glue creep
karl
>I'm doing glued-up x-mas ornaments right now. I noticed the joins on the first one have moved a bit. Is there any way to prevent glue creep when using PVA? Heat? Is the brown stuff any better (more stable)?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
glue creep
karl
>I'm doing glued-up x-mas ornaments right now. I noticed the joins on the first one have moved a bit. Is there any way to prevent glue creep when using PVA? Heat? Is the brown stuff any better (more stable)?
Maybe not the glue
mfoster
>I'm not convinced glue is the problem. This is a topic that has been thoroughly bashed around by segmented turners. The general consensus is that if you glue up the project, then wait for an indeterminate time before final turning and sanding, you won't have a problem. A number of turners who live in the west, including Malcom Tibbets, believe the solution is to use only kiln dried woods and don['t seem to have any problem.
I have turned a few segmented pieces, and lately really seemed to have a problem with the "glue creep". I just re-sanded and refinished a large piece that I completed last winter because of the problem. I have tried the above mentioned solution, and it does not seem to help.
My take on the problem is that the problem really is the movement of wood with changes in relative humidity. I live in Vermont where we experience a fairly wide swing in humidity over the course of a year. I do not have air conditioning, so keeping completed pieces in my house makes no difference. I think the problem is that the wood moves with these swings, just enough to make a difference at the joints. I have found that the joints move differently depending on the species of wood. This makes sense, since different woods don't move the same amount with changes in RH, and will respond at different rates (due to density and porosity).
It is my belief that people like Malcom, Ray Allen and Kurt Theobold have no problems, is that they don't have their pieces exposed to the wide swings in RH that I have here in Vt. Mark Kauder lives in Alabama, and I would expect that he has some change in RH, but perhaps not as much as I do. He, however has perfected a fantastic lacquer finish which really helps to isolate the wood from the swings in RH as it seals the wood so well.
I like using oil finishes and have no intention on moving. My solution is to realize that the wood is going to move regardless. I am not really fond of the high shine lacquer finish and I like the piece to stay as I intended it. I have decided (just in the last few weeks) to give up segmented work because of these problems. I'll leave it to those living where conditions are more favorable. There is so much to explore in turning, that I don't think I'll miss it.
Re: Maybe not the glue
Bill Stehman
>Joint creep can be minimized by absolute grain alignment and using veneer glue. PVA's especially titebond II and III are made for wet area cabinet glue ups and are soft to allow for joint expansion. Titebond I is preferred but does not dry hard like veneer glues. The draw back to veneer glues is the dark joint in light woods. The furniture industry has great success with little movement using veneer glues.
I live in AZ which has RH swings from 1% to 100% so thin walls which minimize the amount of wood to move helps a lot but some woods move more than others. One can do a glue up turn thin and let it set for 30days and finish turn with relative good success but in actuality, wood will move in time when exposed to different humidity.
Re: glue creep
Bill Youngblood
>I live in MI and the humidity swing here is probably about the same as yours in VT. I've been segmenting for about 8 years and have tried many wood and glue combonations. I have found that Titebond I is generally the best. Domestic woods such as Cherry, Ash, and Maple absorb the moisture from the glue and swell. I usually let my glue ups sit for 3 to 4 weeks before finish sanding. The exotics are usually more dense therefore don't have the absorbtion problems as much. Also, I turn to a wall thickness of about 3/16". Less on smaller pieces. The thinner the better. For more help, you can go to the web site of a new AAW chapter, www.segmentedwoodturners.org They are a chapter just for segmenters. Good luck. Don't quit yet. There is a lot of help out there.
Re: glue creep
mfoster
>Bill, I would guess that your RH experience is close to ours as well. I've been segmenting for at least 15 years. I do all the things you suggest and then some. I still find that a piece will move once exposed to the RH swings over a course of a year or two. I have a piece that traveled with me from Alaska and has been here for a few years now. It is a piece constructed of all domestic woods. While the piece looks fine and is totally intact, the tactile experience is not what it was when it was completed. You can feel the joints. I think the problem gets exaggerated once you introduce exotics into the mix. My objection is not the visual esthetics, but the tactile ones. I want the piece to feel as good as it looks and not change over time. I would love to handle one of Ray Allen's pieces that he turned decades ago. I would bet that you could feel his joints as well. Wood moves.
Mike
Re: Maybe not the glue
mfoster
>Bill,
I would venture to say that I pay as much or more attention to detail as anyone doing segmented work with regard to grain I segment veneer layers, and make sure grain is running around the ring even with thin vertical dividers in feature rings. I've tried all the glues including the PVA's, hide glue, resorcinol and epoxy. Like you said, they all have advantages and drawbacks. Most of my turnings have walls between 1/8-3/16" except a couple of the larger pieces where I really thought I needed more heft for strength and to reduce vibration while turning (1/4"). I glue up, turn thin wait, sand.... Like you said, wood moves.
I lived in Phoenix for 2 years (hated it) and indeed there is humidity changes, but not as persistent as we have here. I have furniture here that I had in Phoenix that have had stuck drawers from swelling in the summer, but never had the problem in Phoenix, CO, or AK.
Re: glue creep
john lucas
>I have given up segmented work, at least for now. It's just too time consuming for the time I have and can't sell it for anywhere near the time I have in it. I will probably go back to it someday, maybe soon. I do enjoy the challenge.
I had the same problem you have although not all the time and I don't understand why. I'm guessing 2 things. Wood movement and environment. My mother has a piece and the joint lines are perfect every time I go and check it out.
It is a simple maple and walnut bowl. I did what everybody does on their early segmented work, the grain in the thin pieces runs 90 degrees to the grain in the wide pieces. It's fairly thin, maybe 1/4" and was glued I'm sure with titebond because that's what I used back then.
I'm guessing that at least part of the problem is it's always in her house and humidity doesn't change much. Maple and Walnut also move a little more similar to each other. Even thought the grain runs differently in the segments the orientation of the wood as far as shrinkage and expansion goes is the same. What I mean is the they are all situated so the tangential and radial movements are in the same direction.
After I started having the glue joint problems I found a chart that shows the wood movement in all 3 directions of many species and plots it to show a number. If you work with species that have similar numbers you have less movement issues.
That was about the time I lost my job and everything came to a standstill and I've never really gotten back into complicated segmented work. I still do a lot of simple glue ups and do have some glue line issues.
Re: glue creep
Bill Stehman
>Mike,
I stopped making large and/or complex designs for this reason. Some of my older pieces that had matching wood densities have faired well others have not. My father spent 8 years wintering in Yuma and pestering Ray Allen. Most of his and the one Ray Allen bowl that I have that was passed down joints can be felt so you are correct.
Wood moves.
Re: glue creep
Russ Fairfield
>Glue creep is real. You can feel a definite ridge of hard glue at the joints in identical wood species and grain direction.
I have always subscribed to the explanation that the PVA and aliphatic resin glues were an elastomer material and exhibited a "hysterisis." As such they were similar to a rubber band that could be stretched but didn't return to its same length again. After the initial stretching, the rubber band relaxes and becomes more dimensionally stable at its new length.
The glue behaves the same way in the segmented wood. It expands with the wood when the humidity increases, but doesn't retract as much as the wood when the humidity is lowered again. This leaves the glue sticking out beyond the surface of the wood. This is what is called "glue creep".
There appears to be less "creep" with kiln-dried wood because cellular structure has changed, and the wood is more stable and doesn't move as much as air-dried wood with seasonal humidity changes.
Add to this that the glue also absorbs moisture and grows, and thick glue joints absorb more moisture and grow more. Bad glue joints make the creep worse - an argument for thin tight glue joints.
We notice the problem more with segmented wood than furniture because there are more joints and we give them a much closer inspection. When was the last time you looked at every joint in a table top from 12" away or inspected it with a magnifyine glass.?
Here is how I have worked around the problem.
After a couple seasonal changes, the glue is more stable, and can be sanded back to level with the wood with a reasonabl;e assurance that the surface will stay smooth with future movement. When I lived in North FL, I moved accelerated the process in the hot seasons by moving the turned and sanded piece between the shop and the air conditioned house and back 2 times, and allowing the wood 3 to 4 weeks to stabilize in each location. Then I sanded back the glue lines, and finished the piece.
I also developed what I call my "Minimum 30-30-30 day rule" where the wood was allowed 30 days to acclimate to my shop before cutting it up into segments, another 30 days after it was assembled to allow for all of the moisture from the glue to evaporate, and another 30 days after turning and before sanding to allow the wood to acclimate to its new form. These were minimums, and my working goal was to be turning and finishing this year a bowl that was assembled last year. The second 30-days then became between 8 and 12 months. I also tried to do all assembly in the winter when the humidity was at its lowest. This allowed for one full low-high-low humidity cycle before turning and finishing the bowl.
Doing all of these things allowed me to move bowls from the 100% humidity of North FL to the 26% humidity of summer in North Idaho without any signs of glue creep.
Living in a dry climate means that all wood movement is in only one direction, and the hysterisis of the glue keeps it always lagging behind the wood and always below the surface.
Re: glue creep
karl
>Thanks to all for posting responses to my question (and also to questions I've posted in the past). Since I've got to get these ornaments to a gallery by the first week of Nov. I don't have the time to let them stabilize properly. I guess I'll just have to do my best, and hope the bone dry winter weather here (MN) works in my favor.
Has anyone tried baking or nuking to speed evaporation of moisture from the glue?
Re: glue creep
Russ Fairfield
>OK to heat at low temperatures, but there is always the possibility of over-drying the wood, and that can cause the wood to shrink and another set of problems.
If you choose to heat, keep the temp down to less than 120F. Up around 150F and the glue starts to become soft and expands, and it then becomes granular like corn meal as it cools, unless it is clamped.
Re: glue creep
john lucas
>I was going to second what Russ just said. Heat will soften the glue and can break the joints. I would use very low heat. I break glue joints when I repair things just using a heat gun. I don't let the wood get hotter than what I can touch.
Re: glue creep
Russ Fairfield
>126F is the magic number. That is the hottest touch and hold temperature with your fingertips. There is very little variation between different people.
You guys rock!
karl
>