I client has asked me to make them a bowl but doesn't want anything refined (right in my wheelhouse!). They want it to look old. So, I am thinking I will get the best finish I can off my tools and then...
In the days before sand paper, I believe turners and bodgers used shavings as sand paper. Am I correct on this? The bowl will be in soft, silver maple. What about burnishing it with something harder like ash or hickory? There will be no finish on it except perhaps some wax.
>Actually burnishing with the back of the gouge will bring up a nice shine. I do that on tops that I just hand out to the kids with no finish. A nice shear scrape will really level it out before the burnish. I wonder though, maybe they want to see gouge lines. Maybe they like the idea that potters have been using forever. Show that the pot was hand thrown with really course lines. I'd show them some google images of pottery to see how rough they want it. A paper grocery sack will also smooth/burnish the wood. I've seen guys say that the paper is about 400-600 grit.
>Steve Shaving just burnish the surface and helps get rid of little fibers sticking up. My mother had bowl from around 1900 and you could see that it was turned at high speed and tool marks were just left in the bowl. The grooves were very fine and close together.
I think just turning it and burnishing with the shavings would work just fine. I have read that early woodworkers used a type of weed for sandpaper and even sharkskin. Doubt they have a lot of sharks up your way however.
>I've seen "rustic" turnings in home decor type places that looked just like my fastest rough out bowls - thick walls, heavy gouge spirals, and splits. I've also seen them in clients homes, so they do sell that way. You might not worry about trying to get a great finish - just shape it and let it be.
I am a big fan of the no sand bowls. I met a guy at the Ann Arbor Street fair that had some very cool bowls. They were not sanded at all and had a really nice finish to them. It was really nice to pick them up and see how bowls were made when polished finish was not the fad. It was made for use and was very cool to me.
But is you need some nuke fish to do the finish... here is a good place to start. :)
>Equisetum arvense (scouring rush or horsetail) should grow in Ontario, you just need to look for it. I recall a video on the woodworking channel of a Japanese woodturner making wooden dolls; he used Equisetum to polish them before painting the features.
>Bob is correct - Equisetum is an ancient group of primitive plants with about 15 species, worldwide. They are often called "scouring rushes" (although not even remotely related to true rushes) because they are often found in moist areas adjacent to lakes and streams where pioneers and campers would often clean their pots and pans, which needed to be scoured. The high silica content in their stems makes them very durable and abrasive. These plants are sometimes also called "horsetails", and can sometimes also be found along railroad right-of-ways, and in farm fields as a noxious weed.
Although somewhat delicate, Equisetum arvense may be used, however the thicker stems of Equisetum hyemale would be preferred as a woodturning abrasive. Some of the Japanese demonstrators that were at the Portland AAW Symposium a few years ago used Equisetum stems (which I saw were from E. hyemale) when finishing some of their turnings (including the painted dolls called 'Kokeshi'). The stems should be cut to a convenient length (what I saw were pieces between 4 and 8 inches in length) and dried completely. The hollow stems will collapse upon drying, and these can be stored indefinitely.
I've tried sanding with Equisetum, and while it does work to a degree, you won't see me giving up my aluminum oxide abrasives any time soon. I suppose it would be equivalent to about 150 to 220 grit, at least using the plants I got from a huge patch of E. hyemale near our Little League Fields. I now bring some dried Equisetum stems to show as an example of a natural abrasive when I give my 'Woodworking Abrasives' talk.
BTW - Sharkskin has been used historically in finishing some woods, but it is fairly ineffective as a wood abrasive, so I wouldn't spend too much time following that lead....I understand it was much more widely used in polishing metals.