Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

What's up with chucks?

Posts

What's up with chucks?

#1

What's up with chucks?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>As the Tomlee lathe slowly comes to life I going to need a chuck (I figure) and at least a drive center.

I want to make some chisel handles and spindles for now.

Anyway can I get away with only a drive center?

Do I need a chuck? If so which one?

I see there's a lot out there, I don't need (nor does my lathe can handle) a large one. I've been eyeballing the Penn State "barracudas" number 2 seems to come with everything I would need. Then again, I have now clue what I'm talking about.

You all have been great for advise! Yet, as always I could use some more...

Re: What's up with chucks?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: What's up with chucks?

Dick Hines

>You don't need a chuck the turn handles. Just turn them between centers.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#3

Re: What's up with chucks?

Bill Howatt

>You don't need a chuck to turn spindles or tool handles which are spindles anyway. You just need a spur center at the headstock end and a live center in the tailstock. You could even use a dead center in the tailstock but you don't see that much these days.

Chucks tend to be used for bowls but they also have their uses in turning anything that isn't easily supported between centers. If you get right down to it, chucks aren't essential for bowls and probably most other things however they often make holding some workpieces much easier. There are lots of bowl turners including pros who never use a chuck.

Bill

Re: What's up with chucks?

#4

Re: What's up with chucks?

charlie belden

>You'll at some point - in the not too distant future - want to do the next step from spindles - finials for weed pots/ring holders. You can drill

the hole for the weed with a hand drill or drill press but you'll need to be able to support just one end of the stock of the finial.

And then you really step on to the slippery slope.

Starting with spindle turning - and really learning to turn coves and beads and lips and . . . is really a great way to learn how to use your turning tools - on the outside of things, how to sharpen them, how cuts work cutting down hill but not so well cutting up hill - and you'll get to know a lot of different woods and grain since you can play with 3/4"x3/4" blanks you can probably get for free.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Like they said.......

Jesper, Denmark

>Yuo do not need a chuck for spindle work, but it sure does make drilling out the tool handles much easier.

I have two Oneway Stronghold, which have served me well for a long time. The smaller Oneway Talon also has a good reputation.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#6

Faceplate ?

Doc Green

>Scott, neither you nor anyone who responded mentioned faceplates.

Chucks are a fairly recent innovation in woodturning. You can do a lot with a faceplate. ~Doc

Re: What's up with chucks?

#7

OK Charlie, what the heck are...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>finials for weed pots/ring holders? Remember I'm a total rookie here. Never turned anything.

Thanks!

Re: What's up with chucks?

#8

Well Doc, That's because...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I don't know what I'm talking about most of the time. I'm struggling with a big learning here, and all of you have been a great help.

Thanks, I'll do some looking into faceplates.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#9

Re: OK Charlie, what the heck are... *LINK*

charlie belden

>Scott:

Sorry about that. Fell into the Common Knowledge Trap - again. Should know better because that's one of my pet peeves - things a newbie needs to know - but more experienced folks don't bother to mention that stuff because they assume Everyone Knows That.

Wander around and click on links on the attached web page. It's in chronological order starting when I got a JET mini lathe - to turn wheels and axles for neighborhood kids' summer wood projects (a few have gone on to building skate board ramps and tables and grind rails with support stands). Should give you some ideas for things to turn that can be done Between Centers, and probably get you thinking about acquiring a chuck.

I live down "at the bottom of the hill" from you, near 17 at Camden/San Tomas. E-mail me if you want to set up a Show and Tell.

There's also Silicon Valley Woodturners, a turning club of about 65 members - that has a formal monthly meeting the first Wednesday of each month and weekly informal Saw Dust Sessions on the in between Wednesdays. Several members are active in the mentoring program and we've got some of the best wood scroungers on the planet - with chainsaws, trucks and hooked into the network of arborists and tree trimmers.

Check out www.svwoodturners.org

Attached image is a Ring Holder with Finial (the brown thing on top). Sit it next to the sink, take off a ring (or two) and slip it/them over the top. Keeps rings from building up soap scum - and may prevent one or more from a visit to the garbage disposal - or getting lost.


img

Weed pots, finials, ring holders, etc.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#10

Re: Well Doc, That's because...

charlie belden

>Might want to pick up a copy of Fred Holder's book on the amazing array of things people have come up with to hold wood for turning.

If you get down this way I'll gladly loan you my copy.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#11

Re:Scot- forget the faceplate and....

Jamie Donaldson

>...spend the money for a chuck- much more useful!

Re: What's up with chucks?

#12

No worries Charlie...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I do this all the time on the Handtool forum. When I get closer to getting the lathe I love some show and tell, thank you for the offer!

Weed pots... Boy o boy, did I have a different thoughts running through head.

Thanks for the link!

Scott

Re: What's up with chucks?

#13

chucks and faceplates etc. *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>You do not NEED a four jaw chuck, it is simply nice to have for some stuff. I have a really good One Way and I do not bother with it for bowls. Chucks are just too much hassle for bowls as far as I am concerned. If you take a look at my web site (sound of me blowing my own horn) you can find lots of stuff to make with or without a chuck. Remember that four jaw chucks are very recent and we have been turning for thousands of years. If you read one of the old books about turning and they mention chucks the like mean screw chucks or jam chucks.


Around the Woods

Re: What's up with chucks?

#14

ebd

Re: chucks and faceplates etc.

ebd

>I agree that you don't "need" a chuck. On the rest I couldn't disagree with you more. I have found the chucks and all of the jaw sets that I have to be absolutely wonderful. I wouldn't want to turn (especially) bowls without them. I did it for a long time and I would never go back. I even find them invaluable for turning the handles for my limited edition CobraHead (Registered Trademark by Noel Valdes) weeding tools. It's a multi step process that is much simpler and faster with a chuck and the right jaws. The productivity increase is something I would not want to do without.

Yes turning has been around without chucks for a long time. If you were to build the pyramids now would you use the same methods, or might you be humble enough to use cranes, dozers, etc.???????

Re: What's up with chucks?

#15

Re: chucks and faceplates etc.

Barry Elder

>Please forgive a failing memory, but it seems to me that there was a discussion about chucks/vibration/faceplates that involved some very experienced woodturners whose opinions are fact-based and I found it very interesting if you are going to be turning hollow forms. I believe that John Jordan stated his reasons for using face plates for hollow forms because of vibration with chucks. While they may be convenient, chucks are not the be-all and end-all for woodturners.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#16

Couldn't agree more

john lucas

>having enough time to turn has been a major problem for me. Having several chucks with different jaws has sped up the procedures so much. I turned with nothing but faceplates for a long time, and still do for larger hollow vessels and/or bowls where a tenon might be weak. Being able to grab a chuck and almost instantly begin working or change from turning the outside to the inside in seconds has really increased my productivity.

Re: What's up with chucks?

#17

IMO, you are correct

Bill Howatt

>Sure not essential but would I want to stop using one - absolutely not!

We all talk about tool control as being key to good turning. The other equally important thing that is often a stumbling block in the design process is how to hold the workpiece securely. A chuck provides some more options and for a lot more things than just bowls.

Bill