Inside Hollowing - cutter to the left - or down?
charlie belden
>�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done
A few nights ago, during a brief discussion amongst some turning club members about the Rolly Munro Articulated Hollower, the aggresiveness of the round, flat cone, cutter was mentioned and the �depth of cut limiter� gotten into. Despite the design consideration that obvioulsy went into this hollowing tool, it doesn�t eliminate The Dreaded Inside Catch problem.
A very experienced member mentioned that Rolly Munro suggested orienting the tool in an very non-traditional way to reduce or eliminate The Dreaded Catch problem - or significantly reducing the effects of one - by pointing the cutting edge DOWN.
Wait! The cutting edge is SUPPOSED to point to the LEFT isn�t it?
Why?
�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!
WHY?
�Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!
Well maybe so. But the guy who came up with this tool says Point It Down - because, with this tool, THAT works.
Now I�m thinking �OK - so pointing the tool DOWN reduces catches. Why?�
So I examine the ��Cause That�s The Way It�s Always Been Done!� physics.
You�ve basically got a lever - one end cutting wood spinning down into the cutter, a support/pivot point (the tool rest), and a handle on the other end where you can apply forceS to a) prevent the tip from being pushed down on that end and and the handle from being pushed up on the other end b) to prevent the tool from rotating about its long axis and forcing the cutting edge out of cutting alignment.
So we�ve got a downward force on the cutting end - and a downward force on the handle end - so the fulcrum must is counterbalancing the sum of these two downward forces and pushing UP that much. That�s what I learned in High School Physics, and again in College Phisics and Statics - Free Body Diagrams, Vector Analysis, Moment Diagrams, etc.
So when a catch occurs, the downward force on the cutting end goes way up - VERY quickly. And the instinctive thing to do is to push DOWN on the handle end to counteract the handle being pushed up by the catch - which brings the cutting edge back UP - to where it caught in the first place - which causes another catch - which pushes the cutting end down, the handle end up - which we counter act by pushing the handle end down . . .
Hmmmmmm. It�s that fulcrum/tool rest that lets us do this TeeterTotter thing - that raises all the hell when an inside catch happens - and inside catches WILL happen.
So - if the cutter is pointing DOWN - and a catch happens, pressing DOWN on the handle - will lift the cutting end UP - away from the wood - where it can�t immediately catch again.
Hmmmm - now there�s little if any downward forces on the fulcrum/tool rest - some of the weight of the tool AND any force you apply from the handle end, assuming your left hand is keeping the tool down on the tool rest. If there is a force applied to it by a catch - it�ll be HORIZONTAL - and the tool can slide down the tool rest - away from that force.
This �Point The Cutter Down� idea seems to make sense to me when it comes to The Inside Dreaded Catch.
Does this �Point The Cutter Down� make sense to you?
If not, why?



