Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Risk Assessment Time

Posts

Risk Assessment Time

#1

Risk Assessment Time

Carl Barton

>As I sit here with a cut over my left eye brow and nursing a knott the size of a large marble with a bag of ice, it is time to assess what I did wrong.

I had been turing a 9 3/4 walnut bowl, I had finished most of the outside to the desired shape, did some work on the inside and decided to work a bit more on the outside. My speed was about 800rpm, but I turned it up a bit more to 1200 (mistake #2????). I was taking a small shavings off when the bowl flew off and hit me in the head. I quickly turned everything off, put my hand to my head and felt a few drops of blood, not much. Went inside, got a bag of ice and cleaned up blood to take a good look, nothing major.

I went back out to find the bowl, and I saw the number one reason why the bowl snapped off my chuck. I FAILED TO NOTICE a knott where the bowl was chucked, it was only a very small knott, but underneath this knott was a LARGE inclusion that ran all the way accross the wood. Thus creating a very weak area and when I was shaving the wood off I had a catch which caused the bowl to snapped off the chuck.

I learned a very valuable lesson, which I should have known better already, not to use any wood with a knott where it is going to be chucked.

Anyone else see what I could have done to avoid this?

Carl

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#2

wear helmet and face shield?

adrien

>

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#3

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Sean Troy

>I hope you heal quickly and don't get gun shy. Was the bowl chucked compression mode or expansion mode?

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#4

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Carl Barton

>Sean,

No way I will be gun shy but I will be a be more careful. The bowl was in the compression mode. The reason why I feel it failed was the knott, while small when you looked at it,when it broke off the chuck you could see that the inclusion ran all the way accross the bottom of the bowl. There was no way you could have seen this by looking at the knott. I am just happy that I was not hurt bad enough to go the doctor and that it happened early enough in the turning that I can save the turning.

The bowl is a segemented turing, the bottom being a solid disk, but includes 300 pieces, the majority being the feature ring. I spent 6 days on the feature ring and it would have been a shame to loose it all. SO now I will cut off the bottom and put a new piece in it's place.

Carl

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#5

Re: Risk Assessment Time

bob davis

>FACE SHILD ALWAYS!

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#6

Re: Risk Assessment Time

robo hippy

>I tend to burn any piece of wood that has flaws in it. Unless the piece is 'special' it isn't worth the extra work to fix it. Also, any flaw is a weak spot, from cracks to punky wood to knots. This problem is much greater if it is where you are attaching the wood to the lathe, which is where the most stress will be focused.

Also, stand out of the line of fire when possible, which is most of the time, and wear a face mask otherwise.

robo hippy

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#7

I cannot believe any1 turns without a faceshield!

Mike Brazeau

>

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#8

Re: I cannot believe any1 turns without a faceshie

Carl Barton

>I have always protected my eyes with safety glasses, not a full face shield, I just never thought about using one. Even if I had been wearing one I am not so sure I would not have got out of this with no injuries. In fact, all the turners I have been around do not use a face shield, saftey glasses only.

Carl

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#9

Steven Antonucci

Where you stand is the single biggest risk

steve antonucci

>I demonstrate a fair amount, and folks are always commenting that I don't wear a faceshield when demoing. It is very difficult to talk with a faceshield on, so I assume some risk that I manage by positioning my body out of the "danger zones".

In general, I don't want to be struck in the face with a large chunk of wood even if I am wearing a shield. I've had it happen, and while the shield absorbs a lot of the blow, you are still being smacked in the face with a big chunk of wood, and yes, it still hurts. And by the way, sometimes the wood hits you in the chest or the arms- and a faceshield doesn't improve that one bit...

The single best thing you can do to minimize injury is to learn how these things happen, and where the wood is going to go if they do and then make it a priority to NOT BE STANDING there! I watch new turners getting pummelled by shavings and flying chips all of the time. Not having finer tool control will also increase the risks of catching, which induces a lot of stress into the spinning piece. If you are cutting it "wrong", a catch can grab a large hunk of wood and send it flying in an instant.

Sorry that you had to learn about some of the dangers of turning the way most of us have learned them. Heal quickly, and wear a shield for now!

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#10

Re: I cannot believe any1 turns without a faceshie *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

>Carl - I don't think you can ever be too safe. Did you see my posting from earlier in the summer? An supposed experienced turner was killed in our area when the wood broke up on the lathe and struck him. We have not determined if a face shield was in use, but I am inclined to think not. First item on AAW Red Warning Label is to wear a face shield. Demonstrators are not the best indicator unfortunately of safe turning practices.


img

Woodturning fatality July 13, 2009

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#11

Re: Where you stand is the single biggest risk

Carl Barton

>Thank you for all your comments. After what happened today I belive I am going to make a trip to my local Woodcraft for a faceshield. It may not solve all issues, but as was mentioned earlier, one can be too safe.

Carl

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#12

Mike Mills

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Mike Mills

>Hope you are doing well now. This is the third I have heard of in the last month.

Do a little research on the face shield specs. If you shop on line, Amazon has the same one a wood working store has; the store is about $55 and Amazon is about $27 with free shipping. This is for the standard safety rating (will not fracture when a one-inch steel ball is dropped 50 inches). Amazon also has an upgraded (high impact) model for about $31 but no free shipping.

Mike

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#13

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Walter Ahlgrim

>Thank goodness your injuries were relatively minor. Any turner who says he doesn�t stand on the danger zone must have longer tools than I have seen. Seriously every turner positions their eyes in the best location to see the cut and that often put their head in the throw zone. You may stand to the side when you start or change speeds but once you start cutting you are not thinking about where your head is. There is no way anyone can predict at what direction wood will fly and next bounce could go in anywhere with almost as much force.

When you look for a face shield only buy one rated by ANSI Z87.1. This will not protect you from heavy flying objects but it will spread the impact. The flaws in the wood are often very attractive and must be treated with caution. Close calls have changed what woods I will turn and how fast. Let�s all play safely

Walta

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#14

You're lucky it wasn't worse ...

Fred Meyers, MD

>Had the wood flown a fraction of an inch lower, you would have been facing hours of surgery reconstructing your nasal and pharyngeal structures, and years healing. In fact, one of the hardest areas to rebuilt is the nasal structure and I know many an unfortunate person who never fully recover from such an injury.

Ever heard of Russian Roulette? Because that is what you're playing at by turning without a face shield or driving drunk without a seat belt.

The best risk assessment is never to turn without a face shield!

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#15

demonstrators without face shields

Fred Meyers, MD

>I don't get the excuse of not wearing face shields because they can't speak. Most of the demonsrations I've been recently at use microphones anyway, which remove that excuse.

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#16

Happy to hear you are OK Carl

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#17

Re: demonstrators without face shields

john lucas

>Speaking in a mike with a face shield on is like talking into a speaker phone. I hate that sound and I'm sure others do as well. When I demonstrate I take good sound wood, I turn at speeds a little slower than normal and I don't take aggressive cuts. As Steve said I stand out of the line of fire. It is a possible risk no doubt but I feel I've reduced the risk to an acceptable level.

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#18

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Barry Elder

>Sorry about your standing in the line of fire, but everyone does it at some time or other. Heal quickly! The same thing has happened to me but I always wear a face shield. Doesn't change the fact that there will always be hidden dangers with wood.

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#19

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Carole Valentine

>When you get a shield, be sure and get one with the anti-foag coating! Not sure if the one at Amazon is or not...there is a price difference between the anti-fog and regular. I got mine from thesandingglove.com

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#20

Re: Risk Assessment Time

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>I have some pretty strong opinions on this, and I come from experience with wood coming apart on the lathe, wood coming off the lathe, and demonstrating extensively as well as turning all by myself in the shop. I am sure that some of this will come off as confrontational, and it is certainly controversial, but I do not mean offense to anyone.

Simply put, there is no excuse for not wearing a face shield. It is well documented that people who get hit in the face suffer injury to very sensitive parts. If we are spinning wood, sooner or later it is going to happen to us. I have seen with my own eyes people being hit in the face (shield) with shattered pen blanks, so don't think it can't happen to you. Steve, you are a friend of mine, but you are playing chicken with your eyesight as well as your facial features as the bait. Did you not learn from the CA glue in your eye?

One of the comments I get from people all over the country is how much they appreciate my using a face shield while demonstrating. It is not impossible, and it is not even hard to do. It takes a few extra seconds to take it off and put it on, but the last thing I want is a bunch of strangers trying to save my life or stop the bleeding because I got smacked in front of a crowd.

John, you mentioned you only use sound wood. I submit that there is no such thing - at least that you can see beforehand, unless you have special powers the rest of us do not possess. There is always a chance of a hidden inclusion, a micro fissure that is going to separate, or some foreign object that may manifest itself as a flying object without warning. Iron objects often announce their presence with stain, but other metals, glass, rocks, etc, are not so accommodating.

Then there is operator error. Sometimes the chuck is not clamped properly on the wood, or sometimes we miss a small defect that will cause the tenon to separate. Sometimes all it takes is a catch at the right (wrong?) time. Lots of things can happen, and we are only fooling ourselves when we say we are careful and it won't happen to us.

This is one area where we can reduce the possibility of injury to almost none, but many people seem to think it is too inconvenient to do so. I have a friend who has had reconstructive surgery on his face, not once, but twice. How dumb do you have to be?

When I am not in the shop, I spend my time with firearms. This is another area of life that is very unforgiving of mistakes and accidents. The only way to do it right is to observe proper safety procedures and never deviate from them. Otherwise, if becomes when, and when is usually permanent once it happens. Don't let it happen to you on the lathe.

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#21

Well Said Bill.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#22

everyone should read bill assessment

bob davis

>

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#24

Bought My Face Shield

Carl Barton

>After what happended to me yesterday and reading all the comments I went and bought my face shield today. It meets all the required standards and it is anit-fog too.

I went back to turning this morning and I USED THE SHIELD and I had no problems at all. In fact it is one that curves around the face and has protection on my forehead.

After 33 yrs in the Navy, and all the ORM (Operational Risk Assessment, for those who do not know what that means)the Navy had me using all those years, I made the major mistake of not using it at home, and I have only been retired eight months now.

I want to thank everyone for your strong recommendations and suggestions.

By the way, I was able to save my segmented turing, finsihed most of it today, I just have to sand the inside and finsh the bottom. After spending more than 2 weeks getting the bowl to this stage ( 230 pieces) I was sure happy that I could save it.

Carl

Re: Risk Assessment Time

#25

Re: Bought My Face Shield

Mike Brazeau

>Way to go Carl. Hopefully many others will follow your move.