Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

Posts

PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#1

PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

charlie belden

>Paul Z. posted a photo "3 Pedestal Forms" earlier that got into a discussion about proportions - height to major diameter, % above and % below horizontal centerline, the Rule of 3rds ( I like the Rule of 5ths -2/5ths above, 3/5ths below), etc..

Lacking actual measurements, the discussion was subjective - "It looks to me like . . ."

Of course that's how we see and experience a piece - subjectively. But underlying the subjective, there's often some actual, quantifiable, relationships that can be analyzed (OK, so I was trained as an engineer and I'm the only one who wants numbers and ratios and percentages) - and used in future pieces we do.

So - I brought Paul's photo into PhotoShop, got some numeric data using PhotoShops "guides" and "rulers/scale" and popped some of those numbers into a spreadsheet to get some ratios and percentages. ( I can't help it, my dad was an accountant and I've been playing with numbers since I was three - maybe 4.)

Surprise, surpirse, surprise. The two I preferred are close to The Rule of 5ths - 2/5ths (40%) above centerline, 3/5ths (60%) below centerline.

And the height to major diameter more or less followed one part of The Rule of 3rds, the height being about 3 times the major diameter.

The one that several respondents felt was too centered - the middle one - isn't actually centered - but is close enough to centered (4% off) to be perceived as centered.

Studying, quantitatively, pieces that you subjectively like can be quite useful when you start working out the proportions of the next piece. PhotoShop (and I'm sure other applications) is a great design tool, in addition to all the image manipulation features it has.

Try it. You might discover The Secrets of Perfect Proportions - or not. Either way, you'll probably learn something useful - or not.

Just something to consider.


img

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#2

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

Hal Taylor

>Quite interesting. I'm going to have to try doing this!

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#3

pleasing to the eye works every time

bob davis

>

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#4

Re: pleasing to the eye works every time

charlie belden

>Sure. But it helps to have an idea of where you're going - or - if you're at all like I am - end up with very pleasing to the eye - minatures ; )

( I just KNOW there's a pleasing to the eye piece somewhere in this chunk of wood! All I need to do is keep turning 'til I find it. . .)

And not all of use have an eye for great proportions - which is why I look for ways to figure out what it is about a piece that makes it pleasing to my eye - and then use what I may learn to make my pieces more pleasing to my eye.

May be a fool's errand - like trying to define "art" - or for that matter - "pornography". "I know it when I see it." is just too loose for a legal system to use - and "blind" turners - like me ; ).

Great designs are wonderful. But being able to at least define some envelope of why they're great designs can cut down on a lot of trial and error. Even given an inexhausible supply of suitable wood, and an infinite amount of time to experiment - I'd prefer to spend some time trying to figure out some "envelopes" for good designs - to me -and maybe cut down on both wood consumption and wasted turning time - just a little even.

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#5

Another Example

charlie belden

>This is one of Cindy Drozda's pieces featured from the Elegant Forms Contest page. The "dimensions shown are derived in PhotoShop and not the actual dimensions of the piece. Just after ratios and percentages.

Looks like The Rule of Fifths - upside down, 2/5ths(40%) below max diam., 3/5ths (60%) above.

This method of quantitively examining a piece is really pretty easy to do - and sometimes reveals something that isn't obvious. Cindy does have some guidelines and rules of thumb that she uses - and they work really well for her.


img

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#6

Re: Another Example

Barry Turner

>I do okay with this shape being pleasant to the eye until I get to the base. It just looks way too small to me.........like it would allow the piece to topple over at the slightest breeze. Maybe it's a beautiful shape, but it doesn't appear to be a practical design.

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#7

But if you widen the pedestal, or

charlie belden

>just the foot of the pedestal the delicate balance of the piece is lost.

Widen the whole pedestal just horizontally and the piece gets bottom heavy looking.

Widen just the foot of the pedestal and the piece looks like it might snap off just above the foot of the pedestal.

But this shows another possibility for studying a piece with a graphic program - the ability to see what changes would do to the look of the overall piece.


img

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#8

Yeah........but...........

Barry Turner

>You're probably right about destroying the delicate balance of the piece by widening the base.

Personally, I would hate to pay what Drozda charges for one of her beautiful and delicate pieces and have it come crashing to the floor into hundreds of pieces, just because someone slammed a door a bit too hard.

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#9

Re: Yeah........but...........

charlie belden

>Don't let the appearance of delicate balance fool you. Based on getting to handle and examine a similar piece of hers, the wall thickness to the outside of the piece is thin, thicker towards the bottom. And the lid probably wasn't turned down to 1/8" either - so there's a lot more weight directly over the pedestal's foot than your eyes tell you there is.

And besides, a little museum wax on the bottom of the pedestal, pressed firmly down onto its display surface and a kid on a pogo stick bouncing up and down next to it probably won't cause a problem. If you do it right, the wall or the cabinet its in will go over before the piece does.

Re: PhotoShop to Analyze Proportions from Photo

#10

ps - had to pay a plumber or electrician lately

charlie belden

>Given the time and effort and hard earned skills - along with innate ability - I'm betting she's making less per hour than a plumber, electrician or auto mechanic.

If she were in it for the money - I suspect we wouldn't have her many wonderfully elegant pieces around to see and enjoy.