Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Skew questions *LINK*

Posts

Skew questions *LINK*

#1

Paul Kramer

Skew questions *LINK*

Paul Kramer

>All,

I watched a video of Kevin Glen-Drake driving a skew like . . . like . . . well for lack of a better analogy . . . like a bulldozer. See the link below. My first question: How's that work?

I was turning some turning chisel handles from dry red elm that I got during an episode of the IndyFest a few years ago. That's great wood for handles -- very sturdy. Well, seemingly no matter what speed I used while using the skew, I got this chattering that left a spiral pattern on the wood. My second question: Why does that happen? How does one solve this problem? It's probably obvious -- but not to me.

All help welcome,

Paul


Kevin Glen-Drake turns a chisel handle

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

Practice.

steve antonucci

>You don't get to cut that way without practicing, but once you get the hang of it, that's just how it works.

The chatter is from pushing too hard and causing the wood to deflect while cutting. Sharpen and take a finishing pass...

Steve

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#3

Re: Skew questions

Bill Howatt

>Could be that it isn't real sharp and you are pushing against the workpiece too hard. Also, if the spindle is quite thin for its length it will vibrate causing such marks.

Bill

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#4

Re: Skew questions

JohnKyler

>Remember to float the bevel, not rub...

As said above, too much pressure will cause deflection.

I have also seen where some live centers have some bearing noise that can also cause this too.

John

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#5

Re: Skew questions

Dick Coers

>If you listen carefully to the video, he has a little bobble too. There is a little chatter when he turns the bead on the hand end. So, everyone can have trouble. When I start having trouble with the skew, I loosen my grip. This naturally reduces pressure on the part, as well as letting the cut just happen and not be forced.

You might try point down like he does. Changing position might help you feel the bevel.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew questions

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Paul, good advice, also try easing up on the tension...don't crank the tailstock up too tightly. This will cause the spindle to whip. Also, make sure the cutting edge is not at 90 degrees to the turning...this will cause you to cut straight into end grain, which requires more force and will contribute to the rippled effect you have encountered.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#7

Re: Skew questions

john lucas

>First he is getting chatter. You can hear it when he turns the end and when he makes the final pass toward the tip. He also mentions that the tool is getting dull, Duh, you used it to rough out the wood. That is the reason I use a rough out tool.

It only takes a second to change tools and I can rough out the wood to almost the final shape with a rough out gouge. It is much easier to sharpen a rough out gouge than a skew. Granted it isn't hard to sharpen a skew but I like my skews really sharp and if you use it to rough out wood it won't be as sharp as it could be for the final passes.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#8

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

charlie belden

>The skew is my favorite tool which I started using when I first got started - turning between centers - AFTER Peter Pipe showed me how to put a curve in the cutting edge to get the long point and the heel corner back a bit.

If you notice while he's roughing to round and hogging off wood - he's using the long point going to his left and the heel going to his right as he works back and forth on the blank. And he's working ABOVE center NOT below center. Less apt to have the tip dive INTO the wood if something goes wrong.

When he's doing planing cuts to get a nice surface he's using the middle 2/3rds of the cutting edge. With a straight edged skew that means you have to present the edge at about 45 degrees to the long axis of the work. With a curved edge skew you don't have to angle the skew like that in order to keep the long point and heel corner from contacting the wood - and screwing up your smooth planing cut.

Once you get the skew down, try a bedan. If you think this demonstration seemed a bit shocking - check out Escoulen doing the same type of thing, with a 3/8" bedan (think THICK 3/8th inch bench chisel).

It looks much scarier than it actually is - both with a skew as well as with a bedan.

His point about Why use two or three tools when one will do? probably doesn't go over when with turning gouge makers and sellers - who'd prefer you to think that you need a dozen or so specialized to do one thing really well tools - at $50 to $150 a pop.

Check out the link below and a few pages after it.


Some Skewing Around

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#9

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

charlie belden

>John:

If you look closely, you'll notice that most of the roughing is done with the long point and the heel corner, the planing/peeling cuts being done with the "middle" 2/3rds of the cutting EDGE. And when roughing a round, he starts with the long point and then switches to the "2/3rds" for the smoother final roll.

The skew, especially if it has a curved cutting edge - which still has a long point and heel - has two distincly different functions - one using the "corners" and one using the "middle 2/3rds".

Now someone's going to ask

"But with a curved cutting edge, don't you only have a single point of contact that's cutting - when you do a finish/planing cut since the edge is curved?"

Yes, with a curved cutting edge that's true. However, with a straight cutting edge, it's ALSO true. It's just than with a straight cutting edge you present the edge at about 45 degrees to the long axis of the lathe and the round cross section you're cutting presents a single point of contact as you move along the cut.

With a curved cutting edge skew, you can switch continuously from one to the other, something you can't always do with a straight cutting edge skew.

Look at the animation at the bottom of the attached page - and the "still frames" illustration above the animation to see what I mean about transitioning.


Ogee cut with skew

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#10

Re: Skew questions

john lucas

>Charlie I agree in principal but having used both I know it gets dull. When you use toe down or heel down you are usually working with the an area a little ways up from the end. I'll say 1/3 but that does vary. When you are planeing you are using some area on either side of the 1/2 way up (which is in the ball park of 1/3 from the tip) so in affect you are using the same areas.

I'm not saying that you do use exactly the same spot and when I cut up to a corner or toward the bottom of the bead I am using the very tip. It's just that I know from experience that if you rough with the skew you will have to stop and sharpen more often. This is true with a curved or straight edge.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#11

Re: Skew questions

john lucas

>Curved or straight is something that we can argue about all day. My friend Nick Cook and I love the straight edge and don't see any advantage to the curved edge. Obviously you and Alan Lacer like the curved edge. I think it's whatever you get used to.

I see myself as sort of a production turner and will use the tool I have in my hand as long as I can. However some tools simply do the job better and you have to include stopping to sharpen occasionally in your production mentality so that comes into play. That's why I prefer the rough out gouge to the skew for getting something into shape.

I do try other methods and techniques from time to time to see if they will work for me. I have flat and curved bevel skews I'm currently playing with. I don't see an advantage to the curved bevel either so far but I'm still testing that one.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#12

Re: Sharp is more important than geometry

Russ Fairfield

>When it comes to a skew, sharp is more important than geometry. Most of the problems people have with a skew is from trying to cut wood with a dull tool.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#13

Re: Sharp is more important than geometry

Ken Ward

>I don't mean to hijack the thread here,for one thing,I have gotten some great tips from it.I just ordered a Doug Thompson 3/4 and can't wait to learn how to use it,BUT I have a major issue with this type of teaching(the video)for one this guy can probably do it in his sleep

and he should take into account that noob's can't do what he can with this tool.His comment on changing tools is a waste of time,not only doesn't make sense as that is why they make different tools for different jobs and if I picked that skew up and tried to round off a square blank like that,It would probably end up with the tool stickin out of my head or other body parts.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#14

Sort of

Bill Howatt

>I don't disagree with your general thoughts but I didn't really see the video as much of an instructional video for teaching new turners, more of a demo on "how to turn a handle/spindle with a skew and see how fast I can do it with one tool". It is obvious he is pushing the speed when he drops off the toolrest. An instructional video to teach the technique would have spent time on how to hold the tool, present it to the wood, etc in way more detail and they would remove falling off the toolrest.

IF we had all the tools that were designed specially for optimally turning each feature in a piece, there wouldn't be enough room to store them all. Also, some people actually find using a tool that isn't considered the best for a job by many, to work better for them. The skew is indeed used by many turners as a roughing tool on square stock.

Bill

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#15

Re: Skew questions

robo hippy

>Well, that was an interesting video. The first time I saw a skew used as a roughing tool was the first turning video I ever saw, and it was Richard Raffin. He used pretty much the same tecnique. For me, I will rough with one tool, and use a freshly sharpened one for the finish cuts. It wastes less time to put down the dull tool and pick up a freshly sharpened one than it does to do the extra time spent pushing a dull tool through the wood and the extra sanding you have to do if you finish cut with a dull tool.

As far as the chattering and wave patterns, there are 2 points that haven't been made yet. One is the 10 to 1 ratio. A 10 inch long spindle with a diameter of 1 inch will have almost no vibration. There is enough wood mass to keep it stable. Longer than that, and it will start to 'whip' or vibrate. You can learn to use your fingers as a steady rest to help stabilize the spindle to reduce the whipping. Fingers on the side of the spindle away from the tool rest cause you don't want your fingers to get sucked down inbetween the tool rest and the spindle. DAMHIKT.

I saw one turner once who commented on the skew. Some thing like this, "Some say use the point of the skew, some say use the heel, I say use this," and he held up a spindle gouge. Use what works for you. I did like a skwechigouge, when I used Allen Battey's at a turning workshop, similar to the sorby spindle master, but a half section of round bar stock ground to 30 degrees. Wonderful tool for beads and coves. Also like a Eli Avisera grind (convex with the heel of the bevel ground down round) on the skews for the same thing.

robo hippy

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew questions

Keith Tompkins

>Hey John, you should try sharpening a skew after a student uses it as a can opener! :0

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew questions

Keith Tompkins

>I would like to raise a couple of points on the video. First, notice the high tool rest...yes, that's how we're told to use the skew. Trouble is, when one wants to turn advanced forms between centers, that high tool rest becomes an impediment to better turning. Why? Notice how easily the turner roughs out a basic cylindrical shape...nothing to it. Now, look at the trouble he has trying to form the end of the handle. Watch closely, as he simultaneously raises the handle as he rolls the tool, all the while keeping the point in contact with the wood and the bevel rubbing. (Don't mean to be critical here, as we all have trouble occasionally, but the turner kinda blows his theory concerning efficiency when he has to return the end of the handle several times....when it only needed to be turned once)If he were to lower the tool rest, the end of the handle could be turned with the tool staying on the same plane, without the contortions needed with the high rest. And, he could actually SEE the cut...as it is, the tool is blocking his view of the cut. It will take some practice, but try lowering the tool rest a bit at a time until you can remove wood right at the centerline..you will notice a big improvement with all spindle tools, not just the skew.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#19

I stuck mine in the concrete one day.

john lucas

>I dropped it off the lathe and of course it hit point first and actually stuck standing up. Boy that took some grinding and had to change the geometry a little to get the point sharp again.

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#20

You must have weak concrete.

Paul Zerjay

>

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#21

Paul Kramer

Thanks to everyone

Paul Kramer

>All,

I really appreciate all of the input. The handles were about 11 inches long and between 1" and 1 1/8" diameter. I didn't think they were flexing but I wasn't sure. I don't think I had the tail stock too tight. Tool sharpness -- I thought was pretty good but maybe not -- I'll work on that some more. I also think I need to work on the angle of tool presentation to the work and the pressure. As I got more chatter I think I did the opposite of what I should have done -- probably out of frustration. So, I have some stuff to work on. At the next IndyFest I'll get some more coaching and probably more stuff to work on.

Paul

Re: Skew questions *LINK*

#22

True for ANY Cutting Tool

charlie belden

>Russ wrote:

When it comes to a skew, sharp is more important than geometry. Most of the problems people have with a skew is from trying to cut wood with a dull tool.

============

THAT is true for ANY cutting tool. It's dull tools that cause most of the hell - mainly because you tend to Lean In On It to compensate for it being dull. And with cutting tools (and an incoming left jab or right hook) you don't want to Lean Into It.

If you have to Lean Into It, have bandages at the ready - and maybe a clean pair of shorts handy.