Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Pucker factor: new thread

Posts

Pucker factor: new thread

#1

Keith Tompkins

Pucker factor: new thread

Keith Tompkins

>I didn't want to hijack Mike's thread, but his post brings up a good point. This summer I purchased a motorcycle; before I got married, I was an avid enthusiast, so buying the new machine was like a step back in time. I took the month of August off; all I did was clean, polish and adjust everything on my new-to-me 39 year old machine. All was just like I remembered until I threw a leg over the seat and actually began to RIDE the damn thing. I had a feeling I hadn't felt before....the pucker factor, aka FEAR. As a twenty-something year old, it hadn't occurred to me that I could get myself killed (or worse).After all I was invincible, and trust me, I rode as if I were. As a fifty-something year old, time has had an effect on my outlook....Now, I realized one mistake could lead to an extended dirt nap. So what does this have to do with turning? Lots of turners approach the lathe with trepidation, even fear. (I realize Mike's post is a slightly different subject) Fear causes a biker to look directly at the upcoming guard-rails when he approaches a corner too fast; and no big surprise, the machine heads right in that direction...you go where you look! Fear causes a turner who is attempting to use a skew chisel the think "CATCH"...no big surprise here either...guess what usually happens? And why not...the same death-grip on the tool, the same technique that has caused the same catch repeatedly in the past. Some believe we learn from our mistakes; in the case of the motorcycle, we don't get to make that many of those. In the case of the turner, suppose we compare the progress of two turners.. one continued to learn from his mistakes, while the other took lessons from a skilled turner. After a period of say, a year, who do you think has made the most progress? My point is practice doesn't make perfect, proper practice of good technique makes perfect....and the pucker factor raises its ugly head far less often.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#2

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Don at Central Illinois

>I once heard a wise person say, "Practive does not make perfect; perfect practice makes perfect." Practicing something wrong must means we are better at doing something wrong. I have had the privileage to learn (or at least attempt) from a very good turner. I can't imagine where I would be if I hadn't had decent instruction.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#3

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

charlie belden

>I think the comparison between the self taught and the turner who takes lessons from a skilled turner needs to account for "teacher" as well as "skilled".

There was, and may still be, a well known jeweler who used the lost wax casting process to make his pieces - which were very "unconventional" - for a reason - he'd never apparently learned to solder - with silver or gold solder - he had no idea how to set facetted stone - except in big clunky settings with large "claws" - and could barely use a jeweler's saw. Though he sold some of his work - mainly through Arizona Highways - he made most of his income from teaching. Oh - and he wasn't very good at casting - making up for pits and dings with "texturing" and "oxidizing".

To me, a teacher doesn't impose their favorite method of doing something, but rather provides a range of solutions to a specific problem then helps the student execute the one the student chooses, or hovers nearby the OFF Switch as the student tries what she/he thinks would work - for him/her. And if that doesn't work - help figure out why and what change might make it work.

The problem was, he "influenced" (imposed his ideas of what was jewelry) ALL his students. To this day, if I see three pieces a jeweler has made I can usually tell if that jeweler EVER took a class from this "teacher" - even if they do know how to cast and solder and use a jeweler's saw and how to set facetted stones.

And THERE's the rub - or one of them. Teacher "A" uses a skew - for almost everything. What do you think most of his/her students will use most of the time?

Teacher "B" uses a bowl gouge with a special grind - which may work great for a particular form that he/she is known for. Which tool, and with which grind, do you think her/his students will use most, even if there's another tool that will do the job quicker, easier or better - or all three?

Now the self taught turner, on the other hand, not knowing what "should" and "shouldn't" be done likely will try the tools he got with the lathe and will pick up ways of using them from places like this, or magazines or a YouTube video - or just find ways that seem to work - and not get killed while experimenting/learning. In the process he/she is probably going to pick up some "bad habits" - some potentially dangerous, some though not "the right way" still work satisfactorally enough to continue doing.

I wouldn't put money on it, but I'm guessing a lot of the Old Masters did things that the euro-apprentice system would disapprove of or vehemently oppose -"THAT is just not done!".

I think one of the factors that has contributed significantly to the rate at which turning has and will continue to change is because of the Bumble Bee Syndrome - "I know you're current ideas don't let me fly - but not knowing anything about the theory of aerodynamics - I'm flying anyway.".

ramble mode OFF

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#4

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>As they say on the golf course, practice does not make perfect -- practice makes permanent. You better be sure you are practicing properly.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#5

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Bill Crommett

>I had a motorcycle once when I was young and adventuresome. It was a Harley - 45 WLDL. I sold it for money to go to college, but swore I would get another one when the kids were grown and out of the nest. But by that time I had seen enough blood shed by automobile drivers that were looking for other cars and not suspecting there would be a kid on a bicycle coming out at the next intersection. So by the time I had the money, the time, and the opportunity to get a new set of wheels I had also grow enough common sense to resist the urge. Good luck Keith, and may your guardian angel whisper in your ear at the proper time.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Keith Tompkins

>HI Charlie, I guess if the jeweler had become well known, he must have been doing something right. He probably would have been a better jeweler if he had learned some of the skills he lacked from a competent teacher. I've found that most woodworkers, including turners, reach a certain level and then tend to remain at that level until they reach out for help. By that time, bad habits have been formed that are difficult to correct. Some people have natural aptitude, and can make great progress with no outside influence at all, but these people are pretty rare. Compared with the Europeans, we Americans are less structured, and tend to be more innovative.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Dick Hines

>Keith, when you are twenty you think you you can die . When you get into the 50,s-60,s you begend to think that today may be the day I die.

I rode a motorcycle in my 20's and sold it and got a bass boat. After 40 years of fast boats I got another motorcycle for my 60th birthday. Glad I sold the boat.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#8

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Don at Central Illinois

>I like your explainatin better than perfect practice make perfect. You are right, practice make permanent.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Mike Stafford

>I am self taught. That is not necessarily a badge of honor as I was hampered by the quality my teacher and the intellect of the student.

I totally agree I would be a better turner had I taken a few basic courses of instruction at the beginning of my turning journey with a good teacher. Fortunately I have had the opportunity to take some classes later with some great teachers (Jamie Donaldson, Ed Moore, Frank Penta, Alan Leland) and I believe I have made a lot of progress because of the time spent with them. Better late than never I suppose.

However each exposure to a good teacher has also revealed more bad habits that I need to work on.

Just as Keith said,perhaps some of my trepidation is as a result of my own insecurity with techniques that I have never mastered. I can only keep practicing and trying to improve.

The one thing in life that I know for a certainty is that I don't know much about anything.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#10

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Don at Central Illinois

>Mike, and the older I get the more that is true. I know less and less about more and more.

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Dick, It's hard to explain to people why people ride motorcycles. Totally illogical, but still every time I ride , I experience the same thrill...sorta like turning! Ride safe!

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Keith Tompkins

>Mike, I'm pretty much self taught as well...I learned to turn in high school, but that covered the very basics. I worked in the wood industry, but by the time I started, hand skills were replaced by machines that cut a blank to length, formed the tenon, turned the shape, and drilled the holes...all in one operation. The operator simply kept the hopper full. Some of the shops I worked in had lathes, but they were off in a corner collecting dust. Only rarely, for a custom job, was the lathe hauled out. I got some instruction from a few old-timers, but their technique was suspect...coves were faired with a file, for example. I have come up with a few techniques of my own, but that's the hard way! I have no doubt you'll turn a masterpiece from that block of birch!

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#13

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

John Jordan

>We should have a Wood Central ride. I take a motorcycle to AAW every year. We rode 700 miles in NM this summer. :)

John

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor: new thread

Keith Tompkins

>Sounds good to me, John.