Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

Posts

Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#1

Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

charlie belden

>�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done

A few nights ago, during a brief discussion amongst some turning club members about the Rolly Munro Articulated Hollower, the aggresiveness of the round, flat cone, cutter was mentioned and the �depth of cut limiter� gotten into. Despite the design consideration that obvioulsy went into this hollowing tool, it doesn�t eliminate The Dreaded Inside Catch problem.

A very experienced member mentioned that Rolly Munro suggested orienting the tool in an very non-traditional way to reduce or eliminate The Dreaded Catch problem - or significantly reducing the effects of one - by pointing the cutting edge DOWN.

Wait! The cutting edge is SUPPOSED to point to the LEFT isn�t it?

Why?

�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!

WHY?

�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!

Well maybe so. But the guy who came up with this tool says Point It Down - because, with this tool, THAT works.

Now I�m thinking �OK - so pointing the tool DOWN reduces catches. Why?�

So I examine the ��Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!� physics.

You�ve basically got a lever - one end cutting wood spinning down into the cutter, a support/pivot point (the tool rest), and a handle on the other end where you can apply forceS to a) prevent the tip from being pushed down on that end and and the handle from being pushed up on the other end b) to prevent the tool from rotating about its long axis and forcing the cutting edge out of cutting alignment.

So we�ve got a downward force on the cutting end - and a downward force on the handle end - so the fulcrum must is counterbalancing the sum of these two downward forces and pushing UP that much. That�s what I learned in High School Physics, and again in College Phisics and Statics - Free Body Diagrams, Vector Analysis, Moment Diagrams, etc.

So when a catch occurs, the downward force on the cutting end goes way up - VERY quickly. And the instinctive thing to do is to push DOWN on the handle end to counteract the handle being pushed up by the catch - which brings the cutting edge back UP - to where it caught in the first place - which causes another catch - which pushes the cutting end down, the handle end up - which we counter act by pushing the handle end down . . .

Hmmmmmm. It�s that fulcrum/tool rest that lets us do this TeeterTotter thing - that raises all the hell when an inside catch happens - and inside catches WILL happen.

So - if the cutter is pointing DOWN - and a catch happens, pressing DOWN on the handle - will lift the cutting end UP - away from the wood - where it can�t immediately catch again.

Hmmmm - now there�s little if any downward forces on the fulcrum/tool rest - some of the weight of the tool AND any force you apply from the handle end, assuming your left hand is keeping the tool down on the tool rest. If there is a force applied to it by a catch - it�ll be HORIZONTAL - and the tool can slide down the tool rest - away from that force.

This �Point The Cutter Down� idea seems to make sense to me when it comes to The Inside Dreaded Catch.

Does this �Point The Cutter Down� make sense to you?

If not, why?

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#2

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

john lucas

>I ain't no physics person (bad grammer intended) I only know what works for me. I've never had the Monroe hollower. I use homemade copies of John Jordan's.

When I take cuts I always point the cutter down slightly and cut what would be below center. I started doing this because when I made cuts it wanted to do this naturally. My bars are curved so that the cutter is inline with the center of the main shaft and I make sure the tool rest is on the straight part of the bar which should eliminate this twisting. In theory this should reduce rotational forces but you still have the force of the wood pushing the cutter down. I've found that a slight downward tilt seems to reduce this.

I may be wrong here but I think the reason you get catches is (1) you take too big of a bite or (2) you bump the tool into the shoulder of a previous cut which again takes too big of a bite or you are cutting below center and when you start to get a catch it pulls the tool into the arc of the wood even further and you get a really big bite (read that as nasty catch)

I'm not sure I can explain the geometry of this last statement because it has a lot to do with the orientation of the tool. You have to assume that the cutter is parallel to the surface of the lathe. If you are cutting at or above center and get a catch it will pull the tool down into space. If you are below center and get a catch it pulls the tool into the work. This assumes of course the wood is round and the cutter goes straight down. I guess the words I need to use may be having the tool perpendicular to the side your cutting. I say this because I tilt the tool down(which in affect is cutting below center) but in reality my tool is still perpendicular to the wall. What I'm trying to say is, I don't know how to describe what I do it just works for me. I don't really know the correct terms to use. Perpendicular is too close to the word perplexed and my little mind doesn't know the difference. :)

When I've exploded thin pieces I think it was again to big of a bite. These pieces want to vibrate and when you take a larger than normal bite it will pull the wood into the cutter and probably the cutter into the wood as well and you get a nasty catch which often results in a damaged piece.

Just my thoughts and I got up way too early so my brain may still be cloudy. I need more doughnuts and caffeine.

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#3

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

adrien

>I've got a Vermec hollower and curiously enough, because of the way it's set up, I use it on the right side of the piece, cutting edge down. It's counter intuitive, but works fine.

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#4

Munro's are different

mfoster

>I think you've got the physics right but the deal with the Munro hollower is really more to do with the design. This cutter and the Pro Forme both are intended as cutting tools, not scrapers and work similar to the Hunter tools. The difference is the Hood that protects the cutter from becoming too aggressive. These hoods are a little fiddly to get adjusted so that you are taking a decent enough bite without getting too aggressive that it can't be controlled but I find it's worth it.

Let's assume we're cutting the inside side wall of a hollow form for simplicity. If we configure the Munro hollower int a C shape we now have a tool with similar configuration as John Jordans curved tools (which I have and use several of). Rolly teaches to start this cut with the tool rest and cutter on the center line, but with the tool rolled to the left, or pointig down. If you do this with the Munro, then bring the tool into contact with the spinning wood, you are rubbing the wood with the hood and not cutting at all. Try this with a scraper, like a Jordan, and you will have quite a different experience. A scraper would instantly want to cut and spin in your hands as soon as it touches the wood. With the Munro you then slowly rotate the tool back towards horizontal and you will pick up a cut until it is horizontal, where it is most aggressive. If you keep rotating the tool, the head moves out away from the wood and you are no longer cutting. You couldn't do this without the hood. Think BOOM.

So the difference here is really that the cutter is truly a cutter and the hood that protects the cutter makes the tool a whole different critter. You can rub the hood on the wood all you want and slowly rotate the cutter up to get a bite. You can actually control the bite by the amount of rotation as well as the amount of cutter exposed by the hood.

Clear as mud?

Mike

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#5

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

robo hippy

>Reading this made my head hurt. Maybe I was up too late last night, went to see Jennifer Batten (guitarist with Michael Jackson on Bad, Thriller, and His Story tours, and with Jeff Beck, my guitar idol, for a couple of years as well). WOW!!!!!!!!!!

All ring cutters, and disc cutters cut as scrapers when held flat or at 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood. They are uncontrollable in this orientation as they will bite off way more than most of us can control. This is why they have the chip limiters on them, or in the case of the Eliminator, Hunter tools, or Termite, they are held at 45 degrees or so, which puts them into a shear cutting action rather than a scraping type cut. A shear cut works far better as a finish cut than it does as a roughing cut. The ring and disc cutter angles are probably pretty close to the angle of the burr on a scraper (held flat/scraping or angled/shear). The main thing here is how much steel is presented to the wood at one time. Obviously, too much and you get a catch. This is why most standard scraper type tips (Kelton, Oland, etc.) are rather small. The ring cutters are bigger/wider, and that is part of the reason they have chip limiters on them. I use scrapers on bowls as my primary roughing tool. I always keep the cutter at or above center, and the cutter angled down. If I happen to have it dig in because I am trying to remove too much at one time, when the tip goes down, it does tend to fall out of the wood, rather than digging in deeper. This is some thing you can develope a 'feel' for. It is easier to do on a bowl because you can see it, which of course is impossible on the inside of a hollowform. When hollowing, I think it is pretty much the same thing, I cut slightly above center, but the handle is level. The ridges from stopped cuts do present the possibility of grabbing that extra bit of wood beyond the normal you are cutting off, and the chance of a catch. Again, it is a touchy feely thing since you can't see the wood as you cut it.

I guess I am saying that you cut slightly above center, and if you are doing it by hand, have the tool pointed slightly down. This helps keep catches away, and at least reduces their severity.

robo hippy

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#6

Re: Munro's are different

MikeNelson

>I have no idea where the little hood for my Munro is, after many atempts to adjust and finally getting a smooth cut it would clog within a few seconds on most woods, then the hex screw would strip out from so many clog removals. I finally tossed the hood and learned to control the tool without it, just takes practice.

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#7

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

charlie belden

>As usual, there's more to it than meets the eye - or in this case - the mind's eye since you may not be able to actually see what's going on when cutting inside a hollow form.

So, on the Munro, the depth of cut limiter "cap" also serves as a bevel to begin rubbing, rotating on that rubbing bevel until the cutting begins. And the round cutter is actuall cutting rather than scraping. How much it's cutting depends on where the "cap" is set and how much of the round cutting edge is in contact with the wood.

And where the cutting is taking place, relative to the long axis centerline of the tool determines how much torque gets exerted on the handle - that YOU have to counteract.

Interesting how something that appears so simple and straightforeward - when the wood stays still - gets kind of complicated when the wood is moving - and more complicated if the wood is moving on an arc - and where you're cutting can't be seen.

I learn something new each day. Just a couple of responses and I've met my quota for the day. The rest I'll apply to tomorrow's quota ; )

Thanks.

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

Dick Hines

>It's because Rolly lives below the equator. Drains flow in the wrong direction down there too.

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#9

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or dow

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>With my Kelton hollowers, whether hand held or mounted in the hollowing rig, I attempt to keep the tool level at center with the "cutting" edge angled down approximately 5 percent. This seems to keep catches to a minimum for me. I also am very careful not to take too deep of a bite at a time.

I like the Kelton hollowers so much that I'm having adapters made for my Monster so I can use them in it too.

keithz

Re: Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?

#10

Randy making the adapter?

charlie belden

>