Re: Risk Assessment Time
Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA
>I have some pretty strong opinions on this, and I come from experience with wood coming apart on the lathe, wood coming off the lathe, and demonstrating extensively as well as turning all by myself in the shop. I am sure that some of this will come off as confrontational, and it is certainly controversial, but I do not mean offense to anyone.
Simply put, there is no excuse for not wearing a face shield. It is well documented that people who get hit in the face suffer injury to very sensitive parts. If we are spinning wood, sooner or later it is going to happen to us. I have seen with my own eyes people being hit in the face (shield) with shattered pen blanks, so don't think it can't happen to you. Steve, you are a friend of mine, but you are playing chicken with your eyesight as well as your facial features as the bait. Did you not learn from the CA glue in your eye?
One of the comments I get from people all over the country is how much they appreciate my using a face shield while demonstrating. It is not impossible, and it is not even hard to do. It takes a few extra seconds to take it off and put it on, but the last thing I want is a bunch of strangers trying to save my life or stop the bleeding because I got smacked in front of a crowd.
John, you mentioned you only use sound wood. I submit that there is no such thing - at least that you can see beforehand, unless you have special powers the rest of us do not possess. There is always a chance of a hidden inclusion, a micro fissure that is going to separate, or some foreign object that may manifest itself as a flying object without warning. Iron objects often announce their presence with stain, but other metals, glass, rocks, etc, are not so accommodating.
Then there is operator error. Sometimes the chuck is not clamped properly on the wood, or sometimes we miss a small defect that will cause the tenon to separate. Sometimes all it takes is a catch at the right (wrong?) time. Lots of things can happen, and we are only fooling ourselves when we say we are careful and it won't happen to us.
This is one area where we can reduce the possibility of injury to almost none, but many people seem to think it is too inconvenient to do so. I have a friend who has had reconstructive surgery on his face, not once, but twice. How dumb do you have to be?
When I am not in the shop, I spend my time with firearms. This is another area of life that is very unforgiving of mistakes and accidents. The only way to do it right is to observe proper safety procedures and never deviate from them. Otherwise, if becomes when, and when is usually permanent once it happens. Don't let it happen to you on the lathe.