Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

Posts

Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#1

Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

Jerry Hall

>I do lots of natural edge bowls, lots of walnut, and bit the bullet based on reading all the feedback and debate on this and other forums over the last year. I was tired at my advanced age of getting beat up in the early stages of roughing out with a gouge, especially since I relocate the centers a lot to get the form and bark reveal I am looking for. This leads to very out of round blanks, even with band saw prep. So I got the ER, and loved it, felt I was cheating. I use a heavy Kelton handle. Hardly know I am cutting. My productivity and comfort is way up. But the $14 cutters were only good for maybe 4-5 bowls with all the bark and dirt. Not worth it to me. The Easy Wood FAQ addresses this as a potential problem (see below.)

So, I found some $1.99 (each) import replacement cutters (package of 10, 4" radius) and they work great. Seem to be as sharp as the $13.99 ones, and so far seem to be as sturdy. They are identical in form, but don't have the faces numbered. I am sure they are of a lessor quality, but are fine for my use.

I very much like the tool and it was well worth the price but for natural edge bowls the cutter is only good for say 4 large bowls. And the way I use it with the points and side edges as part of the cut I really can only turn the cutter once to an effective new face with 2 new sharp corners. With my new cutters it is a good deal, but not at the higher price. At $13.99 for a new cutter I would give up on the tool. I found another USA built source with "micro grain" carbide at $4.50 each in sets of 10 that may be sharper, longer lasting, and comparable in quality, but I doubt it would be anywhere near twice as long lived for the type of work I do.

I find the best use for the ER is to round the outside without beating myself up. Also making the tenon quickly. But once round it is about as fast and easy to use my 5/8 bowl gouge. I also have found that the ER is great for rough leveling the bottom of the bowl, leading only to some touch up with a steep beveled BG and a big scraper. I have found I don't really need to bore a center hole, which saves time. By angling back and forth, with the point leading I can pretty quickly deepen the center of the bowl, and it is easy to knock off the nib as Ellsworth teaches, up and down, left to right.

I would like to support this tool, as it is a real asset. Maybe the cutters can be offered in a range of qualities and quantities at a more economical price.

Here are the comments on the web site re cutter life:

"My cutter doesn't seem to be holding its edge as long as I've heard they do. Why is that?

I can say for sure that the one thing that will take the edge off ANY tool is sand. No way around it. I myself have been disappointed on some walnut blanks' sand content, even way down in the wood. When I get wood like this I have a few choices- I can constantly sharpen my old bowl gouge, or I can flip a few cutters on the Ci1 or at last, I can decide this wood might not be worth it. No one way is right. There are times I just rough the blank round with the Ci1 and then complete the bowl with a HSS gouge. Just whatever I am in the mood for; I like to mix it up a bit to keep it fresh. Sand is the biggest enemy of any cutting edge, so always remove the bark from your bowl blanks before turning."

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#2

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

jwoodwright

>Jerry,

Great review. Who sells the $1.99 cutters? The $4.50 cutters?

Being retired and on a budget, the best deals help. Thank you.

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#3

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

Jerry Hall

>Journal Head Knives with 100mm face radius - 15mm x 15mm x 2.5mm - in boxes of 10. Fits "Byrd" Shelix � Heads. With POINTED corners (not radius) is what I got.

These apparently are a standard item in the jointer/planer machinery industry. Lots of sources. Maybe at your local machinery supply store. Search on the above.

I got mine from Oregon at:

http://globaltooling.bizhosting.com/journal-head-knives.html

The more expensive, micro grain ones seem to be available at:

http://www.dehartusa.com/DeHartWeb/Products/ProductCatalogDetails.aspx?catalog=Catalog&product=SquareKnivesRadiusPointedEdges&l=sg

They have different edge radius, (50 and 150mm) which might be useful too.

Again I think it is essential that you get pointed not radius corners. So if it is not clear call your order in and verify.

Remember, I have only done one bowl with these, so far very good, and this info is worth just what you paid for it. But I figured at the price I didn't have much to lose.

Again, I hope Easy Rougher offers a more financially acceptable set of cutter choices. I would be glad to buy from them even at a somewhat higher price. I am not trying to discourage business from this good outfit. But this is the only way I could continue to use the tool for what I do.

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#4

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

jwoodwright

>Jerry,

Thank you. Still saving for the easy rougher, just looking for better prices on the cutters...

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#5

Can't you sharpen the cutters?

Curly Smith

>I'm wondering why you can't sharpen the cutters? I know the intent of the tool is to eliminate sharpening by using cheap and replaceable carbide cutters, but from the thread it seems that the cutters aren't all that cheap.

Why can't you sharpen them using a Green Silicon Carbide wheel? Norton makes them in 60, 80 and 120 grit and they will sharpen tungsten carbide. Also, if you have a Work Sharp or equivalent unit you might be able to use a silicon carbide sanding disk (available from your local rock shop or online).

The grinding wheels run ~$50, the sanding disks ~$2.

But, if the desire is to avoid sharpening HSS then sharpening carbide won't be an improvement.

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#6

Re: Can't you sharpen the cutters?

Jerry Hall

>Good thoughts on resharpening the critters. I don't know anything about sharpening carbide. But I do know "sharp" is two intersecting equally smooth surfaces. These cutters are almost a mirror finish on both facits, and cut wood like it was butter when fresh. I don't think even the 120 grit silicon carbide grinder will produce a sharp, long lasting edge, but rather a sawtooth effect that would quickly dull due to the unsupported pieces of brittle carbide. Also might be grabby since the tool is 15mm wide, and would still be essentially dull and cutting with power alone. I did try using my 1000 grit Lacer hone to "polish" the facits. A little success but it was not as shiny (or sharp) and it took some practice to follow the 4" radius on the front of the cutter. I haven't given up on honing, but am not optimistic. Regrinding would also require some sort of jig it seems to me. Not hard to imagine what it would look like tho. It's all an experiment! I have no idea what technology is used to sharpen them in the first place, but am curious. I don't mind spending 15 minutes resharpening if it works! Heck, I will be making $8 an hour in savings. That's more than I make wood turning. Maybe some honing compound on a hard mdf wheel with a 4" radius jig might work.

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#7

Re: Can't you sharpen the cutters? *LINK*

Curly Smith

>Rather than honing compound, I'd go with PSA back silicon carbine paper on an MDF disk and some sort of jig. Check your local phone book for "Lapidary Supplies", they will have some silicon carbide paper. Anything that will polish a diamond will polish (or sharpen) tungsten carbide.

relative hardness (moh):

Diamonds = 10

silicon carbide = 9-10

tungsten carbide = 8.5 - 9

For reference, grits available in PSA silicon carbide paper:


PSA Paper Discs - Silicon Carbide

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#8

Now that might be the ticket

Jerry Hall

>Put an 3/4 mdf disk on a true face (face plate, or chuck) slap one of your x000 grit disks on it, make a little 4" radius arm that holds the cutter edge down in a tapped hole, fasten it to a 30 degree (adjustable) tilted platform locked in the lathe ways, and polish away. Probably would need to go from the center of the cutter out, and avoid backing up onto the points. Maybe my disk sander with the adjustable table and miter slot to index the jig would be worth a try, if it could be set up accurately enough. Sharpening a bunch of cutters at a time would most likely go fast and last a while. The polishing of a cutter would remove little material and preserve the cutter's relationship with the tool bar.

Might give it a try, but at 25 cents a bowl for a new cutter might not. Time will tell.

Good discussion and ideas. Maybe the ER folk will invent a sharpener and sell that!

Re: Easy Rougher - Natural Edge Bowl Comments FWIW

#9

Re: Now that might be the ticket

Curly Smith

>I noticed this afternoon that my 1500 grit "sandpaper" from the Auto Parts Store is silicon carbide. You might check your supply of paper to see if you already have what you need to test whether or not you'll be able to sharpen the cutters.

FWIW, my 400, 600 and 800 grit are all Aluminum Oxide. I was unable to determine what the 1000 grit is made from but if you have some 3M Wetordry Sandpaper #03013 1000 Grit then it's silicon carbide.