Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Calling all metal experts

Posts

Calling all metal experts

#1

Calling all metal experts

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Can anybody explain to me why we are seeing diamond rather than boron wheels being sold for wood turners to sharpen their high speed steel tools? I have a diamond wheel (for two years) and it is behaving superbly. But if you search the literature and the manufacturers sites, they say diamond is not to be used for sharpening high speed or specialty steels. Boron, (CBN) (Borazon) wheels are to be used. I have found a note in Machinery's Handbook 25, saying that diamond cannot be used on the tool steels we use because of rapid chemical breakdown. Another spot it says that under the extreme temperatures caused by diamonds cutting high speed steels, the diamond will be reduced to carbon. In the same book, it says that CBN, under similar circumstances will become "plastic" and deform or become gummy.

Now, we sharpen for only short periods and the temperatures do not become high. Is that why the diamond wheels are working for me? Are there other reasons we should be using or avoiding diamond?

Metallurgists -- HELP!

Re: Calling all metal experts

#2

Re: Calling all metal experts

Texian

>Bill, Do they make any distinction between Sharpening and Grinding? The latter might generate considerable heat, while the former is a fairly brief process.

Re: Calling all metal experts

#3

Re: Calling all metal experts

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>They seem to be talking about production grinding, where the wheel is running (and grinding) for hours on end with little or no cool-down periods. As you say, our sharpening techniques should produce very little heat. Is that the difference? If so, it would make sense then that the diamond wheels would work for us.

Re: Calling all metal experts

#4

Re: Calling all metal experts

Texian

>If heat is the problem, then that would certainly be the difference. Seems to me it would take a lot of grinding to heat the wheel very much. So if you need to grind 1/2" of steel off something, maybe best not to use the diamond or CBN wheel to do it.

Re: Calling all metal experts

#5

Re: Calling all metal experts

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Since we are not getting any experts answering, I am going to have to assume that is the case. WoodCraft is selling an excellent diamond stone -- and I don't think they would be putting their reputation on the line by selling something that does not really work.

Re: Calling all metal experts

#6

Re: Calling all metal experts

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Found some more information on one company site. It says not to use diamonds to sharpen high speed steel because the steel glazes the diamond surfae. But, after two years of heavy use, my plated diamond wheel is definitely lNOT glazed. Does anyone have answers? I know there are some metallurgists out there.

Re: Calling all metal experts

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: Calling all metal experts

Rob Wallace

>Bill:

I would fire off an e-mail message to Alan Lacer about this question. He's done a lot of comparisons and research on the grinding wheel topic, as well as having contact with metallurgists who know about various steels. I'm sorry I can't provide an answer - you probably wouldn't want one from a botanist on this topic anyway...

Rob Wallace

Re: Calling all metal experts

#8

Re: Calling all metal experts

Texian

>My neighbor, who is much better funded than I, got one of the diamond wheels a couple years ago. I noticed during a recent visit that he has four of them now. I surmise from this that they work well and he likes them. Otherwise they would be in a drawer and he would have different wheels on his grinders. Dunno about the CBN.