Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Need help from you machinist types

Posts

Need help from you machinist types

#1

Need help from you machinist types

john lucas

>I've been trying to build a threader for threading wood. I have tried to align everything from start to finish and here's my problem (see photo below). I get threads that aren't the same depth. I have the same problem to a much lesser degree with my Baxter threader and I took it back to Vic and he checked it and it was less than .0001 inch off so the machine isn't the problem. It has something to do with the chucks or lathe. As you can see in the photo I get flat topped threads on my homemade machine.

When I turn the wood on the lathe and check it runs true +/- about .003 or less. With the chuck and wood installed on the Baxter threader I get about .012 tolerance as I rotate the wood. With my homemade threader I get measure .030" tolerance. Well if you only have a .040" thread it leaves one side really flat.

I can't for the life of me figure out how to correct the problem. Vic tried to explain to me about headstock spindle alignment throwing it off but I guess it didn't sink in. I have virtually the same numbers if I use the threader on my mini lathe or my home made threader lathe and it doesn't make a bit of difference if I turn the wood on my Powermatic or my Nova comet. The wood spins true when on the headstock and is off when it's on the threaders.

Anyone have any idea what to do to correct it. I've tried shimming the whole assembly that holds the threaded rod with no difference. I tried shimming between the chuck and the front of the threaded spindle on the threader and it doesn't seem to change much. I've tried 3 different chucks with virtually identical numbers.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#2

Re: Need help from you machinist types *LINK*

Dick Coers

>Mabe the pic will help, but just an initial thought. Are you taking the chuck off one machine and threading on another spindle? If that is the case, there is no pilot to register the chuck to the spindle, just threads. The threads may self-center, but not accurately center it. I see that the Lindow-White guys have designed a leveling chuck that will adjust to get a very accurate position of the stock. I don't think you can use that chuck for turning, but it addresses the problem.

From their site;

"Leveling Chuck - The leveling or truing chuck is the traditional way of compensating for uneven materials or inaccuracies in work holding systems when moving from machine to machine. The chuck not only compensates for inaccuracies radially like a four jaw chuck, but it also allows for adjustments axially which are virtually impossible to deal with otherwise.

This tool is an absolute must for anyone turning layers or large diameter pieces where runout becomes pronounced because of the size. Both the male and female threads are 1"-8."


lindow-white chuck

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#3

Re: Need help from you machinist types

john lucas

>Interesting Dick. I am registering the chucks against face at the end of the spindle threads. It does look like the sideways movement of the chuck might solve at least part of the problem. I'm just not sure why it's happening. As I said you put the chuck on either lathe and check the runout of the piece and there is almost none.

Put it on either threader and there's 15 thou on the Baxter and 35 thou on the homemade. What drives me crazy is I know the main drive spindle is parallel to the headstock. I mounted it between centers when I installed it in the crossfeed vice that serves as the main body of the homemade threader.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#4

here's a photo of the problem 

john lucas

>


img

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#5

Re: Need help from you machinist types

Dick Coers

>Have you measured the od of the thread? Maybe try loading the chuck to one side when you seat it against the shoulder. Measure, then load it another way to see if you can influence the position of the chuck by how you thread it on. I wonder about putting some teflon tape on the thread an see if that keeps the chuck centered by taking up some of the loose thread fit tolerances. I know there are different classes of threads, but don't know if that is the right path for this.

Class 1 threads are loosely fitting threads intended for ease of assembly or use in a dirty environment.

Class 2 threads are the most common. They are designed to maximize strength considering typical machine shop capability and machine practice.

Class 3 threads are used for closer tolerances.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#6

Re: Need help from you machinist types

Dick Coers

>I just went to the shop and put an indicator on the body of my chuck on the lathe. I could not influence the runout of the chuck by putting pressure on the chuck as I made contact with the shoulder on the shaft. So much for that theory.

Do you know that the shoulders on your threaders are perpendicular to the threads? Maybe sandwich a piece of flat stock between the chuck and the shoulder and check runout there.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#7

Re: Need help from you machinist types

john lucas

>Dick I tried to place shims between the chuck and the face of the spindle on my threader and really couldn't change it. The bolt I'm using for the spindle fits too snugly so the chuck won't tilt.

I did pull the whole thing apart and put it in my metal lathe and trued up the inner face of the bolt. That reduced the runout to .015 which is tolerable but the average person won't have access to a metal lathe so I'm trying to find another solution if in fact that is the problem.

What confuses me is I know the Baxter machine is dead on. Vic measured it with an indicator that measures in the Millionth's of an inch and yet it still shows .015" of runout when cutting threads. So I'm wondering if there is some other adjustment I can make that I'm just not seeing.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#8

Re: Need help from you machinist types

mike@hunterwoodturningtool.com

>John

I suspect it is the helix angle of the thread cutter. Different diameters of threads require different angles of the threaders, both ID and OD. These angles will keep the major and minor diameter of the threads in line with each other.

What is your common diameters and I can send you some information?

Mike

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#9

Re: Need help from you machinist types

Russ Fairfield

>The accuracy and repeatability you are looking for in a self-centering chuck will several times more than anyone is willing to pay for in a woodturning chuck.

The cheapest and easiest way to get accurate centering is to hold the wood in a 4-jaw chuck with independent jaws, and dial it in with a dial indicator. Nobody makes one of those for wood that I know of. I often wished they did. Small 4-jaw chucks for holding metal are available for about $50.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#10

Re: Need help from you machinist types

Dennis Ford

>I think the problem is in the thread fit. Most wood lathes have pretty loose fitting threads. This slop allows the chuck to mate up to the shoulder and the shoulder does all the alignment. If your threads are snug, they will affect alignment.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#11

Accuracy of the chuck isn't the problem

john lucas

>Russ I agree and I have one 2 4 jaw independant chucks but that isn't my problem. When I turn the wood in the Vicmarc chuck the runout is less than .003". With really smooth wood I can get it under .002". However when I take the same chuck and put it on the threader I now have .015". The threader was checked and is so close to perfect it's not funny. So I'm trying to figure out where the problem is.

If it's not the chuck and not the threader then it has to be some sort or alignment difference between having the chuck mounted 180 degrees on what should be the same axis.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#12

Could be Dennis

john lucas

>I know when the chuck pulls up against the face it should straighten out but what if it's off horizontally, if that's a good way to describe it. I don't know.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#13

Re: Accuracy of the chuck isn't the problem

Mark Wollschlager

>Dumb question, but is the spindle you are threading the chuck onto 'bottoming out' on the spindle adapter of the chuck?

Or perhaps entering a portion of thread ( on the adapter )that is 'not right' that your lathe spindle does not reach.

Mark

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#14

Re: Accuracy of the chuck isn't the problem

john lucas

>Mark The chuck bottoms out against the spindle face like it should. I made sure of that when I cut the 1 1/4" bolt off to the length needed.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#15

Have you used a 3 way chuck?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>John,

Several years ago I took a course on making recorders, several of us had trouble with not really circular pieces and I blamed it on my Nova which has lots of problems, but the instructor thought with was not the lathe but the 4 way chuck.

Then we found out that he uses a metal lathe to make his recorders.

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#16

Re: Accuracy of the chuck isn't the problem

Bob Macgregor

>So, do you have a 1.25" bolt welded to a shaft that turns? If so, how heavy is the shaft? Any way it could be flexing minutely from the weight of the chuck? (I'm grasping at straws here)

BOB

Re: Need help from you machinist types

#17

Re: Accuracy of the chuck isn't the problem

Don Orr

>Could it have anything to do with how the threader is mounted to the lathe bed ? Is there any slop or play side to side (toward & away from you as you face the lathe) that could account for the discrepancy? Is the threader dead parallel to the ways ? Is there slop or backlash in the cross slide mount ? How is the center-to-center alignment between spindles-like head-tail alignment for standard turning ?

Just throwing out some things that popped into my non-machinist head. Hope you get it figured out.