. Ever since I finished college, though, I have been searching for "the" art form with which to express myself. I finally discovered photography and I now almost exclusively shoot black and white infrared. I also discovered woodturning, which is what this is all about.

Back to turning wood. While searching for what I wanted to say with woodturning, I have become interested in many different styles, forms, etc. and tried to learn as much as possible about them. And, while I still haven't found what I want to accomplish, I have used everything I've turned to keep practicing the techniques I have seen others use. By doing this, I'm still learning, and hopefully, when I discover what I want, I'll have the skill to execute it.

Because my search continues, I feel that I really haven't progressed all that much. And that may be what my journey is all about.

keithz

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Charlie, I think one could write a book on this subject...I look at this subject from two different perspectives; as a turner and cabinetmaker, and as a musician. As a cabinetmaker, I went from newbie to the president's assistant in seven years. The company I worked for wanted to enter the commercial restaurant furniture business, including chairs. When I started the company produced only a handful of chairs a day; I designed and built fixtures, including pneumatic boring jigs for chair seats. The company received many patents for special equipment I designed. When I left the company, we were producing 300 chairs a day, every day. This kind of work came natural to me...it was easy. I'm pretty much a self-taught turner; some of my techniques are quite unorthodox, I've never felt limited as to what I could create based on my tool technique. I have taught hundreds of turners through various schools and privately. I'v worked hard to develop my own turning style, and don't attend too many classes or demonstrations; I don't want to be influenced too heavily by other's work or techniques.

On the other hand, I struggled as a musician. I had a very difficult time making any progress at all. I finally concluded I needed lessons, and sought out a well-regarded teacher. Much better, but eventually, I hit a wall....I believe I reached a plateau, and couldn't go any higher. I understand much music theory, learned all my scales and chord progressions, I can read music, but slowly, and can transpose from one key to another; I became discouraged when players with far less experience than I easily surpassed my abilities (even after dedicating hour after hour of practice). It became obvious that I should enjoy playing guitar for myself, but that's it. BTW, it helps to practice with other players, one progresses faster. Many guitarists are influenced by their favorite players, Chet Atkins, Eric Clapton,etc, and that influence can be heard in their music.

I think it's a lot like sports...some people are natural atheletes, most are not. I like baseball, but no amount of practice or lessons will ever get me into the major leagues.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#6

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

Paul Zerjay

>I think if you are satisfied with your turning abilities, that's a good thing. I just hope I am never satisfied with my turning abilities.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#7

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

Lan Brady

>It is an old quote but a good one!

" You must learn from other peoples mistakes, because you will not live long enough to make them all yourself!"

Lan

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#8

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

charlie belden

>It's not my abilities with turning techniques that I'm after. They are a means to an end. What I want is to be able to keep coming up with interesting ideas for pieces, and have at least the minimum skills and technique to make them a reality, albeit not technically perfect. How I make them or how long it takes to make them is secondary ( or even tertiary?)

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#9

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

charlie belden

>Learning from the mistakes implies that someone's tried it - whatever "it" is - before - or that you are aware of.

But what if you were David Ellsworth - wanting to do small necked hollow forms - before the internet and access to a LOT of information on How To as well as to tools that are made for what must've seemed like a wild hare idea for a turning? He found tools that were available when he started out - and adapted them to meet his needs, or at least some of his needs. And when adapting existing tools wasn't enough - he made - or had made - what he believed he needed. Then he taught himself the best way to use both the adpated tools as well as the new tools he came up with - for his purposes.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#10

Furniture Maker Examples

charlie belden

>When I was thinking about how to approach the question two furniture makers as examples of skilled furnitutre makers, two immediately came to mind - James Krenov and Michael Fortune - both woodworking hereos to me.

Krenov had a relatively few woodworking techniques almost exclusively using hand tools - and used a few techniques extremely well. His pieces, while looking quite plain and simple - aren't - when you look closely, or have and idea of what isn't being seen, or really think about why they're comfortable to be around. But like the "jeweler" I described in an earlier post (yes, he was a "successful jeweler", but only because he was a terrific self promoter) Krenov, intentionally or unintentionally imprinted much of his design ideas and techniques on his students.

As is the case for students of the "jeweler", I given three pieces, especially if two are cabinets, of a furniture maker who MIGHT have taken classes under Krenov, I can usually spot the Krenov student.

Michael Fortune came from an industrial arts background with a bias towards production work, even when he's doing a one of a kind piece. He comes up with all sorts of pieces - large conference tables, delicate curved chairs, veneered tamboured door cabinets, inlay, etc. - with curves in most of his pieces. And he comes at how to make things from a "with what I have now", adapting tools and developing methods to meet his needs.

Unlike Krenov, who had people come to him, Fortune goes out to where the woodworkers are - be it in a small jungle town in Latin America or a woodworking show here in the San Francisco Bay area - where I encountered him - thankfully - and not just from what he showed me and a few dozen others in his free demonstration or the two dozen who attended his jigs and fixtures day long presentation - but more because I had the chance to thank him for all the time and energy he's put in helping others.

Given your furniture production experience I'm betting you are familiar with Michael Fortune.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Furniture Maker Examples

Keith Tompkins

>Yep. I've been aware of his work since the early 80's. He is recognized as one of Canada's innovators. Tage Frid, who recently passed, left an indelible imprint on his students, similar to Krenov. His influence can be seen in most of his student's work; many who seem unable to develop their own style.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#13

Re: I'm still packing but...

Barry Elder

>As long as I'm having fun and unlimited enjoyment, I'm making progress. Can you believe that my cup is half full and overflowing at the same time?! (Rhetorical question) But think about it! Just as beauty is in the eye of the beholder, so may be progress.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#14

So Developing Your Own Style May Be Milepost

charlie belden

>Maybe developing your own style is a measure of progress. "Are my turnings different enough from any of the well known turners style to start becoming my own style?" might be a measure of progress at some point.

But what if you jump around a lot - and not work off a unique shape/form/technique/wood/finish as part of your own style? How will your work be recognized by others if they don't look anything alike?

Alby Hall seems to be able to get around that one - and definitely keeps progressing. If it doesn't look like anything you've seen before, or looks sort of like something familiar - but is obviously different in some very obvious way - it's likely one of his pieces.

Re: How Do YOU Measure Your Progress In Turning?

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: So Developing Your Own Style May Be Milepost

Keith Tompkins

>Charlie, When I look back as a self-employed maker, almost all of my work was done for architects or decorators. Working from blueprints, there was no room for self-expression or experimentation. Always under deadline pressures, there was no time for more rewarding projects based on my own tastes. Even worse, I very seldom got credit for the work I did...I almost never met the end customer. (One customer I did meet informed me of the cost of his custom kitchen..four times the price I charged the architect) After too many years, too many hours, and too few dollars, I began to hate what I did, and walked away.

Can you imagine the freedom I now experience when I create a new piece! I can turn out anything I desire, and frankly don't give a damn if someone likes it, or wants to purchase it. You can imagine how I bristle when someone tries to put me back "in the box". If I can put a bit of myself into each piece, I feel I've accomplished a successful piece.