3 Pedestal forms
Paul Zerjay
>The tallest is 16". All Maple burl with ebony pedestals and finials.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
3 Pedestal forms
Paul Zerjay
>The tallest is 16". All Maple burl with ebony pedestals and finials.
Re:Very well done Paul, but I would ....
Jamie Donaldson
>...prefer the base details not be located in the centers, but moved up to a 1/3 distance from the bottom of the forms.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
Mike Nelson
>Great work Paul, are the fenials removable? How far did you go with the thickness of the maple burl? I tend to agree with the 'thirds rule but these are excellent.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
Cyril Griesbach
>Jamie has a point but they're still wonderful.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
charlie belden
>Paul:
Though you didn't solicit comments or suggestions . . .
Three part pieces like these and christmas ornaments with icicle and finial present the challenge of integrating the three components into a visually coherent and pleasing whole. Have any single component stand out from the rest and that wholeness breaks down. So, in my mind's eye, a continuous profile OR a crisp and clear demarcation where components meet can both work. But for me, going with both in one piece appears inconsistent and incoherent.
The two pieces on the left appear to have the pedestals flowing fairly well into the bottom of the body, the pedestal of the right piece has a clear demarcation between pedestal and body.
Then I look at the upper part of the pieces and the reverse is true, the two on the left have clear obvious demarcation - body to finial - while the one on the right has a smoother more continuous transition.
Going with smooth continuous curves at the transitions does take a bit more planning, leaving enough wall thickness in the body for "inlaying" the finial and pedestal then blending them. And it does require turning the interface and adjacent areas to a smooth transition and holding the parts to do that turning can be "interesting"/"challenging" but rewarding if pulled off well.
The disadvantage of the inlayed and turned continuous approach idea is that you can't swap out a finial or pedestal - no option for mixing and matching that the clear demarcation approach allows. You must commit to the idea - or come up with tricky ways to recover if things don't work out. For me, recovery seldom works and it's Do It Again time.
Nice forms, great technique, finish works to bring out the figure and texture without distracting shiny, proportions and form pleasing, balance of the two on the right fine (the one on the left looks to centered to me) you've got as close to Drozda finials as one can get without being Cindy and the photography is well done and no lighting hot spots.
It's just those transitions that keep these from being "just so" - to me.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
Paul Zerjay
>Thanks Charlie. You (anyone actually) can critique my stuff anytime you see fit brother. I appreciate your honesty, and insight.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
nickt
>Just love them
Nick
Re:Very well done Paul, but I would ....
Paul Zerjay
>Jamie. I personally don't see the 3rd's rule that big of a deal. I kinda like them the way they are. I see Charlies response of the flow into, and out of, the main body as more of an issue.
Re: 3 Pedestal forms
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>I would tend to agree with Paul about the division on the pedestals. For bowls, hollow forms, and things like that, a major feature or diameter right in the middle tends to deaden the form, and can make a piece look clunky. But spindle work is more in the realm of furniture type stuff, and a mid point divider is often found in pieces like that. So it is natural for me to see this as a good way to divide the piece with the details, making it somewhat symmetrical on the top and bottom. Of the three, I actually like the pedestal in the middle the best because it is symmetrical throughout. That symmetry is not required on every piece, but I think it can be an asset in a case like this.