Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Presentation & Preservation

Posts

Presentation & Preservation

#1

Presentation & Preservation

charlie belden

>I was married to a picture framer. She had a pet peeve about a significant shortcoming in the college curriculum of art colleges - NOTHING, or almost nothing, was taught on Presentation or Preservation.

The nicest painting - on a piece of fine water color paper, or on a stretched canvas - - SHOULD NOT be the end point for the artist. With good mat selection - color/texture - layers - border width, etc., and the right frame - even a fair to middlin piece can be made more attractive and pleasing on the eye. Presentation - good presentation - can make or break even the best works.

And when it came to Preservation . . .

A beautiful water color - on paper that wasn't acid free - would drive her up the wall.

"Those beautiful colors - will lose their color in a year or two - and will be lost in 20 years."

If the frame had glass - glass touching the piece, or its mat - NEVER!

Is the back of the framed piece sealed off - with acid free paper? If not it should be.

UV glass? Helps - but any piece exposed to light, especially direct sunlight - WILL fade (ok so Cherry wood gets darker).

In the turning world Presentation and Preservation seems to be almost totally overlooked.

A really nice platter turned perfectly of a fantastic piece of wood with wonderful subtle details and a finish to die for - displayed in a so-so if not downright ugly stand - and displayed where all you see is reflections of the space in which it resides - the finish acting as a mirror.

An unebelievably thin walled hollow form placed on the mantle - of a fireplace - that's used often.

A segmented piece with a fascinating pattern or shape - directly in the air flow path of the heating and cooling system duct outlet.

A delicatly pierced piece - set too high to see - or reach - up in the place where hot air rises and stays.

A display shelf - filled with gorgeous little lidded boxes - ALL sitting directly on the shelf - all their bottoms at the same level.

CA glue. Amazing stuff. How long it will do what it's doing now - holding this to that - or acting as a high gloss finish - who knows. It hasn't been in use long enough to tell. Will it crack and crackle?

What will it do to the wood - over 20 or 30 years?

That necklace stand - with the 30 pieces - held together with glue? What happens if one of its elements should break off? Could it be repaired/restored - wthout a lot of time and effort - or at all?

If you've thought about Presentation and/or Preservation - what have you come up with that others might benefit by becoming aware of it?

What questions do you have about these subjects?

Suggestions, comments, insights?

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#2

Very Interesting Issue

Thad

>I hope to learn some things from this thread.

I may be wrong, butI think that the issue gets complicated even more (compared to framed art at least) when considering the fact that turnings will be handled significantly more often, and less delicately than gallery paintings.

~ Thad

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#3

Great topic

David Belser

>I think it is really two topics -

Presentation & Preservation under the control of the creator/maker and Presentation & Preservation as preformed by the collector.

As a maker, I am much more interested in the first. We make such important decisions in the way we create and finish work, decisions that will have a huge impact in the long term.

I try to use finishes and glues that are repairable. Lacquer or oil & wax. I used to use CA glue but now limit my use and prefer yellow (tight bond) for permanent joints. I'll use hide glue if I think I might need to disassemble in the future.

I'm really interested in the color aging of the exotics that people are using, particularly in segmented turning. I don't most of these works just turn brown in time? I'd like to see some 20 - 30 year old segmented turnings!

This would make an excellent rotation topic at a symposium.

Some day I'll have enough of a collection to worry about that side of it.

I look forward to what others have to say.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#4

Re: Very Interesting Issue

john lucas

>Charlie as a photographer this has been in my mind since the beginning. Trying to make a photo archival has been a forever search.

When I started working wood, the color change was very apparent. I remember making a mirror out of Padauk and left it laying in the sun on the kitchen table. The color change was dramatic. I started doing more reading on that.

I started my turning career with segmented work. I cut and glued wood at any angle I could with no thought of the glue I used or the wood movement problems. I got lucky because most of my pieces were small. I went to a John Jordan demo very early on and he discussed wood movement. I started looking at the problems with my segmented work and the few pieces that had self distructed and realized that it was movement of the wood that broke the joints.

I believe it was Richard Raffen who said, in the long run it will all be barnwood. In other words form is critical because the color will change, it may take 100 years but it will change.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#5

Re: Very Interesting Issue

Barry Irby

>I think it is interesting that many things we know about the very distant part of history we know because we have books and pictures. The Paper and papyrus, and whatever have survived longer than the objects. Without this "written" record there are many things we would know little or nothing about. To be fair, some of the images are carved into stone. We have pictures of things that long since disappeared.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#6

Steven Antonucci

Control what you can control...

steve antonucci

>and manage the rest...

I purposely do not "high finish" my pieces. Aside from not liking "shiny wood", it requires a lot more thought for both the artist and the owner.

In the end, the basic facts are simple- the more people have to do to maintain something, the more rules there are, the higher the probablity that you will get a failure. Can't have a glue joint fail if there aren't glue joints...

I saw two Moultrop pieces in the lobby of a local insurance company, and both of them had finishes flaking off. It doesn't matter why or how or whose fault it might have been- they both needed help. Large pieces move more than small pieces.

Do what you can, and don't worry about whether or not someone will have your piece in a temperature controled environment. After all, it won't matter if a tornado comes through their neighborhood...

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Control what you can control...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Steve, I believe those pieces were treated with PEG, then a hard finish applied. Not much wants to stick to wood treated with PEG (polyethelene glycol) Similarly, I suspect that pieces given a coat of sanding sealer then oiled will suffer a similar effect.

Wood coated with raw linseed oil or "lemon oil" will turn black over time. Interesting, I bought finishing supplies from Lily Chemical back in the early 70's. I was asked to try a new product they were coming out with, a polyurethane oil, and give an evaluation. I still have an oak jewelry box I finished with that product....36 years old, and still looks new.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#8

Re: Control what you can control...

charlie belden

>"All woods, eventually, end up brown - except - ebony, african blackwood, boxwood, some myrtle, and of course black walnut, which starts out brown."

"Wood moves - no matter what you do to prevent it from moving. But it does move LESS in one direction and more in others."

"A mirror finish - is shiny and pretty - AND it shows every smudge and fingerprint - AND won't stay a a 'mirror finish" after a while."

"Wax can make things shiny - for a while. Then another application of wax - following by polishing is required"

"Poly is a great finish - unless you have to repair the finish. 'Hot' finishes, like shellac and lacquer, on the other hand, are fairly easy to repair - are as easy to apply - and result in a nice finish as well."

"Not all finishes will stick to other things - like another finish or paint. What you put on BEFORE the final surface finish IS important."

"Bright primary colors - will become pastel like - when exposed to light long enough."

"What a piece is sitting on and where it is placed can mean the difference between being Lost In The Crow - and OUTSTANDING."

"Almost any turned object, especially small objects, when viewed from a high angle - looks kind of boring."

"If a piece you made requires special Care and Feeding - print up the Care and Feeding Instructions and either put it IN the piece and let the new owner know it's there - or - make sure the new owner receives a copy. Using those instructions then becomes THEIR reponsibility."

"ALL pieces, unless encased in glass, WILL collect dust. Imagine dusting a Bin Pho piece, or some of Andi Wolfe's delicate little carved pieces."

"People keep our pieces in their homes - which are typically made of wood. Make sure any creatures that are in the wood you sold them - are DEAD."

"Dewaxed shellac is a much maligned, and incorrectly so, finish - that comes in a range of colors - from almost "water clear" to amber, to orange and even garnet."

"Drying agents don't always result in 'dry' - and often are kind of toxic."

"Tung oil - real Tung Oil - is extracted from the seeds of the Tung Tree. Most 'tung oil' finishes have very little actual Tung Oil. Oh - and BTW - the tung is pronounced dung - in chinese - but don't mention that to the person buying the piece that has the Tung Oil finish - the mental exercise dealing with that can cause injury - or death."

More Present & Preserve please.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#9

Ellis Walentine

Presentation of turned pieces

Ellis Walentine

>Charlie, thanks for raising a really thought-provoking issue. Part of the reason it is interesting, as you say, is that it is something we are not conditioned to think about. Your observations are excellent, by the way, and should be part of everyone's design awareness. I hope we can come up with some more.

Thinking aloud here, the idea of presentation got me thinking about how my turnings are displayed in our house, which is badly. Every available horizontal surface is cluttered with them -- mantles, side tables, the credenza, the window sills, even the top of the corner cupboard. I say clutter, because that is what they're reduced to when there are so many visual stimuli competing for attention in the same eyeball. At one point, we cleared off the sofa table and chose just a few pieces to display there, and the effect was profound. You could really focus in on the worthwhile (such as it is) attributes of each of the pieces, without the visual white noise of a bunch of other pieces crowded around it. Now, if I can just do the same for all the other cluttered areas....

Ellis

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#10

Which side is UP?

Russ Fairfield

>Here are some thoughts on something we don't often think about when we present our turnings for others to see.

Displaying our works

Which side is UP?

The question �Which side is UP?� was asked about a burl for hanging on a wall.

Presentation is important; and that makes the location of the "hook" for hanging anything on a wall important. This concern for presentation also applies to things like pocket watches, pendants and earrings; and things as different as plates, platters, and bowls. It can make the difference between a fantastic piece of art and just another piece of wood; and that difference can mean $$$'s if we are selling it.

There are many ways to display a piece of wood. The following are the guides that I use for displaying a piece of wood for viewing.

The �Rules�

I use 4 simple rules for locating the "hook" on a piece of wood. If you don't believe me, break any one of these rules and see if that one is selected over another that obeyed all the rules, even though it may have the better grain picture.

Plan Ahead. The application of these rules has to start long before we put a piece of wood in the lathe, whether that selection is made with a chainsaw, or choosing a piece of wood from the pile or shelf.

The 1st Rule:

All curved lines, or any general curvature in the overall wood pattern or shape, should open upward. Any curvature that opens downward will have the appearance of sadness or of spilling its contents. In other words, any "U" shape of the grain pattern should open upward like a �smile� rather than downward like a �frown�.

The 2nd Rule:

The center of gravity of the wall hanging should be below the horizontal center of the piece. In other words, it should appear to be stable, and not look like it is ready to roll over from the weight being on top. A little rocking is OK, but not a roll-over.

The 3rd Rule:

Any dark or highly figured area should be located anywhere but on the bottom or the top. At the bottom it has the appearance of "heaviness" and that it fell under its own weight. Put it on the top, and it has the appearance of being unstable and ready to fall. Anywhere in between these extremes will "work". Diagonal is always best, but if that cannot be used, go for the more stable appearance of the bottom location.

The 4th Rule:

Straight lines should be vertical. Diagonal works, but NEVER horizontal.

Slightly curved lines can be horizontal when they follow the First Rule for an upward curvature.

Whenever one or more of the Rules are in conflict, you will have to determine which are the dominant factors, shape, grain lines, or color; and look for a general appearance. Always be prepared to change when nobody else agrees with you. That may mean not making the "hook" a permanent attachment to the piece until after it is sold. Screw holes are hard to disguise when we got it wrong.

Plates and Platters

All of these rules will also apply to plates and platters, from the orientation of grain in the form when it is turned, to how we place the piece on the table for the viewer to see it. Rotating a platter as it is seen on the table or held in a vertical stand can make the difference between it selling or going back home at the end of the day.

Bowls

Since the only difference between a platter and a bowl is its depth, these same rules apply to the location of a dominant coloring or grain figure in a bowl. Using them before we cut the bowl blank from the tree, or put it in the lathe, can make the difference between a bowl that sells and one that doesn�t.

The �rules� should also be used to determine how the bowl is placed on the table for viewing. Rotating the bowl to obey �the rules� as seen by the viewer from the front of the table can influence whether they buy it or keep looking.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#11

Ladies - we need HELP

charlie belden

>Russ obviously has thought about Presentation and his observations / rules are a great example of "Of course. That's so obvious - once someone else has pointed it out."

I think there's a Guy Thing that we have to get around when it comes to presenting our pieces. If appearance / presentation is important, most women have an innate awareness of what doesn't look right - and how to make it look better, what goes with what - and what doesn't, and are very good at illusion / camouflage. And this ability kicks in at a very early age.

My grandson, now age 6, usually appears to have Dressed In The Dark - nothing he's wearing "goes together" - he is often seen wearing two different shoes. His little sister - she goes through her dresser looking for just the right combination of things that she thinks, and is invariably correct, will look nice together.

Still don't believe me?

Next time you're at the Mall, look in the Men's Section of any clothing store - and note the number of colors and styles of men's shirts - INCLUDING T-shirts.

Now go over to the Women's Section and do the same for blouses AND tops. While you're in the Women's Section, note the range of colors and variety of blouse styles and all the different fabric patterns. Now go back to the Men's Section and compare what you see there vs what you saw in the Women's Section.

Given the limited number of choices, guys STILL hate to go shopping for clothes, especially if they go with their wives. Women on the other hand . . . (which may be why guys who are married typically look more Presentable - at functions they attend with their spouse). "You're not leaving the house wearing THAT!"

Sure would be helpful - for us guys - if some women would jump into this discussion with some Do and Don't Do advice.

Ellis brought up the issue of More Is Not Always Better - probably one of the most common of a turner's blind spot. You can overdose on a room full of Goyas or Van Goughs - but one, maybe two, - sited well - and lit nicely . . .

Rather than display EVERY piece at the same time, why not have a diplayed pieces rotation - only one, maybe two pieces per display surface - maybe all with some commonality (shape or form, type of wood, color of wood, grain of wood) for coherence, or significantly different to provide some juxtaposition / contrast.

What about using pedestals, stands and bases to set one piece off from another - a mini-environment for each piece. Oriental sculpture - be it a bronze casting, clay piece or even an interesting, evocative rock/stone - typically has a separate base that lifts the piece out of its surroundigs - and sets it off. A simple rectangle of wood, with a black lacquer finish or maybe a dark semi-gloss or matte finish, to provide the base of the implied space for the piece resting on it, or maybe appearing to rise from it - or firmly fixed solidly to it.

Clay Foster is a great example of Presentation. In a filled Instant Gallery, his pieces stand out, and not just because his turnings are unusual. He stages his pieces for the effect he's after - quiet and contemplative - or - bold and provoking, massive looking in spite of their actual size.

OK - so much for vaguery and esoteria. Let's have some concrete suggestions!

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#12

The woman's perspective IS important.

Russ Fairfield

>We too often forget who is our customer, and that women buy a lot more of our stuff than men. Rarer yet is the woodturner who buys anything from us.

Re: Presentation & Preservation

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Back to preservation.

Lyle Jamieson

>Dont forget the importance of UNIFORM wall thickness. Over the years of stress from moisture changes the uniform wall thickness will allow the wood to move not crack. I found out with my torso series shipped to different climates all over the country. My uniform walled torsos were fine but my stands fell apart from the stress.

This leads to tool talk. The laser is a huge help to get the bottom half of the hollow form the same thickness as the top half. And what about the true bottom under the waste from the chuck or faceplate (in my case). Spend a little more time to get the bottom uniform with the sidewalls. Do this for two reasons. First, the drying and cracking danger is reduced. Second, when the prospective buyer picks it up, does it feel right, balanced, and consistent with the shape and rim thichness?? If not, chances are you have lost a sale. Is it functional or light and fragile?? Send a consistent message with your shape and wall thickness to the viewer for a more pleasing response.