>Robbo Hippy brings up a good point below. Sanding green wood is a pain. It clogs the sandpaper instantly. If the LDD will help this I might be willing to give it a try.
I turn many of my green bowls to completion so I want to sand them on the lathe while they are still round if I can. Sometimes I can dry the surface with a hair dryer enough to let me sand. You don't want to get it too hot because you can get surface checks. I blow out as much water as I can before hitting it with the hair dryer.
The sandpaper will still clog so I use a metal file card (the tool you use to clean a file after using it or when it gets clogged) to clean the big chunks out of the paper and then a crepe sandpaper cleaner to get the rest.
I've played a little bit with the mesh sandpapers and they do not clog but I had the cheap stuff and it leaves odd scratches. I need to buy some of the good quality stuff from the sanding glove and give it a try.
>I did try the drying methods of hair drier, spinning, using wet/dry abrasives, and gave up on that. It just takes so much extra time. Much easier to let it dry, and sand the warped bowls. You do need a power sander, and it really helps to have a lathe that will slow down to 10 rpm or so. All of the 3 phase motors can do that, and my PM3520 A model would do that. My Robust will do that, but had to be reprogramed. This came up once on the AAW forum, as the newer 3520 B models, and probably the Jet 3 phase lathes now all are programmed to shut off at 50 rpm. I called them, and they seemed horrified that I would want to do that. They said that the motor would over heat, and fry the electronics. If some one wanted to do that to their lathe, it could be done, but you have to send it in, and it would void the warrantee. I told them that I had sanded out thousands of bowls this way and the motor never got hot and asked them to explain. They said they had tested it in their lab, and the motor got too hot. I asked how hot that was and they said they didn't know, as they didn't have a thermometer on it. Sounds like 'company policy' to me. I used to check my Robust right after I had it changed, and the motor got mildly warm, not as warm as when I do heavy turning. Not even close to how hot my Delta 2 hp planer got when I ran oak through it for about 2 hours straight. A power sander will turn the wood for you, and you hold the wood from spinning with one hand, and the sander with the other.
The LDD method was developed by Ron Kent for dealing with the big vessels that he did, and I think particularly for Norfolk Island Pine. If you have ever tried to sand pine, you know what that is like. Every once in a while I will sand one out that hasn't been soaked. I am still surprised at the difference. Difficult woods don't burn or glaze over. The dust comes off more like big wet snow flakes rather than the powder. There is no taste or scent from the soap.
>I am with Robo. I just do not sand wet turnings. I tried the wet sanding technique (spraying on water while sanding). It is just way too messy and almost requires wearing full rain gear. I haven't found a sandpaper that won't clog. The closest I've found was a roll of mesh abrasive that plumbers use, but even that clogs with wet wood slurry. I usually just let them dry naturally and sand after.
>I start with the basics of cutting as cleanly as possible so that I am never really sanding all that much material. Once the turning is done, I let it dry "completely" and finish off of the lathe by hand. If I have any problem areas, I use a gooseneck scraper first, then sand.
>You can certainly sand green turnings, but have already found out how much it clogs sandpaper. It doesn't have to be at 10 RPMs but definitely low speed. I would not advocate blowing air on it either as that will dry it out unnessicerrily. You want to allow the wood to dry slowly to avoid checking and to lessen (usually) warping.
Regardless of sandpaper used, get a crepe pad to clean off the disk. A must. Add a sanding mesh/screen product like an Abralon and you are better off as it won't clog nearly as much as a fabric/paper or film disk. It is just more open. Also, to get more even sanding on a warped or misaligned piece, use a thick soft, backing pad as it will compensate for the undulating of the wood without adding uneven pressure as it goes around.
>I have had good success with wet sanding. I agree that it can be messy, but I put a plastic sheet over the lathe bed and wear my apron and face shield and let her rip. I keep a dish of water at hand and frequently slosh the sandpaper in the water to rinse off most of the residue. If you keep the wood really wet, the sawdust does not seem to stick to the paper too badly to rinse off. I find that, compared to dry sanding, wet sanding is much less prone to produce those random scratches that require going back through the grits to erase. I rinse and wipe off the slurry between grits. Dennis
Get some Astradot sanding discs from Woodchuckers in Canada. You'll find their ad in the AAW Journal. The abrasive is glued on in dots. It's slow to clog, easy to clean with a brass bristle brush if it does get some build up, and stays sharp a long time. It's all I use any more, even on dry wood.
>I learned about this technique right here several years ago, when I was trying to sand a big cottonwood vessel. I used Klingspor roll abrasives and kept them very wet with a tuna-fish can full of H2O that I kept handy. I covered my lathe bed with plastic for this operation.
>John, Years ago I watched Vic Wood turn a piece of green wood and AFTER he cleaned up all the shavings so he wouldn't set the shop on fire, he applied denatured alcohol with a spray bottle to the turning and then set it on fire! The alcohol dried the surface without causing checking and then he quickly sanded before moisture wicked to the dried surface. Worked like a charm with no clogged sandpaper or out of round turning to hand sand!
>I don't take credit for teaching Ellis about this, but I wet sand at the lathe, too. I cover up the lathe, and sand with a bowl of warm water for dipping/rinsing the abrasive. I also agree with Mike that you can get pretty messy with this method. I aim for just enough water to create a slurry, and when that starts building up, I dunk & rinse in water.
A lot of people think of "wet sanding" as using sandpaper on green wood, which clogs up very quickly. I mean continually adding water by dipping and rinsing the abrasive in a bowl of water, so instead of dust, I get gunk -- a paste of wood dust and water. If you are careful to keep the wood wet without excess water, you don't generally get it all over you. Slower speeds can help a lot, too.