Hey Charlie...Got a critique?
Paul Zerjay
>Walnut and Ebony 11" x 5"
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hey Charlie...Got a critique?
Paul Zerjay
>Walnut and Ebony 11" x 5"
beauiful piece
bob davis
>
For What It's Worth . . .
charlie belden
>You keep picking the hard stuff to do really well.
With a lid to finial transition you have two choices
- make the transition abrupt and obvious - complimentry curves NOT intersecting at their tangent points (which is what reverse curves do).
or
- make the transition smooth and flowing, the reverse curve intersection at the tangent point of BOTH curves (ie not offset) - a smooth reverse curve.
But you came up with something that has BOTH - by adding a curve - the GREEN one in the attached illustration. Now you have a smooth transitioning reverse curve RED to GREEN, intersecting at their tangent point in the body/lid
and
intersecting complimentry curves - the GREEN curve in the body/lid intersecting the WHITE curve (black line in the line drawing) in the finial.
The next post looks at things in terms of just the profiles - without color to confuse things.
Re: Hey Charlie...Got a critique?
Sean Troy
>It looks flawless.
Re: For What It's Worth . . . (aprt 2) *LINK*
charlie belden
>OK - so let's take out the distracting color and just look at the profile.
"A" is what you've got.
"B" is the Abrupt Transition approach.
"C" is the Smooth Reverse Curve approach.
"A" relies on the color change to provide the visual separation of finial from body/lid - as would "C".
"B", by making an abrupt transition visually separates the finial from the body/transition - in addition to the change in color.
Given this piece - with its extra GREEN curve - that can be removed to continue the RED curve of the body/lid - I'd probably go with "B" - since it would be easier to "fix" than "C".
To get "C" you HAVE to turn the body to finial transition together - which means the rest of the finial can't be completed until that body/lid to finial transition has been turned.
Now I'm sure David Ellsworth doesn't put finials on his hollow forms for aesthetic / personal reasons - but if he did - it'd complicate his life a bit.
You'll notice that Cindy Drozda typically makes the finial an integral part of her lidded boxes. Her procedure and methods might not be applicable to this piece - partly because of its size - an also because it's not a lidded box - with finial - but. . .
This is a nice piece. The two woods work together, the body and the finial are each very well done. It's just how they come together that is close - but not quite right.
Any of this make sense to you?
Drozda Lid to Finial Turning Procedure
Any of this make sense to you?
Paul Zerjay
>Nope ya lost me. Just kidding!! And thanks for your time.
Re: Any of this make sense to you?
charlie belden
>I can see "it". Problem is in doing "it". THAT I'm working on - and I've got a LOT farther to go than you do.
Getting "it" right can take a bit of preplanning. "OK - so if I do THIS and then want to do THAT - how the hell am I gonna hold THIS and THAT in order to turn "IT"?
HUH!?
The turning isn't that tricky. It's the holding in order to turn "it" that's the hard part - at least for me. I seem to start out with a great idea - then find myself in a box canyon when I can't figure out a way to hold the parts so then can be blended together. Dead ends in something you've spent an hour or two on can be REALLY frustrating.
Re: Any of this make sense to you?
charlie belden
>Paul:
From looking at the responses you've gotten over at WOW, and given who is repsonding, I'm apparently seeing some things other folks aren't - or aren't mentioning.
That's the difficulty with critiqueing - which is not the same as criticising. The former's intent is construtctive - the latter intent typically is not. And critiqueing takes some time and thought - and for me, a visual learner - illustrations. When it comes to shapes, pictures are worth a lot more than a thousand words. Fortunately for me - I've got two graphics applications I know like the back of my hand so I can illustrate what I can't describe with just words.
So - as the original subject said "for what it's worth . . ."
Re: Hey Charlie...Got a critique?
Texian
>It's a beautiful piece of work, and I'm not gonna be the one to tell Paul that it would be better if it flowed smoothly from the body into the finial. Especially not on WoW. I'm not qualified. Let Charlie do it. Well done Charlie.
Re: Any of this make sense to you?
GaryG in MD
>Charlie, FWIW, I agree completely with your analysis. ...Gary
Re: For What It's Worth . . . (aprt 2)
Brad Vietje
>Paul/Charlie,
First -- this is a beautiful piece, Paul, and one to be proud of!
As for Charlies detailed analysis, I'm a fan of "B", which is what I almost always do, even if there's no finial... This can be done with a collar-type opening on a hollow form, or even with a one-piece HF, as well as with finials. I like the added formality of the curve break and I think there's an implied elegance. I prefer the break to be angled inward, toward the center of the piece.
Here's where I'm probably toooo picky: The shape of the finial itself can be very tricky to get just right. I think the transition from the central feature to the thinnest part is critical to really make the finial *pop*. My own taste is for a curve that reverses just a little more "quickly" or just a bit lower down. That results in a longer and thinner "neck", which is no easy feat to pull off, but can really make the piece stand out in a crowd of nice finials. Just one fellow's opinion, but I'm often looking for a slightly lighter and more dramatic finial than some folks.
The photo shows a reflection of the front edge of the light tent -- I'm sure Jamie or John can help with that sort of thing.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT