>I haven't had much time to turn lately with all the other projects going on but since I was tuning up my Baxter threader I thought I would cut some threads to see if I had improved it any. After I cut the male and female threads to see how they fit I liked the wood so I went ahead and turned the rest of the box. I would probably make a different shape if I had not started it as purely a threading test. It came put pretty well anyway.
>Here is a detail of the threads. I needed to play with the Depth of field stacking in Photoshop CS4. Even at f22 I only had about 3/8" of DOF. I stacked 5 images to get it all in focus so you could see the inside and outside threads.
Since this was just playing around I didn't sand or finish the inside. It's straight off the #4 hunter tool.
>I have always wanted a threadmaster. Pretty expensive for a single purpose attachment. I guess it would pay for itself, but might take awhile to do so. Nice looking box BTW. Question is, did you get any better?
>Paul I haven't traced the problem of ultimate accuracy down yet. By adjusting the gibs on the threader and adjusting the bed lock I was able to get the runout at the end of the chuck to .007" and the cutter to rotating wood to about .012" Quite tolerable as seen in the photo above and the fit of the lid to box has almost no slop.
If you don't count my time, just materials, I paid for the threader in about 2 months in sales of threaded boxes. There was a little bit of a learning curve in the beginning to get really tight threads and do decide how to make the lips to accept the threads on different boxes. Following the instructions my very first box worked out pretty good but by changing the dimensions of the cut threads and box lips before cutting I was able to get a better fit.
I have a call in to Vic at Bestwoodtools to see if I can come buy and discuss how to correct the discrepencies I'm getting. It may not be fixable since I think it has to do with the tolerances of the woodlathe and chuck and not any real missalignment. It will be interesting to find out
I have a Baxter Threadmaster and have reached the conclusion that the accuracy is dependent on the main shaft being absolutely straight and machined correctly. Also the adapter that you screw your chuck or faceplate on must be perfect and be aligned perfectly. If all these factors aren't true, then you are peeing in the wind because you will have runout and/or wobble that can't be eliminated.
Vic worked over my BTM and I think he discovered that the main shaft was bowed. I think it has been corrected, but I sort of lost interest in the BTM when I realized that it wasn't as accurately made as I had believed.
This is the third story I've heard about problems associated with the main shaft of these machines....One of the members of the Des Moines Woodturners has a Baxter threading machine, and it appears to have similar problems with the main shaft being "imperfect" - he just can't get things aligned properly when treading. In contrast, two members of our Ames Area Woodturners group also have BTM's and they work just fine - no problems at all. The threaded shaft seems the be the Achilles Heel for these machines, which would hopefully mean that the QC on this part should be done with extra special care before it is released for assembly and shipping. I am contemplating buying one of these BTM's, but would be more comfortable knowing that this problem is really being paid attention to, and that stories of Bestwood Tools resolving any problems on the BTM are being made public.
I got my BTM right after the first Virginia Symposium, which means it is 5 or 6 years old. When I pointed out some discrepancies to Vic he took it back and worked it over. That's when he discovered that the shaft wasn't perfect. I vaguely recall removing the shaft and rolling it on the tablesaw table and sensing that the shaft was bowed. When it was returned to me it had a new 8 x 1 adapter on the shaft. I can't remember whether he reworked the shaft or provided a new one - I think it was the latter. It was my impression that the discoveries he made while tuning my BTM led him to fine tune the process and thereby improve the accuracy. I hope so.
When you consider the mechanics of the operation you need to have a perfect shaft rotating perfectly on its axis in order to avoid runout, which would lead to an inaccurate/eccentric thread. This assumes that the chuck or faceplate is centered on that same axis and is not cocked nor offset.
>Rob The main shaft on my machine has no runout at all. It fact the needle doesn't even move. When I put the threaded adaptor on I have less than .001" but it move the needle a little. When I put the chuck on is when I have the problem.
I'm going to try to go visit Vic. He tried to explain the problem when I was there last. When I got home I wasn't sure how to do anything about correcting it. Maybe he can help me understand the problem better so I can come up with a solution. I don't feel that it is the quality of the machine because we tested all of it that day and it was about as close to perfect as you can get.
>No I don't usually sand them. Sometimes I will touch them very lightly with 400 or 600 grit. I always wax them to make them turn more smoothly and on weaker woods I will make a final pass after soaking them with CA.