Moisture meters
Claudia Hayward
>The discussion got me wondering about moisture meters. What is the best buy - affordable yet accurate? Suggestions?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Moisture meters
Claudia Hayward
>The discussion got me wondering about moisture meters. What is the best buy - affordable yet accurate? Suggestions?
Re: Moisture meters
Don Evans
>I've done without one for 40 years so didn't see real need for one if had to pay a lot for it. Was in Harbor Freight one day and saw one for (I think) about $20.00, may have been less, so I picked it up out of curiousity.
I had the chance to compare it with one costing several hundred dollars and the HF unit read the same values on 3 different pieces of wood.
Brand name was Cen-Tech, for general use I don't see any reason to pay a lot for one. Especially for a turner.
More value to someone who has a lot of green woodland, does furniture, and has their own kiln.
Remember they only read barely below the surface. You can be 12 percent 1/8" deep and still be in the 20 percent in the middle of a 4" thick blank.
Don
Re: Moisture meters
Russ Fairfield
>I agree with Don Evans. Moisture meters are a waste of money unless you are working with lumber. All moisture meters are a surface indication of moisture content, and tell us nothing about the inside of a piece of wood. A 1" board has to be measured from both sides, and there will be a difference between a planed and sawn surface.
The most accurate moisture meter is the one with pins that penetrate into the wood, but the pins are only about 1/2" long and leave holes in the wood - fine for construction lumber but not for furniture or turning wood.
For the woodturner, a digital scale is a far better investment. It is more accurate and will define when the moisture loss is stops far better than a meter.
There are other ways to measure moisture that work well for the woodturner.With a little practice they will be as accurate as any meter. Remember, we are only interested in Equiibrium Moisture Content when there is no longer moisture evaporating from the wood at ambient temperature and relative humidity.
Your own cheek is the least expensive moisture meter, and it is very adequate. With the wood at room temperature, hold it against your cheek. If it feels cool, the moisture content is still above equilibrium. If there is a neutral feeling of neither warm nor cool, the wood is at its equilibrium moisture content. And that is probably as good an indicator as anything you can buy.
You can also stick your finger into the depth hole you drill into a bowl. If it feels warm and wet, then there is moisture inside of the chunk of wood, and it may not be as dry as you think.
You can also tell a lot by grabbing a handful of shavings or sawdust. The shavings will be cooler if there is moisture evaporating. If your hands are sensitive to temperature, you can feel the difference between hot and dry and cool and moist. That is good enough most of the time, and more accurate than a moisture meter.
Re: Moisture meters
John Scheideman
>I use a Lignomat and have been very satisfied with it. I rough turn green blanks and then use the moisture meter to check them after they have dried and it seems to work well for me.
John
I agree
David Belser
>What Russ said x2
I bought one of the non-penetrating pinless ones and now only occasionally do I use it on 4/4 flat stock.
If I'm doing twice turned bowls, I'll weight them after roughing and write the weight/date on the blank. Keep weighing occasionally, when the weight stabilizes it's dry.
I should have added the meter money to what I spent on the scale.
I'll sell you my meter if you are still interested :)
- Dave
Re: I disagree...
Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.
>Since Russ's post covered so many of the issues, I will use it to rip upon...with full respect for Mr Fairfield,(as well as heartfelt thanks to him for all the help with finishes that are due him)
RUSS SAYS:
>>>" Moisture meters are a waste of money unless you are working with lumber. All moisture meters are a surface indication of moisture content, and tell us nothing about the inside of a piece of wood."<<<
MIKE REPLIES
WRONG! Read Wagner specs. and stand corrected.
RUSS:
>>>>" A 1" board has to be measured from both sides, and there will be a difference between a planed and sawn surface."<<<<
MIKE REPLIES: This does not have much meaning to a woodturner with a bowl rough-turned to 1/2" thickness.
RUSS:
>>>>"The most accurate moisture meter is the one with pins that penetrate into the wood, "<<<<<
MIKE: I don't know if that is really true anymore. But more importantly, the difference in the LEVEL of accuracy is a moot point if you think the "wood-to-cheek" method is accurate enough!
RUSS:
>>>>"For the woodturner, a digital scale is a far better investment. It is more accurate and will define when the moisture loss is stops far better than a meter.<<<<"
MIKE: I use a digital scale and at $29.95, it is a great tool for the money. The scale, however can only weigh the entire piece, and cannot differentiate pockets of moisture, or parts of the piece that are not yet assimilated. A moisture meter can. Many a turner has been fooled, I think, by the scale indicating that no more water is leaving the wood, but only the free water has transevaporated, and bound water hasn't even begun to break out yet. I often read on this forum, of turners that are baffled about their "assimilated" bowls later cracking or warping and wondering how that could happen. Using a moisture meter is a much more accurate way to know if you are ready to finish turn.
Claudia, give pause for a moment, and think about the logic of someone that says " I have gotten along all these years without one, .....so therefore it would be a waste of money for YOU"
I use my little Wagner and believe that it has saved me a few heartaches along the way...and certainly was not a waste of money!
Re: I disagree...somewhat
john lucas
>RUSS:
>>>>" A 1" board has to be measured from both sides, and there will be a difference between a planed and sawn surface."<<<<
MIKE REPLIES: This does not have much meaning to a woodturner with a bowl rough-turned to 1/2" thickness.
If you rough out to 1/2" thickness you don't need a meter. It will be dry in a few days anyway. My question is why would you rough out to 1/2" thickness. Unless it's very small it will warp enough to not go back on the lathe. for boxes and such you can rough out to that thickness but again. It still dry in less than a week.
RUSS:
RUSS:
>>>>"For the woodturner, a digital scale is a far better investment. It is more accurate and will define when the moisture loss is stops far better than a meter.<<<<"
MIKE: I use a digital scale and at $29.95, it is a great tool for the money. The scale, however can only weigh the entire piece, and cannot differentiate pockets of moisture, or parts of the piece that are not yet assimilated. A moisture meter can. Many a turner has been fooled, I think, by the scale indicating that no more water is leaving the wood, but only the free water has transevaporated, and bound water hasn't even begun to break out yet. I often read on this forum, of turners that are baffled about their "assimilated" bowls later cracking or warping and wondering how that could happen. Using a moisture meter is a much more accurate way to know if you are ready to finish turn.
I have to dissagree with this. If you weigh a bowl over a few weeks, it will change weight until it is dry enough to use. At least that is my experience. Early on when I was having bowl cracking problems and I did a lot of weighing and not taking notes. I have had a bowl stabilize in weight for 3 or 4 days but never more than a week. After years of doing this I believe the weighing method is accurate.
Claudia, give pause for a moment, and think about the logic of someone that says " I have gotten along all these years without one, .....so therefore it would be a waste of money for YOU"
Ask people like John Jordan, Clay Foster, and many other top turners who turn green wood. They will tell you that they have never owned a moisture meter either. Neither have I. I will admit that I've wanted one but purely for interest sake. I don't see how it will solve any of my problems with the rare exception of getting wood as a gift and not knowing the moisture content. In that case I simply treat it as green wood.
Not trying to step on your toes and I do like to see another side of the coin on all things but I think I have to agree with Russ on most if not all of his statements.
YMMV
David Belser
>Your mileage may vary.....
I actually gave my meter away. A few extra points that explain what led me to take this action.
First and foremost, I purchased the cheaper Wagner pinless meter. It has a flat surface that you are to hold against the wood that you want to measure. The face of this surface is about 3/4" by 2 1/2". It was impossible to hold it flat against any part of a roughed bowl other than the bottom. Any rocking of the meter when held against the bowl would give wildly different results.
It possible that a pin meter would do better but then you leave pin holes in the blank.
Second - my shop is in the basement and in the same space as the boiler. I have an indoor/outdoor temp and humidity meter. In the winter when the heat is running the relative humidity is around 30%. In the summer if the humidity exceeds 50% I turn on a dehumidifier.
Third - when I first got my scale, I chose to way a batch of green blanks daily and then charted the weight loss. This gave me a good idea of how the process goes and what a dry bowl feel like (Russ's points on sensing moisture).
If the blank stops losing weight and stays there for a few weeks, it's probably dry - Unless you are working in a shed in Bombay in monsoon season! Seriously, a little common sense should tell you if it really is at equilibrium.
I Wish that I'd bought a better scale. Mine can only weight up to about 5lbs, which excludes weighing larger blanks. It also has a very annoying short annoying auto shutoff. The scale will be useful for other stuff - like making small batches of epoxy. This is where the auto shutoff drives me nuts.
- Dave
Controversial
Russ Fairfield
>There are 3 controversial topics among woodturners that are sure to start an argument every time they are brought up in a conversation.
- Moisture Meters
- Tormek tool grinders
- Soaking wood in dishwater or denatured alcohol.
I expected that my answer would be controversial. If you want to really get mad, ask me what I think about soaking wood in the dishwater or denatured alcohol.
Re:Russ et al- I've been happily turning ....
Jamie Donaldson
>...wood for the last 24 yrs. with none of the above, and have neither need nor desire for such "aids" in the process!
Well, I'll open...
Cyril Griesbach
>this can of worms. Which do you prefer, Russ, and why? No disrespect as I always enjoy your point of view.
Re: Moisture meters
JL
>I do spindles mostly. I work with green lumber (white oak and maple) that I split out of the log and either shave or turn. I then dry in a drying chamber until they are dry. I have used a moisture meter with pins. It works quite nicely for the work that I do. If you do go this route, do not get a cheap one.
I have never used it on a bowl. I much prefer to use a scale for that.
Re: I disagree...
Don Evans
>Claudia, give pause for a moment, and think about the logic of someone that says " I have gotten along all these years without one, .....so therefore it would be a waste of money for YOU"
Please tell me Mike WHERE in my message did I tell Claudia WHAT to do?
Also, where did I say it would be a waste of money for "YOU"?
I only told of MY experience and what I consided a waste for ME, I said NO such thing as your MISQUOTES in your message and resent it greatly!!!
You want to quote, do it accurately, you want to paraphrase? then don't change the meaning or intent......
Don
if you turn a lot of bowls...
steve antonucci
>it's probably more important that you understand how different woods react that what the moisture meter says. I also use my cheek as a litmus test, and when the bowls don't feel cool, I re-turn them. Almost never lost one.
I turn a LOT of green wood, and I guarantee you that I couldn't even guess at what the numbers are. I do know when a bowl is "ready" to get back on the lathe. If you turn hollowforms, they are finish turned, so it doesn't matter as long as you are less than 1/4" wall thickness, they wont crack.
Personally, I don't need one...
Steve
Re: Controversial
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>I've been turning for a long time and I've never owned a moisture meter or a digital scale. I seldom turn wet wood to the finish. I prefer to rough turn and finish later. I date every rough turned piece and I go by that to tell when a piece is dry and ready to turn and finish. I'll admit that once in a while I find that I'm getting still-wet shavings from a piece that I thought was dry.
I too have never soaked wood in alcohol or dishwater. They might work but I've never felt the need to use them.
Wally
Re: I disagree...
Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.
>Don, I am so sorry. I quoted directly from Russ's Post (not yours)...and did not intend to cause offense to anyone.
Apologetically yours,
Mike
Re: Controversial
Keith Tompkins
>Hey Russ, you forgot number 4: The old art vs. craft debate!
Re: if you turn a lot of bowls...
Bill Crommett
>Interesting ! I must have one of those meters around some place. I had forgotten all about it 'till just now.
Re: if you turn a lot of bowls...
robo hippy
>I kind of guess it is like a digital rpm read out. Never had one, so never need one. Turn green to final thickness, LDD soak (makes them MUCH easier to sand out, but nothing else) let them dry a week or so, then sand and finish. No need for a scale, or moisture meter.
robo hippy
Re: if you turn a lot of bowls...
Barry Elder
>I don't use a moisture meter, because in Florida the weather is likely to change every hour or so. Our relative humidity is higher than most other places and I have weighed wood slabs and roughed out pieces for a long time. I have seen changes in weight of up to an ounce due to the changes in humidity in the varying weather conditions. I can understand a commercial operation using moisture meters, especially those with kilns, but for the average everyday woodturner, the marketers are just doing their job!
Interesting Discussion
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I have used moisture meters in the sawmill for years and really like the pinless for lumber. When you use this type of moisture meter you have to be careful of how you handle the wood which is being checked. If you wipe the sawdust off with your hand or blow it off the reading will be incorrect. I found this out by experimentation.
In general I have found the moisture meter to be rather useless for turnings. First of all, getting a good reading on a curved surface is tricky plus you have to be careful how you handle the piece before testing. If I am going to turn a platter or plate, I use dry wood to start with.
Determining the moisture level in a cured bowl is not critical enough (in my opinion) to justify the expense.
Re: Moisture meters
Jerry Bennett
>All successful artisans consider the properties of the material they are using in some fashion. With experience we know what will work and what will not is a given situation. It is when we push the boundaries that a little extra help is needed. In my work, I combine steel, brass and wood into a big mess. If I do not consider accurately the equilibrium moisture content in a piece, it will not be successful. I ascertain the specific gravity for each batch of wood I buy with an �oven� test, and calibrate my meter. Then a reasonable indication of the moisture content is measured for each board. This process is not appropriate for a bowl blank. I prefer a blank retain some of its water and then dry after turning, reshaping if necessary. One caveat, if you are doing threaded lids, making sure the wood is in equilibrium with the ambient environment is a must if you need for the lid to come off later. I learned this the hard way.
That should be #1 Keith :)
john lucas
>
Re: Controversial
Dick Hines
>I have found that wood turning is a lot like fishing. If you think the newest lure in the store will catch the biggest and most fish and it makes you feel good, buy it.
In turning what ever makes you feel you are doing a good job do it.
No one can afford all the things in a catalog say Lee Valley. Number one, you don't need all that stuff. Number two, you would need a hand out form the government to pay for it.
If you feel something works for you buy it.
Re: Moisture meters
Bill Howatt
>My meter is the pin type. I do find it useful when starting with wood that has been sitting around a while without being roughed as nothing more than a crude reference. However, I have jabbed it into the external tenon a few times - given its shape, I considered the remainder of the bowl to be less dry than my measurement. My roughed bowls always sit for a long time so I'm not monitoring them carefully. To be honest, the date and how badly it has gone oval are my main references.
This is very unscientific but when I was trying the dishwashing soap trick (and long since abandoned it), I felt the meter measuements were incorrect.
Bill