Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Large chuck on small lathe

Posts

Large chuck on small lathe

#1

Large chuck on small lathe

Alex Yeilding

>All the manufacturers talk about size ranges of lathe (generally in terms of swing, presumably as a proxy for bearing load) that is appropriate for each size of chuck. I know these manufacturers know a thing or three more than I about lathes and chucks, but help me understand this.

It seems to me that a big chuck on a small lathe could be a good thing, as long as you had enough bed length, and it didn't interfere with access to the "back" side of whatever you are working on.

  • Five pounds of very well-balanced mass would seem to put pretty small strain on the bearings compared to even slightly unbalanced workpieces spinning at 500-1000rpm.


  • And the flywheel action of that mass would seems to help a small and underpowered lathe run more smoothly.

The only negative I see is a little more motor strain getting the mass turning.

What am I missing? Or should I get a Titan chuck for my Jet mini? :-)

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#2

JL

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

JL

>My personal opinion only. I have a Stronghold and a Oneway scroll chuck (the one with bars). I used these on my old Delta 46-715 (with the Reeves drive). That lathe has since found a new home.

I did notice a performance difference in using the two chucks. The motor on the 46-715 is a 3/4 hp so the difference really shouldn't be that much. Maybe it was just subjective on my part - but it didn't "feel" that way.

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#3

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

john lucas

>I have a Carbo-tec as my smallest lathe. I use my Vicmarc 100 chucks on it. I think they are too big. I've used my old Nova chuck which is lighter and the Carbo-tec performs better with the lighter chuck. I thought the same thing you did, about the flywheel affect but judging from the performance on that lathe I think it isn't there.

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Large chuck on small lathe--Long Response

Dennis In Southern Oregon

>Alex,I agree that a larger chuck would add negligible additional bearing load. However, it would not reduce the bearing load caused by an unbalanced workpiece. The extra mass would reduce the shaking of the lathe by a minute amount, but for that purpose, you would be better off adding a large weight to the headstock or the lathe bed. The flywheel effect would also be negligible. In my opinion, the only advantage of a large chuck over a smaller chuck is that (with proper jaws) you can grip larger tenons. The disadvantages are many: higher cost of chuck and jaws, difficulty in using it to mount smaller workpieces, difficulty in working small pieces close to the chuck, twice the weight to lug around, and larger storage space needed.

Personally, I would advise against buying a large chuck as a first chuck regardless of the size of the lathe; wait until you have a clear need for it. I turn a wide spectrum of pieces on my Oneway 2436 and own three Vicmarc 100 chucks (each with different jaws) and one Vicmarc 120. The Vicmarc 120 is the least-used of the bunch, and there is a good argument that if it is needed, a face plate may be a better choice anyhow. My two cents. Dennis

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#5

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

Alex Yeilding

>JL, you say that there was a performance difference. But which performed better?

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#6

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks for sharing that experience, John. Do you have a feeling of WHY it seemed that the lathe performed better with the lighter chuck? Maybe the negative side of the flywheel effect, with it harder to get back up to speed after being slowed with a too heavy cut?

Re: Large chuck on small lathe

#7

Re: Large chuck on small lathe--Long Response

Alex Yeilding

>I turn a wide spectrum of pieces on my Oneway 2436 and own three Vicmarc 100 chucks (each with different jaws) and one Vicmarc 120. The Vicmarc 120 is the least-used of the bunch, and there is a good argument that if it is needed, a face plate may be a better choice anyhow.

Dennis, I think this gave me the "aha" revelation I was looking for. Thanks.

It is NOT that a large chuck is inappropriate for a small lathe, but rather that it is not appropriate for anything you are likely to be able to turn on a mini lathe. And whether you turn a 6" bowl on your big Oneway or my little mini, the answer is the same--a small chuck is more appropriate for that workpiece.

Re your other points, I was not counting on the mass of the chuck lessening the vibrations; it would be a small addition to mass already in play for that purpose. And I am actually looking to buy a second chuck. I like my Nova Precision Mini, but was considering a G-3 or larger with an insert, which I can move up to a larger lathe someday. Sounds like the G-3 is the way to go.