Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Pucker factor....

Posts

Pucker factor....

#1

Mike Stafford

Pucker factor....

Mike Stafford

>Seldom do I experience anxiety when I chuck up a piece of expensive wood but today I cut up a short blank of Masur birch that had a $66 price sticker on it. I have been carefully drying this stick for nearly 4 years.

I rounded it up on the lathe, separated lid from body, (well, of course it is going to be a box...what else?) and hollowed sanded and finished the inside of the lid.

So far so good. The pucker factor is still there because the hard part remains; hollowing and completing the box.

My question is do many of you ever get anxious when you are about to work on an expensive piece of wood? I am such a cheapskate I get very upset when I mess up a piece and doubly so when it is expensive. I just hate losing a piece of expensive wood. If its the wood's fault I just say oh shucks. When its my fault I say other words best left unsaid here....LOL

Worst part of this ordeal is that I cannot get back to work on the piece for another day or two because my work interferes with my shop time. I just hate it when our vocation interferes with our avocation.

Re: Pucker factor....

#2

Re: Pucker factor....

fredbear34

>Being in a situation where I really can't afford wood, expensive or otherwise, I worry about messing up even FOG wood.

Re: Pucker factor....

#3

Re: Pucker factor....

charlie belden

>Please explain this "$66 price sticker" phrase as it relates to turning material. I understand 66 as an integer quantity - and I get sticker - but what is this character "$" mean - and what is "price"?

Wait a minute.

You BUY wood - to turn?

What a novel idea!

There is this gasoline powered device with a chain with teeth in it that will make parts of a tree smaller and more manageable. And there is another electrically powered device with a band of thin metal that has teeth ground in one edge which will convert the more manageable tree parts created with the gasoline powered device into roundish shapes suitable for turning.

These two devices can provide you with all the wood you'll ever want to turn. Of course you have to be patient and let the wood dry - say for 4 months to several years - and there may be splitting and cracking problems. But with an almost inexhaustable supply of wood . . .

If you have a great wife, or rich adult offspring or a deceased woodworker close relative, these devices often just appear in the shop.

I'm still not sure why woods that can be such a PITA to turn are so highly sought after - and have this "$" and "price"? Somebody's Marketing Department are geniuses.

Having looked at some images of this stuff - how in the hell are you going to get the figure in the wood to line up where the lid meets the box?

I look foreward to the results - which I'm sure will be really really really nice.

Re: Pucker factor....

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: Pucker factor....

Ric Taylor

>My pucker factor is related to the amount of time invested in the project, not the value of the wood. If I've been working on a piece for quite awhile, the pucker gets tighter approaching the completion, not wanting to mess up everything that has gone into it so far.

Ric

Re: Pucker factor....

#5

Re: Pucker factor....

Lan Brady

>Mike,

I would have puckered when I spent 66 dollars on a piece of wood. But after it has sit in the shop for 4 years, it is just another piece of wood! Go for it!

Lan

Re: Pucker factor....

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Pucker factor....

Dick Hines

>I do some times Mike. Depends on how much the wood set me back. But as someone once said "No guts go glory!"

Re: Pucker factor....

#7

Re: Pucker factor....

john lucas

>I've almost never had an expensive piece of wood but when I used to do segmented work it happened all the time. Imagine spending 20 hours assembling a piece and then trying to turn it when your skills aren't very good. I really sweated a lot of those.

Re: Pucker factor....

#8

Re: Pucker factor....

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>We burn the stuff by the cord to keep warm - not masur birch of course, but I don't get too worried about wood. Then again, I don't often pay for it either. ;-)

Re: Pucker factor....

#9

Re:Let see here- after sitting in the shop......

Jamie Donaldson

>....for 4 yrs. occupying space and not paying rent, that stick has depreciated to a minus value Mike! Chew it up!

Re: Pucker factor....

#10

Re: Pucker factor....

Barry Elder

>Mr. Stafford, you have my most sincere good wishes!! While I don't even know what Masur Birch is, I salvaged some protected woods in 2004 after tremendous hurricane damage (with the State's permission, of course) so whenever I pick up one of those pieces, the pucker factor is intense 'cause the wood is not replaceable, ever. Deep breathing and slow, measured cuts are the order of the day!

Re: Pucker factor....

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor....

Keith Tompkins

>Barry, Here is a sample of Masur birch...


img

Re: Pucker factor....

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pucker factor....

Keith Tompkins

>Man! that didn't help! Don't know what happened to photo! I'll try again.

Re: Pucker factor....

#13

Re: Pucker factor....

Barry Turner

>I find that I do better work on expensive wood. Maybe it's the pucker factor at work. I get a little sloppy and reckless on cheap, especially free wood.

Re: Pucker factor....

#14

Re: Pucker factor....

Barry Turner

>I've never kept an expensive piece of wood long enough to forget how much it cost. Apparently, my memory is too good.

Re: Pucker factor....

#15

Keith Tompkins

Try Again..

Keith Tompkins

>This should show the birch grain... sorry for the previous photo. Mike, the solution is use ONLY expensive wood! :)


img

Re: Pucker factor....

#16

Re: Better Keith, but still very.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...sickly green? And about those "dual headlight" highlights? (;-O)

Re: Pucker factor....

#17

Re: Pucker factor....

Carole Valentine

>Mike, yes I definitely have experienced the pucker factor. The more beautiful or the more expensive the wood the higher the factor! I have had some pieces that sat in my shop so long that they started to deteriorate simply because I was afraid of screwing them up. Now just how much sense does that make? LOL

Charlie, some of us just like a beautiful piece of exotic wood now and then. What the heck is wrong with that???

Re: Pucker factor....

#18

Grandfather? Yes, Grandson...

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

>(Grasshopper:) " this "pucker" of which they speak...a form of fear, is it not, Grandfather?: "Ahhh...very astute,Grasshopper" Their value is misplaced and their fear is self defeating...."

Your piece of wood, Grasshopper, has taken many years for it to come to size and color. Has it great value? Let us wash it with stiff brush and perfumed oils. Let us rub reed upon it in the clean river water and wash away stones... we'll sing to it (just in case it is "the one".) Let us carry it with us on our journey tomorrow and into as many hands and eyes as will behold it. At the end of the jouney we shall bless it, and ask for guidance reforming it.

If, upon presenting it to the lathe, and, should we feel the "pucker" running in our bodies, will we know that we have not given ample reverance for what we have held.

In this way, Grasshopper, each piece is given the same "value" and same gratitude that it came into our hands. Eash piece is destined for The altar of some holy man. We cannot lust for that which has been lent to us. We must allow our 'creator within us' free unfettered flow of creative power.

Rather than "pucker" we shall feel empowered and the task will be light.

Re: Pucker factor....

#19

Re: Pucker factor....

Texian

>Haven't bought wood for many years, but sometimes have a "special" piece, gift from a friend or unusual grain patterns. Would not call it "anxiety" exactly, but maybe requires some extra attention to maintain focus on tool presentation and how to not ruin a unique blank. Try a little bit harder than usual to not mess up, but don't overdo it and get all uptight.

Meanwhile, you have a day job and can always buy more wood. So no need to cause yourself mental discomfort.

Re: Pucker factor....

#20

Re: Pucker factor....

John Scheideman

>I've lost expensive pieces of wood more times than I care to admit. But it happens. I don't think there is anyone who hasn't lost a nice piece at some point....whether it was an expensive piece or a nice looking free piece. If you get upset it only makes the pucker factor worse the next time. My thinking is that if you never pressure yourself and live on the edge a little you will never get any better and you will never experience the thrill of turning a really great piece.

When you lose a nice piece you have to have a very short memory and move on to the next piece. My two cents....

John

Re: Pucker factor....

#21

Re: Pucker factor....

Cyril Griesbach

>Several years ago I bought a couple of small yet expensive Aussie burls and set them aside until I decided what to do with them. Now I can't find them so they're really expensive.

Re: Pucker factor....

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Pucker factor....

Steve Kubien

>Like most turners, I buy very little wood. Pen blanks and stock for peppermills are about it and I actually dry and "sit-on" a lot of stock for those. Whenever I pay $15 for a chunk, I get the pucker factor. As Lan (I think) said, I get worried whenever I am turning a piece that I've got a bunch of time in or a piece showing some really special grain and character.

Be sure to let us know how it works out.

Steve

Re: Pucker factor....

#23

Re: Try Again..

Barry Elder

>Thanks, Keith! Now I can see where the fancy price tag comes in. I'll still have to stay with junky southern tropical woods, though. Mike does a great job on all his turnings whether the wood is pricey or not!!

Re: Pucker factor....

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Better Keith, but still very.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Jamie, You will be glad to know that I now have a proper photo area with good lighting. this was BP..before photo tent. My lousy photo era is over, I hope!

Re: Pucker factor....

#25

Mike Stafford

Re: Pucker factor....

Mike Stafford

>I have to say I have enjoyed all the responses. I don't know that they have alleviated my concerns but nevertheless it was fun talking about it and seeing how others felt.

I am fortunate that I am given lots of wonderful wood and I am also lucky that I am able to buy beautiful wood. Masur birch is one of my favorites and I love the finished product that results from a piece. I just want this piece to turn out correctly.

I have attached a picture of a box I turned from some Masur birch.

Thank you all for your comments. I enjoyed reading all the different opinions.


img