Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

Posts

Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#1

Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

Sean Troy

>How important is it to you as a turner to finish the inside of a hollow form? I know the old saying, "if you can feel it with your finger, you should finish it" has been talked about a lot but how much do you think it really makes any difference to a potential buyer? Here is why I ask. I recently sold a hollow form to someone, the HF had been dyed and lacquered to a very high gloss. The buyer said they probably would not have bought it if they didn't see the bare wood and some tool marks on the inside to prove it was real wood. Normally I try and finish as much of the inside as I can but this got me to wondering if all that work is really all that important. What's your thoughts and experience on this topic? Thanks, Sean

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#2

Re:I use the Ellsworth method, of .......

Jamie Donaldson

>.. making a sincere effort to smooth out most of the visable humps with a scraper, but no big effort at sanding/finishing. Of course it helps that David makes most of his openings too small for a finger! I follow those same examples, but not often to the tiny openings that David magically achieves!

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#3

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Sean, my approach to the inside of a hollow form is to get the inside walls as smooth as I can, then, if the opening is small, I apply the same finish as the exterior. If my opening is larger, I usually add a collar and paint the interior walls with black gesso. I usually put a 1/2" hole in a collar so very few fingers will fit.

keithz

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#4

The TD method

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Terry Daniels used to put small sized gravel in his HF's, tape the opening shut and put it on a low rpm for a few hours on the lathe, letting the tumbling of the stones finish the inside, best method I have ever heard of, LOL...

take care,

Jim

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#5

Steven Antonucci

It's finished when I stop cutting

steve antonucci

>Like others, a small hole will prohibit other turners from jamming their fingers inside to comment about wall smoothness. Anyone who sands the interior of a vessel has way too much time on their hands, with the exception of those vessels with voids where the insides are visible.

On larger openings, I do a "finger quality sanding" only- meaning it feels smooth, but may still have sanding scratches that cannot be seen by normal means. If I am worried about the interior, I paint it with black gesso.

Steve

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#6

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Jamie Donaldson

>...is that it leaves a gray sludge or coating of imbedded rock dust inside the vessel, and it's not at all appealing.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#7

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Russ Fairfield

>The gray sludge Jamie mentioned, plus the wood I use always has a soft spot where the rocks wear through.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#8

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>TD used a dry method with granite road gravel. He cobbled up bearings and a shaft at about 45� from horizontal. The shaft held a chuck that would hold the HF. A riding lawn mower transmission and spare motor finished the rig, similar to a rock tumbler. I furnished him with some scrap ceramic grit(no longer available) that cut the process time by several days. He was getting promissing results about the time he dropped off the internet.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#9

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Guess you need to stop before the soft spot wears out.. ??

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#10

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I got a slow turning motor and set up a rig in the garage to use TD's method. I was real disappointed when I got the gray dust too. I used the rocks that were put on our driveway. I never got the smooth surface that TD got.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#11

I am with you on that, Steve.

Norm Smith

>

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#12

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Don at Central Illinois

>What if you washed the rocks first. The gray sludge, I think, would disappear, if you washed it off first. Just my .02 worth.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#13

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Actually if you used rocks with high silica (quartz) content you would not get the grey powdering. A lot of sedimentary rock has a matrix composition that can be of a silt nature, limestone and slates easily decompose into a find silt like powder. Most rocks with high silica in them will not do that, so it does depend on what you choose, selecting rocks of a granitic nature would be different, but what do I know??

:-)

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#14

Steve Kubien

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Steve Kubien

>How about going to your local sand-blaster and getting a few handfuls of silica sand?

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#15

Dick Hines

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Dick Hines

>I sand the inside around the opening and down as far as someone's finger can reach. Deeper than that I try to get all the highs and lows out. I dump in some Watco and roll the hollow form around to coat the inside. Then finish the out side.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#16

not sanding the inside

john lucas

>I sand open vessels that I can stick my hand in. I know David Ellsworth, John Jordan and a few other big name people don't sand the inside. That's good enough for me.

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#17

Re:The problem with that TD method....

Don Evans

>There are better blasting medium for the job IMO, one is "glass beads" other would be "walnut shell" both available where blasting supplies sold.

Don

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#18

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

John Jordan

>The inside should be appropriate to the piece. On a piece with a small opening, there's no advantage to sanding the inside, it does not improve the piece, and the only person who would care would be another woodturner. It should be done as smooth and even as your skills will allow-relatively smooth and even, tools marks are appropriate, big lumps and ridges are not.

If the inside becomes visually part of the piece, then a sanded surface may be appropriate. Being visually part of the piece is NOT the same as being able to see inside if you try. Nothing is worse than a piece that is half-assed sanded inside.

I only use 3/16" tips and get the pieces relatively smooth and even. What helps the most besides a FRESHLY SHARPENED cutter is a smooth tool rest with something to lubricate the tool/rest. I clean and polish the rest each morning with sandpaper and WD40, and before the finish cuts, wipe the tool shank and toolrest with a block of parrafin or beeswax. This allows the small smooth.even movements that result in a good surface. Try it.

John

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#19

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

fredbear34

>"What helps the most besides a FRESHLY SHARPENED cutter is a smooth tool rest with something to lubricate the tool/rest. I clean and polish the rest each morning with sandpaper and WD40, and before the finish cuts, wipe the tool shank and toolrest with a block of parrafin or beeswax. This allows the small smooth.even movements that result in a good surface."

This may seem obvious to a lot of the experienced folks here, but it smacked me right up side of my head as something that I was neglecting, and thank you for making this point.

Fred

Re: Finishing the insides of Hollow Forms

#20

Re: A nice smooooooooth tool rest.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... surface is a feature that I really like with the new Robust Comfort Rests. The hard steel rod stays very smooth, and a bit of wax is generally all that needed to make tools glide right across!