Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

abrasive walnut?

Posts

abrasive walnut?

#1

abrasive walnut?

GaryG in MD

>I didn't want to hijack Jerry Hall's Easy Rougher thread below So I'll start a fresh one here.

I was turning a "big" walnut blank (literally as big as I can get on my Jet 1236) yesterday, and I found that I had to resharpen my 5/8" bowl gouge quite frequently. What's odd about this is that it's a Doug Thompson CPM-10V (A11) cryo. The first time it happened, I thought something was wrong because the gouge just quit cutting and it was reasonably freshly sharpened. Almost as an afterthought, I resharpened it, and it cut great again, for a short time, and then back to the wheel again.... I've never had this happen before.

There is no evidence of any "grit" in this clean log. So what's going on? Is walnut one of those "hi silica" woods? Or is it just this tree? I don't remember having a problem with it in the past.

TIA, Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#2

Re: abrasive walnut?

Ken

>Thats wierd,I turn walnut all the time and some of its been drying for well over 5 yrs and I use D T gouges and can turn a 15" bowl from start to finish with no problem at all.Is this just one blank or is it happening with several blanks?

Re: abrasive walnut?

#3

Re: abrasive walnut?

John Jordan

>It's very common- walnut can be a joy, or a pita like you have. I have a big one right now, and it's really nice, but it cuts like crap. Dead fresh, straight-grained. The gouge stays dull. A big one like I have is worth the effort, but just barely. If I had another right now, I would get rid of it in a minute-and I will get rid of most of it.

The kind of gouge doesn't matter.

John

Re: abrasive walnut?

#4

Re: abrasive walnut?

john lucas

>Same here. I've turned about 20 feet of walnut logs in the last year and it turns as sweet as can be.

I've had different results with Osage Orange. One log will dull tools really fast and the next one is just hard but still cuts clean.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#5

About 80 years into my last walnut

Jerry Hall

>bowl I noticed a shiny 5/32 circle. No stain or rust. Thought about it for a while and then wondered if that hunter almost a century ago got his buck, grazing under that tree....Didn't seem to bother my gouge edge much tho. But it was a nice connection to a time long past.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#6

Re: abrasive walnut?

GaryG in MD

>John,

Thanks for the confirmation. It's good to know I'm not the only one. Like the others above, my previous experiences with walnut have been good (except for a little end-grain tear out). This piece will dull a DT gouge in a couple passes up the side. It really surprised me. And, yes, that means that this 11.5" x 5.5" blank is going to have me spending nearly as much time at the grinder as at the lathe. It's a pretty piece of wood, so I'll just have to put up with it. Do you have any idea what gets into the wood to cause it?

Looking forward to your visit in October. Come up a day early if you like.

...Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#7

Thanks for your replies...

GaryG in MD

>I guess it's obvious from the replies that some walnut has this property and some/(most?) doesn't. Another interesting data point. Well, I like it too much to give it up, but this one's going to be a pain. I'm trying to work up to making a beauty like the ones Joe Moran turns out. (That'll be the day.) ...Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#8

Re: Thanks for your replies...

Carole Valentine

>Found this on a timber management site not long ago:

"Black Walnut found in the Southeast often has small particles of silica (sand) absorbed from the soil into the wood of the tree. This degrades deep-South Black Walnut and makes it much less valuable than the Midwest variety."

I figured this explains why some walnut I have turned seemed so blasted "hard" and dulled my tools in short order. Maybe what you have is similar.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#9

Re: abrasive walnut?

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Up until two years ago I was turning about a transport truck load of Walnut a year, and I found the same thing. I don't know whether it is just problem of where they grew or if it is genetic. But some logs will cut so beautifully, you think you are a turner like John Jordan. The next one will be so full of silica it will dull a Doug Thompson tool.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#10

Re: abrasive walnut?

Jeff Rich

>I have found the same as others have experienced.

A lot of walnut that I gather is roadside.

I think a lot of the silica content could be from the old gravel roads.

Most of the Walnut will turn pretty good.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#11

Re: abrasive walnut?

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Bill. This is certainly one of the latter. I'm going to go out now a try to turn it into a nice bowl shape. The grinder is ready! ...Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#12

Re: Thanks for your replies...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Carole. I guess that explains it. This tree grew in a church yard in downtown Silver Spring, MD. The soil here is basically red clay, just like in the Southeast. Q.E.D. ...Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#13

Thanks Jeff...

GaryG in MD

>

Re: abrasive walnut?

#14

Re: Thanks Jeff...

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>I am not an expert on tree physiology, but, based upon what I do know, I don't see any way that grains of sand (silica) can be absorbed from the soil and transported up the capillary system of a tree. Sand is insoluble and moving a grain of sand physically would be like sucking a basketball through a soda straw. Besides, what possible reason would there be for a tree to add silica to its structure?

There is a legitimate concern about sand granules being embedded in wood after the wood has laid in contact with sandy soil, but that is much different from sand being added to wood structure internally.

Wood that is hard to cut is probably explained by variations in wood density and grain patterns.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#15

Re: Thanks Jeff...

GaryG in MD

>Emmett,

I know what you mean and agree. That's obviously not the mechanism -- it's not a matter of "granules". I'm no biologist, so I don't understand the mechanism either, but from my various readings, I gather that silicates do get absorbed into the structure of some trees. I guess these silicates must be water soluble.

It's not a matter of the wood being "hard to cut" -- it cuts quite normally, but you can almost feel the edge getting dull. With this piece of walnut, I literally have to resharpen my Doug Thompson CPM-10V every couple cuts, and normally I can turn a whole bowl on maybe one sharpening. This piece has a tiger stripe character going from the sapwood into the hardwood, and I'm wondering if that might have something to do with it.

Thanks for your thoughts, Gary

Re: abrasive walnut?

#16

Re: Thanks Jeff...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Silica can be like fine powder and float in the air, you can even breath it into your lungs without knowing... this is a major health issue in some factories.

Re: abrasive walnut?

#17

Hi Doug...

GaryG in MD

>I think I could turn this walnut into a disc and put it on the grinder to use for sharpening M2 tools! I can feel the CPM-10V getting dull in one pass. That's certainly never happened to me before! That's one of the "beauties" of wood -- as with a box of chocolates, you never know what you're going to find inside. I'll post a photo of the "tiger walnut" that's been doing this when I get it off the camera. ...Gary